Sawyer caught the second girl, and picked her up, too. It was easier with two adults. They weren’t outnumbered, and Olivia seemed more natural with the girls than Sawyer was.
“What’s your name?” Olivia asked brightly.
“Bella.”
“Yeah, you’re Bella?”
“Bella.”
Sawyer looked at the toddler in his arms. “Hey, Lizzie,” he said softly.
“Daddy...”
Sawyer looked over at Olivia, his heart speeding up. “Did we just do it?”
“I think we know who’s who,” she agreed.
“Okay, don’t put her down,” Sawyer said, waggling a finger at Olivia. “We’re finding a marker.”
“That was a joke,” she laughed.
“It was a good idea. I need to tell them apart.”
Sawyer led the way up the steps and into the side door of the ranch house. He might not remember much, but he did have a mental picture in his mind of a junk drawer of some sorts that had a big felt-tipped marker inside. He looked around the kitchen, unsure of where to start, so he began at the first drawer he saw, pulling it open, then closing it when it wasn’t the right one. On the fifth drawer, he found it.
“There we go.” He pulled out the marker with a grin. “If there were a mother I’d have to explain myself to, I might be a little more worried. But I’m their dad, right?”
“So I’ve been told,” she replied with a small smile.
“Yeah, well, as their dad, I figure telling them apart is pretty important. I need something that won’t just wash off.”
“Okay.”
“So I’m making a responsible parenting decision here.” He held up the marker, watching her for a reaction.
“You’re their dad,” she said with a nod. “It’s your call.”
While he didn’t remember anything about them, being their father still mattered. In fact, as confused as he was, focusing on being their father had been what had held him together so far.
Sawyer pulled off the cap and took Lizzie’s hand. He wrote a small L on the back of her hand, and then blew on it to dry the ink. Lizzie looked down at her hand in curiosity, and he put her down on the kitchen floor, then reached for Bella’s hand. She held hers out happily, and he wrote a small B.
Bella pursed her lips to try and blow, and he laughed, then blew on her hand to make sure the ink was dry.
“There,” he said. “That’s one problem solved.”
It felt good—a victory. Olivia put Bella down, and the girls scampered off to a bucket of toys in the corner and dumped it out. He watched them for a moment... It still felt unreal that he was a father and that these little girls were actually his.
“What was I like?” he asked, glancing toward Olivia.
“You were serious,” Olivia said. “And stubborn. Really stubborn. You knew what you wanted and you didn’t let anything get in your way. You wanted to help your uncle grow this ranch—you thought you could double the herd size with the right support.”
“Hmm.” A goal. He liked the sound of that. “How did you and I know each other?”
“We met at the diner where I was working. We just kind of...clicked. It went from there.”
“And you live in town still?” he asked.
“No, I moved for college,” she said. “Right after you got married. I live in Billings now. I work at the hospital there.”
He frowned slightly, taking her in—the tangled curls, the soft brown eyes, the pink in her cheeks. “What was my wife like?”
Olivia’s expression froze, and then she glanced away.
“Perfect for you,” she replied. “Mia loved horses and cattle. She wanted a ranch life. And she was quiet enough to balance you out.”
“I take it you didn’t want the ranch life like we did,” he said. “Since you moved.”
“I wanted...” She looked around the kitchen, her gaze turning inward. “I didn’t want to stick around Beaut. I guess I just wanted more.” She winced. “That sounds insulting. I don’t mean it to be. I just didn’t want a rural life. I wanted a new start. I wanted...streetlights and a nightlife, and more people. I was tired of living in a place where everyone knew my personal business, or thought they did.”
She was beautiful, but it wasn’t her looks that kept his eyes riveted to her. There was something there, just beneath the surface, that he could almost remember. He hadn’t felt that about any of the other people from his forgotten life that he’d met so far. But he had a foggy memory—a black coat and a woman facing away from him. He put out his hand and touched her. She turned—
Then nothing. He couldn’t get any more of it, but it felt connected to her. Or was the memory of his wife and talking to a woman bringing it back? He couldn’t tell. Not remembering was a strange weight. He was sad—or was that sadness some part of a memory that he couldn’t place, like the woman in the black coat? He wished he knew. It was confusing and frustrating. All he had was these shards of memory that didn’t fit anywhere, and sadness so deep that it made his chest sore.
“Will you help me to remember it?” he asked quietly. “That life with my wife. My daughters.”
“I wasn’t here for most of that part,” she said with a quick shake of her head.
“Right...” So she might not be able to help with that as much as he’d hoped, but still, when he looked at her, that memory of the coat kept brushing so close that he could almost touch it. “What about our friendship? I have a feeling that you mattered to me, too.”
Olivia blinked up at him and she opened her mouth to say something, then stopped.
“Did you matter to me?” he asked. He needed to know that much.
She nodded. “Yes. But Mia was the one who deserved you.”
What did that mean? He was about to ask, but then one of the toddlers threw a
