She held an umbrella above her head, shielding herself from the worst of the storm. The canopy blocked her view of the street above. I stood unnoticed, watching as she sifted through the rubble. Piled like flotsam at the base of the embankment were several blackened items she had already rescued, including an ornate ceramic platter that her mother had given us on our wedding day, two china cups, and Tom’s division-championship football trophy-its plastic base now gone, the brass figure partially melted. Next to the trophy lay a piece of Nate’s skateboard and one of the champagne glasses Catheryn had brought back from Venice. Leaning down, she plucked another vestige from the ash, a large silver serving spoon that had been part of our family dinners for as long as I could remember.
She added it to the pile.
Soaking wet by then, I watched as Catheryn moved to an area that had once been the music room. She knelt beside the skeletal frame of Travis’s piano, its wire-strung bass and treble bridges barely visible beneath a pile of half-burned joists. Head down, she groped in the cinders. Then she stood, holding something she had pulled from the ashes.
A blast of wind ripped at the umbrella in Catheryn’s hand. She fought to maintain her grip, turning toward the gust. As she did, she glanced up, noticing me. She stared briefly, then lowered her head.
It took me painful minutes to hobble down the crumbling slope. Once on the beach, my crutches proved nearly useless in the sand. Grimacing, I resorted to hopping on one foot, trying not to jar the cast on my leg.
When I finally joined Catheryn, she was examining the most recent object she’d retrieved from the debris. It was the neck of her cello. The scroll had somehow survived, one ebony tuning peg still in the peg box, the scorched tailpiece hanging from a metal string. Not knowing what to say, I stood silently. “Are the kids all right?” I asked at last.
Catheryn nodded.
“They’re still at your mom’s?”
Again, Catheryn nodded. She appeared drained, exhausted. Wearily, she studied the stitches running the length of my right cheek. She started to touch my face, then withdrew her hand.
“Only hurts when I smile,” I said. “Not a big problem right now. The doc says it’ll probably spoil my good looks, though,” I added ruefully.
“And your leg?”
“It’s going to be okay, Kate. I may need some reconstructive surgery later, but I’ll be fine.”
“I’m glad.” Numbly, Catheryn let the pieces of her ruined cello slip from her fingers.
“Get any sleep?” I asked.
“Not much.”
“Me, neither. Kate, about last night-”
“I don’t want to talk about that.”
“But-”
“Not now; not ever,” Catheryn said firmly. She hesitated, then went on. “Dan, I’m sorry about some of the things I’ve said to you recently. You were right when you told me I didn’t understand your world. Even after all the years we were together, I never really understood. Maybe I didn’t want to. Now I do, and I’m sorry about that, too. As for what I did last night… I want to forget it.”
I nodded. “I understand.” I poked the ashes with one of my crutches. “We can rebuild,” I said, changing the subject.
Catheryn didn’t respond.
“The place was insured. It’ll be tough, but we can do it. It’ll be better than before.”
“I don’t think so.”
“Why not?”
“It isn’t as easy as that,” Catheryn replied. “You know, I’ve always thought that a family whose members loved one another could weather anything. But now…”
With a heavy heart, I realized she was speaking of more than wood and shingles. “Whatever we’ve lost, we can replace,” I said.
“Not this time.” Catheryn turned toward me with an expression of profound sadness. “That was a brave thing you did last night.”
I shook my head. “No. If anything, it was selfish. When I got here and saw what was happening, I realized something. I realized that if I lost you, I didn’t want to go on living.”
“Dan, I don’t-”
“Kate, let me say this. It’s something I’ve had inside me for a long time. I want to get it off my chest.”
Catheryn gazed out over the angry Pacific without replying.
“It’s no secret I’ve never been much good at expressing how I feel,” I pressed on. “I’ve been so wrong about so many things, I don’t know where to begin. I’ll probably get this all jumbled up, but here goes. Kate, when Tommy-”
“Don’t, Dan. I was at fault too, but nothing you can say now will make any difference.”
“I know. But I need to say it anyway. Will you listen?”
“Dan…”
“Please,” I begged. I took a deep breath and plunged ahead. “When Tom died, a hole opened inside me that I couldn’t fill. Not with you, or with the kids, or with work-no matter how hard I tried. And I made a terrible mistake. I know that now. I shut you out. I shut out everyone and everything and let the ache grow until nothing could ease it. Then, when I thought I was losing you to Arthur, it seemed as though my whole world had come apart.”
“There was never anyone but you,” said Catheryn, still staring out over the roiling waters.
“I know. I should never have doubted you,” I said miserably. “I also know that there are things for which saying I’m sorry will never make right. I am so deeply ashamed and disappointed in myself for what happened between Lauren and me, and I don’t expect your forgiveness. But Kate, I would give anything to go back and do things over. Every day I don’t see you, I feel so empty I don’t want to go on. Last night when I thought I was going to die, the one regret that kept coming back to me was that I hadn’t told you how I feel about you in such a long time. You’re the only real thing in my life, Kate. You, and our children. Without you, nothing else means anything. On Christmas day when I said I didn’t know the meaning of the word love, I was wrong. I knew it the first time I saw you, and I’ve known it every day since.”
Catheryn turned, tears gathering in her eyes.
“I also know how deeply I’ve hurt you,” I continued. “I’m sorry, Kate. I’m so sorry. I know things can never be the same between us, but I’m hoping that-”
Shaking her head, Catheryn raised her fingers to my lips.
Before she could speak, I took her hand. “Please don’t give up on us. Don’t answer now. Just think about it.” I reached into my jacket. “I’ve been carrying this around for the past couple of days, hoping I would have the chance to give it to you.”
Catheryn looked down at the object in my hand. It was my Christmas present to her, the one she had refused-the ribbon coming unraveled now, the wrapping wrinkled and torn.
“Take it,” I said, offering her the crumpled package. “I got this before… before everything happened, so I’ll understand if you don’t want it. But Kate, I’m hoping you’ll keep it. Whatever you decide.” I took the umbrella and held it over her, then placed the present in her hands. “Open it. Please.”
Slowly, Catheryn untied the ribbon and removed the paper, revealing a small ebony box. Inside, on a cushion of velvet, lay an antique emerald pendant. Though the green stone was modest and the setting unassuming, I could tell from Catheryn’s expression that she understood the meaning of my gift. I handed back her umbrella, then withdrew the pendant from its box and fastened the delicate silver chain around Catheryn’s neck.
A gust howled off the water, carrying a spray of stinging rain and the musty smells of the sea. Like an angry demon, the wind tore at the umbrella in Catheryn’s hands, ripping the canopy. Within seconds lashing rain soaked through her clothes, plastering them to her body. Letting the tattered umbrella drop to her feet, Catheryn raised a hand to touch the pendant. Then she lifted her eyes to mine. In a voice filled with heartache, she asked, “A new beginning? Do you mean it?”
I held her gaze, not looking away, even for an instant. “With all my heart,” I answered. “I want our family to
