A Necessary Evil

putting together a piece for the paper that involves the Omaha Archdiocese. It involves O'Sullivan.'

She got his attention, just like she wanted. He couldn't help wondering if this was what Tony couldn't talk about.

'Involves the archdiocese in what exactly?' he asked, pretending it really didn't matter to him.

'What else? The same thing that's been plaguing the Catholic Church all over the country for the last several years.'

'You're saying Monsignor O'Sullivan's been abusing boys?'

'Keep it down,' Christine whispered, getting up from the porch swing to glance inside the house. 'If Mom found out I was working on something that might go against the church, she'd be lighting candles for the salvation of my soul for weeks.' Satisfied that their mother wasn't listening at the door, she leaned against the porch rail and took a sip of her beer before she continued. 'A lot of what we have right now is considered speculation and rumor, because no one's willing to go on the record.'

'Maybe no one's willing to go on the record because it is speculation and rumor.' Nick wasn't good at hiding his disdain for the news media, despite his sister being a part of that crazy world. And right now, he hated that Christine seemed willing to point to O' Sullivan's death as proof of a bunch of rumors, some sort of way to validate a story she was trying to dig up. Hadn't she learned anything from four years ago?

'Sometimes even the most outrageous rumors have a grain of truth to them.'

'And sometimes they're simply started by bitter, vengeful people,' he added.

'Okay, then how about the rumor that O'Sullivan was taking secret documents with him to Rome and now all of a sudden they're missing.'

Too late. The expression of surprise must have registered on his face, because she was nodding at him with that 'I gotcha' look.

'What kind of documents?' he asked.

'So the police did ask about them?' Now Christine sat down next to him again on the swing, leaning in as if they were about to exchange secrets.

'They asked Tony if Monsignor O' Sullivan was delivering anything to the Vatican for Archbishop Armstrong. And they asked about a brown leather portfolio.'

'Really? So the documents might be missing.'

'What kind of documents, Christine?'

She hesitated as if she needed to think about what she could and couldn't tell him. Ordinarily he might have enjoyed having the tables turned for a change. She was concerned about divulging classified information to him instead of him trying to decide what pieces of an investigation or criminal indictment he could share with her.

'It hasn't just been rumors. There have been complaints registered against Monsignor O'Sullivan, but not with the police department. Only with the archbishop,' she said in almost a whisper. Her eyes darted to the front door again as if she was still worried their mother might overhear. 'Affidavits have been signed, money exchanged, promises made. But all in secret.'

'If it's all so secret, how did you find out?'

'People feel less motivated to keep secrets when promises are broken. Let's just say Armstrong hasn't been holding up his end of the bargain.'

'So why wouldn't he just shred any so-called documentation? Why even bother to hand deliver all of it to the Vatican?' Nick wasn't sure he was buying any of this. It sounded too sensational, too much like some conspiracy theory.

'Nicky, I'm surprised at you. Shredding such documents would be against the law,' she said with a smile before she resumed her serious tone. 'When the Boston Globe did its investigation on Cardinal Law and the Boston Archdiocese, they discovered that bishops were being told to send any documents in question to the Vatican to store. After all, the Vatican has diplomatic immunity.'

'And that's what you think is happening here? In Omaha?'

She smiled again and shrugged, took another sip of her beer.

Maybe it wasn't so sensational after all, and it was exactly the kind of thing Tony would feel he couldn't talk about, couldn't tell anyone because of his loyalties to the church. Sometimes Tony could be loyal to a fault. But he also knew his friend wouldn't sit back and keep quiet if there was a chance the allegations might be true. No way would Tony allow a child abuser to get away with it even if the abuser was a priest and his boss.

'Do you think Tony knows about any of this?' Nick asked, hoping that might be the case, but from the look on his sister's face, he could tell she didn't think so.

'That's what I'd like to know,' Christine said.

CHAPTER 22

Washington, D. C.

Someone was following her. Gwen glanced in her rearview mirror as she pulled into the tiny four-slot parking lot behind Mr. Lee's Market World. She had circled the block three times and so did the black SUV. Only now she didn't see it Was it possible she was being paranoid?

The SUV's tinted windshield had been too dark to see the driver, although during the left turn at the last intersection she had gotten enough of a glimpse to know it was a man's silhouette. Traffic was crazy on a Saturday evening and it was a holiday weekend at that. Finding a parking spot in this neighborhood of small shops with a few clapboard houses lucked in between sometimes took three and four times around the block. That's probably all it was _ someone trying to find a parking space. And yet, she stayed in her car, waiting, checking the mirrors and watching along the street, giving him plenty of time to catch up with her.

The killer had no reason to be following her. He had to know by now that his threat __ albeit subtle __ had kept her in line. She had done everything he had demanded, played along with his evil game of scavenger hunt. Why would he think she'd suddenly run to the police with his latest puzzle piece? Although this one was different from the rest. In the past he had sent her instructions, maps, information __ even a cell phone __ all for the purpose of directing her, leading her to find his victims. She believed it was to show her what he had done, what he was capable of doing. But why send a single earring? She couldn't help wondering if this latest victim was still alive. If that was true, was this a cruel taunt? Or was he giving her a chance to stop him?

Gwen twisted around, searching up and down the side streets in both directions. No black SUV with dark tinted windows. This was ridiculous. Her mind was playing tricks on her. She was allowing him to screw with her mind and he wasn't even here.

She glanced down at the manila envelope sitting on the passenger seat, now encased in plastic. Next to it was the water glass she had offered Rubin Nash, also in plastic. Before she left her office she had phoned Benny Hassert at Hassert Independent Labs. She had decided to drop off the items on her way home. Benny had agreed to put them on his priority list, no questions asked. After all, she was a longtime client. He was used to her bringing him anything, from human saliva for DNA testing to soil samples. He had no idea if this was for an FBI case she had been independently contracted to help on. He hadn't asked. He didn't care. He would simply have the results for her on Monday. And then she would know whether or not the fingerprints on the envelope with the earring matched those on the water glass and whether or not Rubin Nash was the killer.

And if it was Nash, she'd have something solid, something substantial. There would be enough of a reason to believe he* posed a serious threat to do harm. And she would have just cause to give everything to Maggie, to disregard any and all patient/doctor confidentiality. The police would have enough to make an arrest. He couldn't possibly hurt her father or any other woman ever again once he had been arrested and became their prime suspect.

Maybe it sounded a bit arrogant to think she could catch Rubin Nash so easily. Had she suspected him sooner, she could have already put an end to his killing spree. And maybe, just maybe, if the earring's owner was still alive, she could save her.

Gwen checked both sides of the street again and finally decided the SUV must have found a parking space somewhere else. She must have been wrong about it. She convinced herself that she needed some rest. A good night's sleep would be a nice change, and once inside Mr. Lee's World Market she started to browse the wine aisle,