Karsite commanders. Now, I can't pretend to tell who was right and who was wrong in those areas where both sides claimed to have been attacked first, or were provoked into attacking, or where magic, sabotage, and assassination were allegedly employed, but I can tell that the Valdemarans never took armies into Karse, but my people certainly waged war up into Valdemar.'
'Very even-handed,' Firesong replied approvingly. 'No side is always in the right. Now, we'll change the subject again. I need a religious opinion from you. What do the Sun-priests have to say about ghosts?'
'As in, what?' he asked. 'Unquiet dead? Haunts? Spirits who return to guide?'
'All of those,' Firesong said, making a general gesture. 'Some religions deny that any such manifestations exist, and some religions are written around them as a form of ancestor worship. What does the Writ of Vkandis say?'
'The Writ says very little.' He frowned, trying to think of what it
'Some people even have to have their afterlife ranked, arranged, and organized,' Firesong chuckled. 'I hate to say this, but being gathered up to lie in a meadow sunbathing and singing for all eternity is
Karal laughed. 'Maybe not for you, but think about the poor shepherds who were the first Prophets, living in the cold, damp hills of Karse, with rain and fog and damn poor grazing most of the time.'
'I suppose for them, rich meadows and sun forever would be paradise, wouldn't it?' Firesong raised his eyebrows. 'All right, so Karsites can't become ghosts—but what about other people?'
'Well, that's not in the Writ. But there is a tradition that the unblessed dead become the hungry, vengeful ghosts who roam the night. That's why most Karsites won't venture out after dark without a Priest to secure their safety.' But Firesong's question had asked about more than mere Karsite tradition, it had been about what Karal himself thought. 'As a Priest, I can exorcise ghosts, in theory. I'm supposed to be able to send any unblessed spirit to the sorting even if they aren't of the Faith, if they want to go. The Writ is kind of vague about what happens to heathen who have the misfortune to worship someone besides Vkandis. Most people assume that they'll be sent to eternal punishment, even if they are good people, but the Writ really doesn't
'Well, what about the Avatars?' Firesong asked, echoing his thoughts. 'Do they count as ghosts?'
'If they aren't, I wouldn't know what else to call them,' Karal admitted. 'And even if they aren't 'blessed' in the Karsite sense, they are anything but evil or hungry. They certainly aren't vengeful either, so there's no reason for me to interfere with whatever they are doing.' He thought a bit harder. 'The thing about exorcism is that if you want to be exact about it, there are two kinds. One kind just throws the ghost out of whatever it's possessing and bars it from coming back—it can still go possess something else somewhere else. The other kind blesses the ghost, opens a path for it so it can see where it's supposed to be going, and gives it some help to break the last bonds with the world and send it on its way if it's ready. But it has to be ready. Most Priests combine both kinds, hoping that once the spirit is cast out, it will see the Light and realize it shouldn't be here, but I've also seen reports about spirits that just seemed confused about the fact that they were dead, and in that case, the Priest only used the second kind of exorcism.'
'All very well, but suppose you were to see something that you knew was a ghost—not an Avatar, or anything obviously under the direction of anyone's god. What would you do about that?' Firesong asked. 'Would you feel that you had to do something about it?'
It was a good question. According to some Priests, he would
He still didn't see what relevance any of this had to their current situation, but presumably Firesong had some idea where he was going with all of this.
Firesong appeared to make up his mind about something, for his expression became a bit more animated and less contemplative. 'Look,' he said, 'I've been asking you all these questions because I need your help, yours and Altra's, and there are some religious problems involved. I made the—acquaintance—of some real ghosts, and you wouldn't mistake them for anything else. One of them is an ancestor of mine. Physically, they're bound to a place up north, right up at the northern border of Valdemar.'