The Frost Fair

    'But he did. He was there. He had an argument with Jeronimo.'

    'So did one or two other people, by the sound of it.'

    'I still think Henry Redmayne, he is the man. That's why I went in search of his brother. He stabbed my brother, I wanted to kill his.'

    'How did you know where to find Christopher Redmayne?'

    'I was told where he lived.'

    'By the same Captain Harvest, I daresay.' Maldini nodded. 'He deliberately set you on. That means he incited murder. We have another charge to hang around his neck.'

    'Jeronimo always trusted him.'

    'Enough to turn his back on the man. That was his mistake.'

    'This captain, he told me, was very useful to him. Jeronimo, he relied on him.'

    'At the fencing school?'

    'For something else. My brother, he did not tell me what it was. He liked to keep secrets. It was the same when we were boys at home in Italy. Jeronimo was very private.'

    'Yet he led a very public life,' said Jonathan, perplexed. 'How much privacy can you have if you spend all day teaching pupils to fence? Your brother was surrounded by people.' He pulled a face. 'Unfortunately, the captain was one of them.'

    'All I know is what Jeronimo tell me.'

    The Italian shrugged his shoulders. He looked thoroughly miserable. Though he did not condone what the man had done, Jonathan nevertheless felt sorry for him. Impelled by a desire to avenge the death of his brother, he had sacrificed his own life.

    'Did you meet any friends of his?' asked Jonathan.

    'No, sir.'

    'Did he ever mention Sir Humphrey Godden to you?'

    'No, sir.'

    'What about a Mr Crenlowe? He's a goldsmith.'

    'Ah,' said the other, 'that name I know. My brother, he say that this man make some jewellery for him. Mr Crenlowe. That was his name.'

    'Did your brother tell you who the jewellery was for?'

    Maldini gestured with a hand. 'Who else but for a lady?'

    Jonathan had the feeling that the man could provide valuable information about his brother but he was not certain that he was the best person to elicit it from him. Maldini needed more time to understand what was happening to him. He was still too bewildered by the turn of events. Jonathan leaned forward on the table.

    'We both want the same thing,' he said. 'We want your brother's killer to hang. You tried to do the hangman's job for him and that was a terrible mistake. You were wrong about Captain Harvest being a friend. He's a criminal. And you are wrong about Henry Redmayne as well.'

    'No,' protested Maldini, 'he is the one. Everybody knows it.'

    'Most people think it, I agree. Those of us who know Mr Redmayne, and who have looked into this case, are certain that he's innocent. I won't try to convince you of that. I can see that it would be a waste of time. However, tell me this. If - and I only ask you to consider it - if someone else stuck that knife in your brother's back, would you help us to catch him?'

    'Yes, of course. But the killer has already been arrested.'

    'On false evidence in my view,' said Jonathan. 'That's why his brother is moving heaven and earth to prove his innocence. You can understand that, I think. You know how it feels when you think a brother has been cruelly wronged.'

    'Oh, yes,' said the other, knuckles tightening. 'I would have done anything for Jeronimo.'

    'You've already done too much.'

    Maldini's head fell to his chest. Jonathan felt another surge of pity. The Italian was young, strong and lithe with a promising career as a musician ahead of him. All that had been squandered. Jonathan sought to relieve his suffering a little.

    'Where did you spend the night?' he said.

    'With a pack of wild animals,' replied Maldini, looking up. 'It was torture.'

    'I might be able to get you moved to a cell on your own. Would you like that?'

    'Yes, please! Those others, they drive me mad,'

    'I'll speak to the prison sergeant.'

    Maldini grabbed his arm. 'Thank you, Mr Bale. Thank you, sir.'

    'But I expect a favour in return, mark you.'

    'A favour?'

    'I want you to talk to Christopher Redmayne.'

    Maldini withdrew his hand in disgust and spat on to the floor.

      The meeting with Lady Holcroft had been less enlightening than he had hoped but Christopher had the supreme consolation of spending an hour alone with Susan Cheever. At no point did she press him about his reason for a secret rendezvous with Lady Holcroft and he was grateful for that. She felt able to confide in him her worries that Mrs Cardinal was showing an interest in her as a possible future wife for her son and assuring him that, while she admired Jack Cardinal, she would never choose him as her partner in life. He was tempted to reveal his own dilemma with regard to Lady Whitcombe but he drew back, still hoping that he could resolve that particular problem.

    'What will I tell Mrs Cardinal when I get back to the house?' she asked.

    'Tell her that you and Lady Holcroft went for a ride in the coach.'

    'She's bound to press for details.'

    'Invent some,' said Christopher cheerfully. 'Lady Holcroft will not contradict you. I suspect she'll pretend that this morning did not really take place. The main thing is to get you back before Mrs Cardinal and her son return.'

    'Yes,' she agreed, sad to leave. 'I suppose so.'

    'I'm deeply grateful to the lady. After all, she brought you to London.' 'She did, Christopher. If the situation were different, I could like her very much. But she will watch me all the time, just like Brilliana. It's almost as if they have a secret pact to marry me off, and I hate it when people try to make decisions for me.'

    'I'd never presume to do that.'

    'Thank you.' She turned round so that he could put her cloak around her shoulders. 'It's been wonderful to see you again,' she said, facing him again, 'but I know that you have to get back to helping your brother. How is he? I heard his name mentioned more than once at the dinner table yesterday. The comments were not flattering.'

    'They will be when Henry is exonerated.'

    'How close are you to proving his innocence?'

    'Jonathan Bale and I get closer every day, Susan,' he said. 'I've managed to win over the most difficult man to persuade.'

    'Who is that?'

    'Jonathan himself. He thought at first that Henry was guilty.'

    'That must have made for some awkwardness between the two of you.'

    'Oh, it did,' he agreed, 'but friendship is an odd thing. It sometimes thrives on differences of opinion. At least, I felt that it did in this case.'

    'Does he know that you were coming here today?'

    'No, Susan. It was something that even he could not be told about. And he never will. I promised Lady Holcroft in my letter that nobody else would ever be aware that our meeting took place. Apart from you, that is.'

    'I can be very discreet.'

    'That's why I turned to you.' He gave her a smile of gratitude then remembered what he had been told earlier by Lady Holcroft. 'May I please ask you something?'

    'Of course.'

    'This is purely a suggestion,' he explained, 'and relates to nobody in particular. Suppose that a certain lady,