After the notes were transcripts of the interview with the only witness, Christine Castiglia, eleven years old.
Next, Justine looked over the list of stolen property, an itemized account of the contents of Wendy Borman’s backpack. A piece of handmade jewelry had also been taken, a gold chain necklace with a gold charm in the shape of a star.
Toward the back of the book was a photograph of Wendy Borman wearing that necklace while she was alive. She was posed standing between her parents. She was already taller than they were, and she had looped her arms over both their shoulders. Wendy had been a grinning, blond-haired girl with an athletic build. She didn’t look like she should ever die. How sad was that?
“I’m ready for the contents of the evidence box,” Justine said. “I think so, anyway.”
Detective Murphy offered Justine latex gloves from a dispenser, then used a pocketknife to slit the red tape around a plain cardboard box. She removed the lid, lifted out a large paper bag, and sliced the seal on that.
Justine was hit with an adrenaline high, a rush of bright anticipation she couldn’t control. This was precisely the feeling that had gotten her into forensics and made her good at it. Something here might open a window into the Schoolgirl case.
Maybe it would even reveal a killer.
She reached into the bag and pulled out a pair of stretch jeans, size six, and a baby blue jersey-knit top with a scoop neckline.
She plunged her hands into the bag again and brought out a pair of Nike cross-trainers and baby blue socks.
She spread out the clothing, examining where samples had been cut out of the fabric by the LA crime lab.
“I take it the blood belonged to the victim.”
Murphy nodded yes.
“I need to borrow her clothes,” Justine said.
“Chief Fescoe and DA Petino already okayed their release,” said Murphy. “You’re the man.”
She pushed a form over to Justine and handed her a pen.
“Wendy’s left arm,” Murphy said. “It was under some garbage bags. The rain didn’t soak the sleeve. I’d have your lab check it out. Technology is a lot better now. Especially at a lab like yours at Private.”
“Let’s keep some hope alive,” said Justine.
“No, let’s get this bastard,” said Detective Murphy, smiling again, but also showing Justine just how tough and relentless she was.
Chapter 69
“You remember the Wendy Borman case?” asked Justine.
The air smelled of fried fish, fried onions, fried potatoes. Justine sat across a small square table from Christine Castiglia in the Belmont High School cafeteria. The only witness to Wendy Borman’s abduction was sixteen now. She was petite, hugging herself, looking up at Justine with big eyes half hidden under thick brown bangs.
You didn’t have to be a shrink to see that Christine was afraid. Justine knew to tread carefully, and she wasn’t feeling so steady herself. She was desperate for this girl to tell her something that could lead to the Schoolgirl killer before he killed again.
“I was only eleven when it happened,” Christine said. “You know that, right?”
“I know.” Justine swirled a straw in her plastic cup of ice and Diet Coke. “Can you tell me what you saw anyway? I need to hear it from you.”
“Are you thinking those same boys-I guess they’re men now-might have killed the girls around here?”
Someone dropped a tub of dishes behind the steam tables. An awful, nerve-rending clatter.
Justine waited out the kids’ applause before saying, “It’s possible. There was a gap of three years between Wendy Borman and Kayla Brooks. That’s why no one thought to connect them. It’s why what you witnessed is so important. If Wendy Borman was their first killing, they might have made a mistake.”
“It was a plain black van,” Christine said. “It stopped in a cross street off Hyperion, and when I looked again, two guys had grabbed this girl. Like, it only took a second? And she was like having a fit or something. They swung her into the van, and then one of them got into the driver’s seat and they drove off. I told the police what the driver looked like.”
“Wendy Borman was zapped with a stun gun,” Justine said. “That was the fit you saw. And your mom didn’t see anything?”
Christine shook her head. “I wasn’t sure what I’d seen myself. It could’ve been a commercial between my thoughts-that’s how fast it was. I froze, and when my mom turned to see what I was looking at, the van was gone. She didn’t believe me-or didn’t want to.
“But when it was all over the TV, she finally called the police. My mother believed the TV but not me.”
Kids were passing the table, staring at the woman in a business suit having a deep discussion with a kid at their school.
“Tell me about the boy-the one whose face you saw.”
“In the drawing the police made, he looked kinda like Clark Kent in the Superman movie. But he didn’t exactly look like that. His nose was a bit pointy? And his ears stuck out? I mean-they definitely stuck out.”
“Did you see the license plate number on that van? Even one or two numbers would give us something to work with.”
The girl paused, eyes flicking up and to the left, searching her memory.
A class bell rang then, loud, jangling. Kids got up en masse, and a couple of them brushed Justine’s arm and knocked over her briefcase on their way to the trash bins and out the door.
Christine said, “There was a decal on the rear window. It said ‘Gateway.’ Like that computer company? But there weren’t any cow spots.”
“You told this to the police?”
“I think so. My mother was freaked out. She couldn’t get me away from the police fast enough.”
Justine looked at the girl, and for a moment, the girl held her gaze. “See if you can draw that decal,” Justine said. She passed over her PDA and stylus.
The girl sucked hard on her lower lip as she sketched an oval shape and the word Gateway in graduated letters.
“I think this is it. I don’t know why I remember so well, but I do.”
Justine stared at the crude drawing. The logo looked like that of a private school in Santa Monica called Gateway. When she had worked for the city’s psych ward, she used to drive past Gateway Prep when she did sessions at Stateside, aka the California State Hospital for the Criminally Insane.
She still vividly remembered her patients, the ones who burned down houses, killed their siblings, shotgunned their parents, and lit up schoolyards with explosives. It had been devastating and demoralizing work that had taught her about the mental workings of some of the most heinous humans on earth.
Justine had thought then about the contrast between Stateside and Gateway Prep, only a mile apart geographically, worlds apart in every other way. Now she thought about the Gateway decal.
There was no mention of a Gateway decal in the Wendy Borman murder book.
The decal was news. The facial characteristics were news. Maybe she was getting somewhere. If these were the same boys.
“Could you identify this boy if you saw him again?”
“I could never forget his face.”
“Christine, thank you.” Justine gave the teenager her card. “Call me if you think of anything else. The next time we meet, we won’t be strangers.”
Chapter 70
