time as the murder. It could be coincidence, of course. It could also be that the crime had somehow triggered his mourner obsession, dormant or subdued in him since his childhood trauma. The marble headstone and the ongoing supply of flowers fitted that kind of obsession; it was possible he’d supplied the same service to other victims of violent crime, past as well as present.
It was the other, darker possibility that worried me. Suppose the headstone and flowers were a product of guilt, remorse? Suppose he was the man who had raped and strangled Erin Dumont?
You looked at Troxell’s upbringing, the shape of his adult life, and on the surface he seemed an unlikely candidate for that kind of vicious criminal act. Successful financial consultant, home in St. Francis Wood, beautiful wife-good old-fashioned American success story. No history of trouble of any kind, none of the warning flags of aberrent behavior. Normal adult male. Except that “normal” is essentially a meaningless term; any psychologist will tell you that. The human animal is far too complex for any such simplistic categorizing. And Troxell had been witness to a bloody murder-suicide at a highly impressionable age. That kind of shock can create a psychic breeding ground for demons and monsters.
The thing I couldn’t quite fit into the man’s apparent psychosis, benign or malignant, was the Potrero Hill angle. He might’ve gone to the Wisconsin Street address to visit somebody who lived there; a girlfriend, despite all the disclaimers. Only he’d done nothing the past three days to even hint that he was anything but a faithful husband. Male friend or business associate, a shut-in he bought newspapers and rented videos for?
But suppose he was the one renting the mother-in-law unit. The obvious explanation for a man setting up a private little retreat didn’t seem to apply, so why would he want or need a hideaway? He had plenty of privacy at home; he could do all the newspaper reading and video watching he cared to behind the locked door of his den. A place to keep personal belongings he didn’t want his wife or anybody else to stumble over? And what about those videos he’d bought or rented? Slasher films, sick depictions of violence against women?
Getting ahead of myself, jumping to conclusions.
I tried to bounce all of this off Tamara, but she wasn’t in a mood for brainstorming. Or any kind of conversation that required more than monosyllablic responses or simple declarative sentences. Over the years a parade of different Tamaras had marched through the agency offices, like a multiheaded Hydra. Most of the heads were likable-Warm and Tender Tamara and Bright and Sassy Tamara were the dominant ones-but a few were exasperating. Today Glum Tamara was back after a long absence, along with her twin sister, Self-Pitying Tamara. Quiet, withdrawn; pinched look around her mouth, puffiness under her eyes that testified to a lack of sleep. Carryover from whatever had upset her yesterday, I thought. I still figured it for Horace-related bad news, and I was ready to offer her a shoulder to cry on, a sounding board to vent at, some fatherly advice, or anything else she might need from me. But the overtures would have to come from her. She’d tell me about it when she was ready and not before. Until then the best way to deal with her-as with Kerry or any woman when she was in a funk-was to do and say nothing to provoke her. Lessons I’d learned the slow, hard way.
I would have to report to Lynn Troxell pretty soon, but not until I was armed with a few more facts to either support or banish suppositions. I asked Tamara to pull up what she could find on the Internet on the Erin Dumont rape-homicide. It didn’t take long. One inside-page Chronicle news story the morning after the body was discovered, one brief follow-up article, the inevitable angry op-ed piece on the prevalence of sexual predators in modern society, and then silence. Life goes on and so does death, public outcries fall on deaf ears, and after their fifteen minutes of infamy the victims are quickly forgotten.
Erin Dumont had been twenty-five when she was assaulted, manually strangled, and her battered body left in a screen of shrubbery five hundred yards inside the park entrance at Thirtieth Avenue and Fulton. Employed at a Union Street boutique called FashionSense. Born in Green Bay, Wisconsin, moved to San Francisco five years ago-as her sister had told Runyon. Marisa Niland and Erin’s boyfriend, Scott Iams, were mentioned briefly.
Longshot that there was any connection between Troxell and either the sister or boyfriend, but worth at least a cursory look. I asked Tamara if she’d run checks on them yet. She muttered something.
“Sorry, I didn’t catch that.”
“Routine crap,” she said, scowling.
“What you found out?”
“What I get stuck with doing half the time around here.”
Self-pitying Tamara, rearing her ugly head. Judiciously I said, “Big part of the game, kiddo. Not just for you, for all of us. You know that.”
“Yeah, well.”
“Risa Niland? Scott Iams?”
She’d run the checks, all right. In one of her moods or not, she was always efficient. Risa Niland was twenty-nine, worked at a place called Get Fit, a health club on outer Geary not far from the apartment she’d shared with her sister on Twenty-Ninth and Anza. Divorced from one Jerry Niland, a Marina district CPA, a year and a half ago. No police record of any kind. No apparent connection to Troxell, personally or professionally. Iams was twenty-six, lived in the Inner Sunset, and was employed by a catering company on Union Street. Single. Likewise no police record except for a couple of speeding tickets, the last one three years ago. No apparent connection to Troxell, personally or professionally.
I said, “Okay. Next question. What did you get on the owners of the Wisconsin Street property?”
“More routine crap. Ralph Linden: forty-six, works for a Japanese company in the East Bay, Yumitashi International. Justine Linden: forty-five, commercial artist.”
“How long have they owned it?”
“Sixteen years. Granny unit’s illegal-no record of an outbuilding on the original deed, no record of a building permit or application for one since.”
“Some leverage in that, if we need it. Anything unusual in their backgrounds?”
“No. Two more of your average San Francisco white folks.”
All I said to that was, “Leverage in that, too. People with clean records want them to stay that way.”
“You gonna talk to them?”
“Let Jake follow up. I’ve got some other things to do. See what I can get out of SFPD on the Dumont case, for starters.”
There’d been a time when I had several contacts on the San Francisco cops-friends from the days when I’d been one myself, a couple of guys I played poker with now and then, a couple of others whose paths I’d crossed in a friendly way. Time and a series of high-profile screwups, scandals, and shakeups had dwindled their number, and changed the shape and policies of the department. Ed Branislaus had quit the force and gone into private security work in Arizona. Harry Craddock had been promoted and transferred to the Ingleside District Station. Lieutenant Jack Logan, the man I’d known the longest and was closest to, was in line for an administrative position and would probably retire if he didn’t get it; either way it went, he was no longer as inclined to do favors for friends and/or to bend departmental rules.
Logan was in and he took my call readily enough, but he was a little on the curt side. We barely got through the how-are-yous before he asked, “So what can I do for you?”
“Some information, if you can manage it.”
“Well, I don’t know, buddy. You know how things are these days.”
“I figured it couldn’t hurt to ask.”
“Important?”
“Too early to tell. Small chance it could be, though.”
“New or cold case?”
“Couple of months old.”
“Still open, then?”
“As far as I know.”
“Too damn many that are. Which one is this?”
“Rape homicide in Golden Gate Park, end of March. Woman named Erin Dumont.”
“Oh, yeah, I remember it. What’s your interest?”
“We’ve picked up a connection to a case we’re working. Pretty tenuous right now, no direct link to the homicide itself. But I could use some more information.”
“Give it to us right away if the link develops?”
“You know I will, Jack.”
