“An interesting challenge, Earl. I am sure you have already solved it.”
“I called this place a prison,” said Dumarest. “Let me use another term which might clarify the situation. For you, of course, I am clear on the matter. Think of a maze. A pattern of lines or constructions-bricks, bushes, hedges, bales of hay, lines of chalk-anything. The pattern is the important thing. It can be simple or complex. A path which loops and turns and wends in endless configurations only one of which is clear. One which has to be chosen at each junction, each fork, each barrier.”
“I know what a maze is, Earl. Your point?”
“A maze is a prison. There are prisons which are mazes, deliberately so. Buildings which are honeycombed with oddly shaped chambers, tubes, vents-anything a sadistic mind can imagine. Three-dimensional hells of calculated torment. People die in there.”
“So?”
“There is one weakness in a maze. Not those built as prisons though the same principles apply. Now I’m talking about the ceremonial type of maze. The paper-puzzle kind. A long time ago I was held in an establishment for a while. The warden was fond of mazes and had what he thought was a good idea. He issued them to us to work at. All were different but basically the same. You entered the maze and worked to find a way out. Tracing the correct path earned a small privilege. Some managed to do it fairly. The rest cheated.”
“You among them, Earl?” Shandaha had relaxed, drinking, now refilling the goblets with wine. “How did you cheat?”
“As I demonstrated a short while ago. I tried creating a short-cut. On paper I would have crossed a line. In a large maze I would have jumped over the barrier or broken through the hedge or whatever had been used. Here I smashed down a wall.”
“And what did you gain?”
“I was hoping you could tell me.”
“I thought I had. You broke into a small chamber housing electronic devices. You admit that you slipped and struck your head with force enough to render you unconscious. You were rescued, attended, put into Nada’s care.”
Who had reported everything she had been told to her master. Dumarest was not surprised. He had anticipated her action and his talk about prisons and mazes had been simply to divert Shandaha’s interest away from what had really taken place.
He said, “I apologise. I had forgotten. That blow I suffered was more severe than I thought. I must apologise, also for having broken that wall. If you will allow me the use of materials and equipment I am willing to repair it.”
“No, Earl. You are gracious but there is no need for me to accept your offer.”
“It will be of no trouble and I could use the exercise.”
“No.” Shandaha was firm. “The subject tires me. We will talk no more about it. More wine?”
He lifted a flagon and poured as Dumarest nodded his acceptance. He watched as it flowed into the glasses wondering what had been added or was being added to the rich liquid. Nothing, he guessed. It was a simple matter to spike a drink with the use of a pill held between two fingers or a drop of liquid held in the hollow of a palm, but the way Shandaha poured precluded either possibility. He touched only the flagon. In any case he would have no need to be so crude.
Dumarest leaned back in his chair and apparently relaxed, sipped at his wine as he studied the table, the furnishing, Shandaha himself. All seemed no different than they had before, yet he was convinced that nothing was what it seemed to be. Shandaha had lied about what was beyond the crystal wall. There had been no chamber, no exotic electronic devices emitting flares of energy, but he had no intention of admitting anything else.
“This is excellent wine.” Dumarest set his emptied glass back on the table. Do you manufacture it?”
“Why do you ask?”
“I am curious. It would be a pleasure to examine your equipment. I once owned a small vineyard but I could never produce a vintage such as that I have just enjoyed. Also, with respect, I have never possessed a domain such as yours. On both counts I envy you.”
“Do you mock me?”
“Mock?” Dumarest shook his head. “That I would never do. I am your guest and am sincere in what I say, but if the subject displeased you then another can be chosen.” He paused, waiting, then as the other remained silent said, “Or, perhaps, you would care to answer a question?”
“Continue.”
“Why did you summon me?”
Shandaha made no reply and Dumarest felt a warning prickle of danger. To tease the cat wasn’t a good idea if you were a mouse. He had triggered a flash of anger and had tried to rectify the error, but diplomacy wasn’t always easy and he was in no position to make a powerful enemy.
He said, “Nada told me that you had sent her to tell me you required my presence. She didn’t arrive in time, but when she came she was instrumental in saving my life. She would not have been able to do that had you not sent her. So, logically, you are the one I must thank for my continued existence.”
“And so, again by the use of logic, I am responsible for everything you do. Your thefts, killings, crimes, wastes, depravities,” Shandaha shrugged. “Should I feel proud at having saved you or ashamed at what you may do? Can logic provide a true answer?”
“In order to solve that question we first have to decide the definition of truth,” said Dumarest. “Your truth could be my lie. For example you say that I am not a prisoner and am free to leave here whenever I wish. You would be stating the truth as you see it. To me you would also be telling the truth, but unless given the means to survive I would die. To accept your offer of freedom would be fatal. How, then, could I be free? Which means your apparent truth was a lie.”
Dumarest paused, then as Shandaha made no comment slammed his hand on the table with abrupt force, the flagons, glasses and trays dancing from the impact.
“Take this as another example. Is this table real or is it an illusion? I can touch it, feel it, see it so logic would infer that it is real. But an illusion would yield the same conclusion. So how can we determine the truth?”
Shandaha said, flatly, “The answer to your first question is death is not a factor in the equation. Your liberty to make a choice is paramount. You can be free if you choose-what happens after you leave is immaterial. As for the table your argument is more the rambling of a philosopher than the studied calculation of a logician. But there is one reality we cannot but agree is the truth.”
“The past,” said Dumarest, knowing what was to follow. “My past.”
“Your memories,” corrected Shandaha. “You asked why I had sent Nada to request you to attend me. I am impatient to enjoy more of your experiences. To travel back in time with you. To share the most significant moments of your life.”
“Again?”
“Yes.”
“When? Now?”
“Yes, Earl. Now.”
His world was filled with the agony of the fire, which burned on his torso. Pain born of the deep cuts slashed across his naked flesh. Blood oozed from the wounds to add to the dirt on the floor beneath the plank on which he lay. Above him the cracked plaster of the ceiling held the distorted image of a grimacing face. Light came from lanterns hanging from hooks on the walls. The air quivered with sound from the arena where men and women shrieked their pleasure over the clash of steel, the screams of agony from those fighting for their lives.
A harsh place filled with the scent of pain and fear, of sweat and blood and despair.
Dumarest turned as he heard the pad of feet behind him, tensing as he saw the group of men approaching the plank on which he lay.
“Relax!” Their leader held something in his hand. “Lie back and open your mouth. Do it now!”
“Why?” What do you want with me?”
“Forget the talk. Just do as I say!”
“Take it easy, Gastar,” said one of the others. “He’s young. New to the game.” To Dumarest he said, “No one means you harm, boy. Just cooperate and let’s get on with it. Just open your mouth.”
The object Gastar held slipped into it as Dumarest obeyed. It was wood covered in fabric soaked in strong
