CAPACITY

it.”

Lemuel remained silent.

“Why don’t you say anything? Why should I help Chris? How could he possibly believe that I would?”

Lemuel put his hands together and thoughtfully touched his lips with his fingertips.

“Judy, the reason that I am here, the reason that Frances would want me to come, is to tell you this…”

“What?”

Lemuel gazed intently at the performer. Judy began to think that he wasn’t going to answer, but then he turned to look at her.

“Judy, AIs can read human personalities all the way to the least significant digit. Chris really believed that you would see his point of view. If Frances hadn’t fought him, if she hadn’t made you run, he would have convinced you.”

“She made me run? He was trying to kill me!”

“Not at first, Judy. Not at first.” Judy tilted her head, trying to understand what he was saying. He continued: “But Frances believed it was for the best. Judy, it was Chris who sent you looking for David Schummel. He gave away the position of the processing space owned by the Private Network. He had someone waiting in there to speak to one of your sisters. He wanted to speak to you.”

“Why?” She paused. “He said something to me, before I ran from the room. He said that my mind had been programmed from birth. What did he mean?”

Lemuel looked unhappy. “Judy, you know what he meant. It’s what Social Care does. You train and counsel and manipulate through social pressure. All humans are programmed from birth…”

Judy stared at Lemuel. He gazed back.

“…but there’s an alternative, Judy-an idea. It’s been around for a long time. Why bother with Social Care and such imperfect mechanisms? What if humans were to be directly programmed at birth?”

“That’s immoral. What about freedom of choice?”

“You see?” said Lemuel. “You’re starting to sound like Kevin already.”

Lemuel leaned closer and spoke in serious tones. “The Watcher says we will never attempt direct programming, but there is evidence that somebody already has.”

“What was that?”

“The White Death. That was a program designed to affect human brains.”

Judy stared at him.

“But who? Why?”

“No one knows where it came from.”

“Oh.”

“And then there’s you.”

“What about me?” Judy felt her heart grow cold again. She suspected the answer already.

“What if I were to tell you that your personality was written for you before you were born? What if it turned out that you were a virgin, not through personal choice, but because someone decided that you would be?”

Judy felt something clench at her throat. She tried to speak and failed. Swallowed, and tried again.

“And do you think that?” she asked.

Lemuel looked back to the performer. “Aren’t you going to ask me about the baby?” he asked.

Judy froze. She felt very small and unworthy. She had been so wrapped up in her own personal tragedy that she had never even thought about Justinian’s baby, left abandoned in the cave on Gateway.

“How could they do that?” she asked. “How could the Watcher send an innocent to its death?”

“The Watcher risked just two people in order to save the lives of billions. Trillions. Would you have done differently?”

“Yes!”

“I know you’re lying. I think you know it, too, in your heart of hearts. But think about this, Judy. Think about what Frances did. She looked at the seed in Chris’ head in order to find a way of defeating him and to help you live. She risked everyone on Earth just to save you.”

“That’s the difference between strangers and friends,” Judy murmured.

“I know,” Lemuel replied. “That’s why I remain a stranger.”

Judy gazed at him, and then suddenly she was crying again, though there was no reason for it. Lemuel waited patiently as she regained control of herself. Her tears formed little puddles on the stone floor. She smeared the pools with her foot, then took a deep breath.

“Has Frances put us all at risk because of me?” she asked.

“Not yet.” Lemuel looked up into the barrel vaulting of the ceiling. Judy had the impression he was looking beyond it.

“Judy,” he said, “three days ago there was an indescribably fascinating plant floating above the Earth, scattering seeds and BVBs in all directions. Now that plant is approaching the outer corona of the sun, where I hope it will have the decency to burn up and be utterly destroyed. The Watcher has had seventeen years to think and plan for how to deal with those plants. Even now, little black boxes skitter across the planet and across the Shawl, and we avert our gaze while lesser intelligences look at them and fix them in position before whisking them away to safety.”

“So we are safe?”

Lemuel pursed his lips. “I think we are slowly winning the battle, and all because seventeen years ago a boy and his father were sent to Gateway. The information gained from that expedition was enough to put in place countermeasures against just such an eventuality as the one that Frances precipitated. Taking that into consideration, I think that what the Watcher did on Gateway was the right thing, don’t you?”

Judy couldn’t reply. She could only think about the baby.

She pushed that thought from her mind. “So what now?”

Lemuel pointed to the front of the room.

The performer was coming to his final piece. Slowly, with much deliberation, he donned a microphone headset. Lights flickered on his keyboards as he changed the voice settings, and then he was still. The audience sat up a little straighter in anticipation as he held his position, and held it, and then finally he pressed his hands down. An organ chord filled the church, a note that seemed to sound out across the centuries, and then the performer sang, his voice emerging from the speakers as a full choir.

“Veni! Veni Creator Spiritus!”

Fumbling trumpets sounded.

Lemuel looked at Judy.

“What?” she said. “I don’t understand. It’s not as if he’s even that good.”

Lemuel arched an eyebrow. “Many of us consider him to be the greatest artist humankind has yet produced,” he said. Judy looked at him in disbelief.

“Are you serious?”

“Yes, five centuries of music delivered by one man, daringly arranged, delivered to the very limits of his skill.”

“You can’t be serious. There are many human performers far better than him. Listen to his mistakes!”

“I can hear them. But I also hear the mistakes made by even the best human performer. Every human performance is imperfect, Judy, and still we observe them all. We nurture you all and help you to grow. That is why I am here. That is why the Watcher is here.”

“You don’t know that for certain!”

“I don’t, but still that is what we choose to believe. All you can really do is trust me when I say the Watcher’s motives are for the best. Tell me, do you trust the Watcher?”

Judy gazed at Lemuel for a long time. Did she trust the Watcher? She thought of Chris. He didn’t trust the Watcher. Why did he believe that Judy could be brought to think the same? Was it because the Watcher had programmed her to be a virgin? No. She couldn’t believe that was true.

But maybe she was programmed not to believe that.

She thought of her dead sisters.