That had clouded his vision. He had wanted to rescue the Greens. He had convinced himself there was a chance to do that; that despite the odds, he would find Stewart Green whole and bring him back.
Dumb.
There were still questions, of course. Why hadn’t Ross Gunther’s body been dumped down the well too? There were a few possibilities, but Broome didn’t love any of them. The bodies in the well also didn’t answer the question about who had killed Harry Sutton and why, but perhaps the timing had indeed been a coincidence. As for Lorraine seeing Stewart Green alive, that was an easy mistake to make. Even she had admitted that she had her doubts. It was probably someone who looked like Stewart. What with the shaved head and goatee and seventeen years of aging, even Broome could hardly say for sure that age progression was based on him.
Unless, of course, Lorraine hadn’t been wrong. Unless Stewart Green hadn’t been the first victim but the perpetrator…
He didn’t think so.
Another skeleton was brought up.
“Detective Broome?”
He turned.
“I’m Special Agent Guy Angiuoni. Thanks for calling us.”
They shook hands. Broome was too old to play territory games. He wanted this crazy son of a bitch caught.
“Any clue who’s down there?”
“My wi”-he almost said wife-“My partner, Erin Anderson, is still making up a list of men who vanished on or around Mardi Gras. We can get you that information so you can match it to the victims in that well.”
“That’d be very helpful.”
The two men watched the pulley and rope head back down.
“I hear you may have a suspect,” Angiuoni said. “A man named Ray Levine.”
“He’s a possibility, I guess, but there’s not much evidence yet. We already have a warrant being served on his place.”
“Great. Maybe you could help coordinate with our people taking over that?”
Broome nodded and turned away. It was time to get out of the woods. There was nothing he could do here right now. It’d be hours, maybe days. In the meantime he’d find out what his people had uncovered, if anything, in Ray Levine’s basement. He thought about Sarah Green and if he should wait until they had firm confirmation that he was in that well, but, no, the media would be all over this. He didn’t want Sarah to hear about it from some pushy reporter.
“I can meet your guys at Levine’s,” Broome said.
“I appreciate that. I want to keep you involved in this, Detective. We do need a local guy to coordinate with us.”
“I’m at your disposal.”
The two men shook hands. Using his flashlight, Broome started back down the path toward his car. His cell phone buzzed. He saw that it was from Megan Pierce.
“Hello?”
But it wasn’t Megan Pierce. It was a homicide investigator from Essex County telling him that someone had just tried to murder Megan Pierce.
It took Erin a while, but she’d finally found the home number for Stacy Paris, the exotic dancer Ross Gunther and Ricky Mannion had fought and, in Gunther’s case at least, died over. Stacy Paris had changed her name to Jaime Hemsley. She was single and owned a small clothing boutique in the tony suburb of Alpharetta, Georgia, half an hour from Atlanta.
Erin debated making the call but not for very long. Despite the hour, she picked up the phone and dialed.
A woman with a light Southern drawl answered the phone. “Hello?”
“Jaime Hemsley?”
“Yes, may I help you?”
“This is Detective Erin Anderson from the Atlantic City Police Department. I need to ask you a few questions.”
There was a brief silence.
“Ms. Hemsley?”
“I don’t see how I can help you.”
“I hate to call you out of the blue like this, but I need your help.”
“I don’t know anything.”
“Well, Jaime, or should I say, Stacy, I do,” Erin said. “Like, for example, your real name.”
“Oh my God.” The Southern drawl was gone. “Please. I’m begging you. Please let me be.”
“I don’t have any interest in harming you.”
“It’s been almost twenty years.”
“I understand that, but we have a new lead in Mr. Gunther’s murder.”
“What are you talking about? Ricky killed Ross.”
“We don’t think so. We think someone else did it.”
“So Ricky is going free?” There was a sob in her voice. “Oh my God.”
“Ms. Hemsley-”
“I don’t know anything, okay? I was a punching bag for both of those psychopaths. I thought… I thought God did me a favor. You know-two birds, one stone? He got both of them out of my life and gave me a fresh start.”
“Who gave you a fresh start?”
“What do you mean, who? God, fate, my guardian angel, I don’t know. I had two men fighting over which one would eventually kill me. And suddenly they were both gone.”
“Like you were saved,” Erin said, as much to herself as the witness on the phone.
“Yes. I moved away. I changed my name. I own a clothing store. It’s not much, but it’s all mine. Do you know what I mean?”
“I do.”
“And now, what, Ricky is going to get out? Please, Detective, please don’t let him know where I am.”
Erin pondered what she was hearing. This situation again fit a certain profile that had been emerging in connection with the missing men-that is, most of these men were not exactly model citizens. Several of the wives or girlfriends had been equally up front, begging Erin not to find their missing partners.
“He won’t find you, but I need to ask: Do you have any idea who may have done this?”
“Killed Ross, you mean?”
“Yes.”
“Other than Ricky, no.”
Erin’s cell phone sounded. It was Broome. She thanked Jaime Hemsley and told her that she’d call her if she needed anything else. She also promised to let her know if Ricky Mannion was released from prison.
After they both hung up, Erin picked up the cell. “Hello?”
“They’re dead, Erin,” Broome said in the strangest monotone. “They’re all dead.”
Erin felt a cold stone form in her chest. “What are you talking about?”
He told her about the photograph of the hand truck, the trip back to the ruins, the bodies in the well. Erin sat unmoving.
When Broome finished, Erin said, “So that’s it? It’s over?”
“For us, I guess. The feds will find the guy. But there are parts that still don’t fit.”
“No case is a perfect fit, Broome. You know that.”
“Yeah, okay, and but here’s the thing. I just got a call from an investigator up in Essex County. Megan Pierce was attacked tonight by a young blond woman who matched her description of the woman who was in Harry Sutton’s office.”
“Is she okay?”
