The Kills

'What have we here, Mr. Robelon? A little accident?'

'I wish that were the case, Your Honor. Unfortunately, it's a lot more serious than that. My client was attacked last night-a vicious street crime-repeatedly stabbed in the back in a senseless act of violence.'

'You know about this, Alexandra?' the judge asked.

'I don't think it's quite as serious as it looks, Your Honor.'

'Now Ms. Cooper's a doctor, too,' Robelon said. 'Mr. Tripping was released from the hospital at two o'clock this morning. He's in great pain, and he's got a schedule of follow-up medical care that has to be kept. He-he can't even get out of this chair.'

'That's ridiculous, Judge. He's got some superficial wounds in his upper back. I know all about this. If you'd just order him out of the chair, he's perfectly able to stand up and go forward with the plea that counsel and I have discussed.'

Moffett pointed his gavel at me and shook it. 'The last time I tried that, young lady, at the direction of one of your buddies, I was censured by the appellate court.'

I had struck the wrong chord. Years ago, in an incident that had made tabloid headlines, cops had been pulling the leg of one of my rookie colleagues. The perp being arraigned was a notorious career criminal, who had frequently been a malingerer and faked diseases to avoid judicial proceedings. The night he was brought up on charges of homicide, the arresting officer insisted to the assistant district attorney that despite his protestations, the killer could get out of his wheelchair and stand before the court.

The prosecutor passed the message along to the judge, neither of them knowing that the victim's brother had just broken the defendant's kneecaps with a golf club. Moffett barked at the guy to stand up, five or six times, threatening to hold him in contempt if he refused. When the man tried to stand, he collapsed on the floor of the courtroom, and the Legal Aid Society brought a complaint against Moffett that almost caused him to be denied reappointment.

'Your Honor, there has actually been some progress to report, if you'll give us some breathing space here. I've had a conversation with Ms. Cooper. My client has authorized me to accept an offer of a misdemeanor plea. We had every intention of going ahead with that this morning, but in light of Mr. Tripping's physical condition-his injuries-'

'Judge, this is ridiculous. Yes, we had plea discussions. And this-this sudden bunch of scratches on the defendant's back are nothing more than an insurance policy for the strategy planned by Mr. Robelon. Although he told me he thought there could be a disposition of the case, he wanted additional time out of jail for his client. When I told him I would not go along with that condition, this sham is apparently the solution they devised to buy some time out of Rikers.'

'What does he need time for, Alexandra? He pleads guilty, so he gets a week or two to tie up loose ends. What's the big deal?'

'I have no idea why he wants it. Maybe he doesn't intend to surrender himself. Maybe he has plans to abscond. Maybe-'

Robelon was livid. 'Stop with the fantasies, Ms. Cooper. Where do you come off throwing out these absurd ideas to prejudice the court against this defendant?'

'Look at him, Alexandra,' Moffett said, pointing at Tripping. He had slumped down in his wheelchair and both arms were hanging over the sides. 'He can't even hold himself together. They give you any medication, Mr. Tripping?'

Tripping looked dazed. He was nonresponsive.

Moffett tried again. 'You, Mr. Tripping. You with me?'

'I'm sorry, Judge. I'm in terrible pain-'

Robelon interrupted. 'I really don't want my client speaking on the record, Judge. Yes, he's been given MorphiDex. It's a morphine derivative, Judge. Obviously,' he said, sneering at me, 'someone believes he's in pain.'

'Here's what we're gonna do. You lose, Ms. Cooper. I can't take a plea from somebody who's doped up on narcotics.'

'You do it every day of the week, Judge. Just different narcotics.'

'The boy, Dallas-'

'Dulles,' I said.

'Dallas, Dulles, whatever-he's out of harm's way?'

'Doing very well,' Robelon said. Hoyt, Taggart, and Irizzary all nodded up and down, like a row of bobble-head dolls.

'Let's put this over till the beginning of October. I try and allocute him today, and he'll come back wanting to withdraw the plea. It'll be a complete waste of time.'

I didn't have a prayer in this skirmish, but there was one more fact for the court to know. 'Your Honor, are you aware that this incident-this charade-happened less than two blocks away from my home?'

'You really are over the top, Alex,' Robelon said quietly before standing up again to address the court. 'Judge Moffett, this attack happened a block away from the Frick Museum, it happened a block away from the Ukrainian embassy, it happened a block away from the Nineteenth Precinct. Fortunately, none of the occupants of those buildings has any reason to be paranoid either. We don't have martial law in this city, do we? Mr. Tripping was enjoying an evening on the Upper East Side.'

'He told the police, Your Honor, that he was coming to find me. I think you know I'm not an alarmist about these things, but it is quite disturbing to think the defendant believed he had any legitimate reason to be talking to me.'

'Is that true, sir? You couldn't wait for this morning to see Ms. Cooper?'

Robelon leaned over and grabbed Tripping's arm, telling him not to answer. He straightened back up. 'My client says that's absolutely ridiculous. That's a lie.'

'October second, nine-thirty sharp. We'll take the plea and you can prepare to be sentenced the same day. Bring your toothpaste and pajamas, Mr. Tripping. No excuses next time.' Moffett looked from the defendant to me. 'You want an order of protection, Ms. Cooper?'

Little good that piece of paper would do if Tripping became unglued. 'An admonition will do, sir. Make it clear if the defendant has anything to say to me, he can do it in the courtroom or through counsel.'

'One last issue, if I may,' Robelon said. 'I had talked to Ms. Cooper about getting her agreement for a single visit between Mr. Tripping and his son. All the doctors believe it would be the healthiest way for them to separate, going forward.'

'Fine,' I said, giving up the fight. 'As long as it's supervised and on the condition that it comes to an abrupt end if the defendant does anything at all to upset the child.'

'Then the last order of business,' Moffett said, 'is for me to dismiss the charges of rape in the first degree against your client, isn't that right, Mr. Robelon.'

'That's correct, Judge.'

I left the courtroom amid the self-congratulatory backslapping of the defense team.

'Where'd Mercer go?' I asked Laura.

'He said to tell you that a Detective Squeeks-did I get that name right?-that Squeeks needed to see him down at the First Precinct on the Vallis murder. Just routine. Wanted to interview him about your original case. Said he'd meet you at Twenty-six Federal Plaza for your noon appointment.'

The detectives on the Vallis case were certainly working hard to keep me out of the mix.

I took care of a pile of correspondence that had stacked up on my desk, returned a bunch of nonurgent phone calls, and gathered up some of the Tripping memos from my file cabinet so that I could write a closing report while I was in the country. I encouraged my assistants to cover their tails with paperwork. There were always bizarre defendants-like Andrew Tripping-who were bound to revisit the system at some future point in time, and it was smart to leave documentation of why an earlier case had been dismissed.

As I assembled a case folder to take with me, I came across Dulles's Yankees jacket in the rear of my file drawer. Returning it to me had been a last act of kindness by Paige Vallis that I had hoped to use to warm my introduction to the boy. I stuffed it in a folder to return to Robelon or Hoyt, now that I would not need to interview him.

'I'm probably going to go right from this meeting to the airport, Laura. I'll be on the Vineyard for the next