“Will the president and Mrs. Clinton be there tomorrow night?”
“Not sure, but I know they’re invited. I hope so.”
“Let’s clean up this mess and go to sleep.”
I held his face and kissed him on the forehead. “Go inside. This is the part I do really efficiently. I’ll join you in ten minutes.”
By the time I cleared the table, loaded the dishwasher, and straightened up the kitchen, Jake was spread- eagled, face down on the bed. I folded my clothes and placed them in my armoire, slipping in beside him and raising the comforter over us against the soft night wind that always makes my hilltop such an easy place for sleeping. I don’t remember any tossing and turning after my head came to rest on the pillow.
I was startled by the sharp ring of the telephone. Light was just appearing on the horizon as I picked it up and spoke softly into it. It could not have been much later than 6 a.m. “Hello?” I asked somewhat disoriented, perhaps by the hour, perhaps because of too much wine with my dinner.
“Alex, it’s Mercer. The lieutenant insisted on me calling you. Said you raised a stink last time you read it in the newspaper without a heads-up from us.”
“Don’t worry, he’s right. What is it?” I sat up as Jake raised his head and rested it on his elbow, massaging his eyelids with his thumb and middle finger.
“West Side-Eighty-sixth Street. Our man just hit again early this morning, about an hour after midnight. Got a twenty-year-old kid going into her building. Raped her, beat her up pretty bad when she tried to resist. I hate to do this, but can you come on back into town?”
I got out of bed, made the coffee, dressed in jeans and a blazer, and sat on the deck while Jake unpacked his golf clothes from his duffel and got ready to leave the house.
“You sure you don’t want me to go back with you?”
“Of course not. It’s a sin to leave anything as beautiful as all this unless you have to. You’ve got a lot of friends on the Vineyard,” I said, “and tonight, when I finally crawl into my bed at home, it will give me enormous pleasure to close my eyes and think of you being right here, wrapped in my sheets and looking out at this view.
“I’m the one who feels guilty, promising you a weekend together and then flying off-island to go to work.” I was worried that the unpredictability of my job and its all-consuming nature when I was working a big case or a complex trial would put Jacob Tyler off, as it had done other men.
“Hey, if a guy with
The airport was on the way to the golf course, so he dropped me at the terminal, kissed me good-bye, and I promised to be careful and stay in touch. There was no direct service to New York on Saturday morning, so I took the next Cape Air flight to Boston and called the Special Victims office to tell Mercer that I’d be on the ten-thirty shuttle.
With runway delays and air traffic, it was after eleven thirty when I got through the gate at the Marine Air Terminal.
“Sorry, Alex. Sounds like you were planning a nice couple of days. Hate like hell to pull you away from it.”
“You know that’s never a problem. How’s she doing?”
“She’ll be okay. She’s got a lot of guts. Tried her damndest to fight him off. She saw the gun but didn’t think it was real, so-”
“That’s some chance to take,” I said.
“You’re not kidding. She grew up in Florida, around handguns. So she felt pretty comfortable with her guess. Maybe she was right. The guy stuck it back in his waistband and started to pummel her with his fists.”
“Completed rape?”
“Legally, yes. He penetrated but he didn’t ejaculate. So there’ll be no DNA on this one.”
The elements of the crime required penetration of the victim’s vagina, however slight, for the charge to be rape. Most victims had no reason to be aware of this technicality, so many would tell us that the assailant “tried” to rape them but hadn’t completed the assault. In fact, the insertion of the defendant’s penis, whether or not he completed an act of intercourse, was all that was needed, by law, to accomplish the act.
“Where are we going?”
“She’s down at headquarters now, working on a sketch. The lieutenant figured you’d want to get as detailed an interview as soon as possible, so that’s where we’ll do it.”
“What time did she leave the hospital?”
“I got called at home and went over to Roosevelt Hospital at three. Treated and released. Had a head-to-toe exam, and one of the advocates stayed with her the whole time.” The Rape Crisis Intervention Program run by the hospital was one of the best in the city. Like most others, it was underfunded and staffed by volunteers, but the quality of the care and service was superb.
“I took her home so she could clean up and rest for a while, then picked her up at nine this morning to take her to One Police Plaza.”
The NYPD had a unit of detectives whose specialty was the artistic re-creation of likenesses of defendants, the police sketches that were made into Wanted posters and distributed throughout the neighborhood at risk or the city at large. Some preferred to work freehand, and others used computergenerated programs that assigned a particular feature from a description provided by a witness or victim. Every nuance, each subtle distinction, led to a thickening of facial hair or a change in shape of an eyelid. The results in many cases eventually proved to be almost photographic reproductions of the attacker’s face.
In this instance, with a serial rapist, the artists had already produced several composites. And although each one resembled the others, there were variations that were reflective of the circumstances under which each woman saw the man who committed the crime. This witness would add her own detail to the pictures that had already been circulated.
“You think it’s too much for her if I go back over everything with her today? Can she handle it now?” I asked Mercer, trusting his judgment and knowing the sensitivity that he brought to this work.
“I didn’t push her. Thought if you and I did the questioning together at once, we’d get whatever we need, and she’d have to explain it all one less time. She’s game, Alex. Determined to get this guy and put him behind bars forever.” He had pulled away from the curb and we were headed for the Brooklyn-Queens Expressway and the bridge to Manhattan. “I promised her I’d find him and that you’d make sure he never sees daylight again. She’s really eager to talk to you.”
So much had changed in this business, just in my professional lifetime. Women, who had traditionally been reluctant to report cases of sexual violence, were now far more likely to come forward, as society lifted the age- old stigma on victims who cried rape, and began placing the blame where it belonged: on the offender. Still, those who were attacked by strangers and not acquaintances were believed more readily and were far more likely to be victorious in the courtroom. Paul Battaglia, who was passionate about this issue, had devoted resources to prosecuting these cases that no other office in the country could match. Whether the assailant was a date, a relative, a spouse, or a professional colleague of the victim, we had a mandate to vigorously investigate and take to trial the case of any credible witness who deserved her day in court.
“Guess you didn’t get much rest last night,” I said. Mercer looked exhausted. He had worked all week on the Caxton case, which relieved him of other duties at the Special Victims Squad. So he had not caught new cases, but he was still the one they beeped when the West Side rapist struck. He had been assigned to that task force from the outset, and the lieutenant counted on his skill in relating to victims, as well as his ability to remember the similarity in modus operandi-language, actions, order of the sexual acts-that would help coordinate all the cases in the pattern.
He laughed. “First night in weeks I had some companionship in the form of a warm body, other than Chapman. I don’t think I’d been home an hour when I got the call.” He took his eye off the road for a moment to look over at me. “This job can’t do much for your love life either, can it?”
“I’m in no position to complain after you gave me the day off yesterday.” I spent the rest of the ride telling
