and the Ur-reality concealed within. I call it the Divine Dichotomy.'
My father and I nodded thoughtfully. What else could we do?
'To answer your question, Mr. McNally,' Gillsworth continued, addressing mein papa, 'my wife reacted to the letter with complete serenity. You may find it remarkable-I certainly do-but she has absolutely no fear of death, no matter how painful or horrid its coming. She believes death is but another form of existence, that we pass from one state to another with no loss, no diminution of our powers, but rather with increased wisdom and added strength. This belief-which she holds quite sincerely, I assure you-enables her to face her own death with equanimity. And so that letter failed to frighten her-if that was its purpose. But it frightens me, I can tell you that. I suggested to Lydia that it might be wise if she returned to Rhode Island for an extended visit until this whole matter can be cleared up.'
'Yes,' father said, 'I think that would be prudent.'
'She refused,' Gillsworth said. 'I then suggested both of us take a trip, perhaps go abroad for a long tour. Again she refused. She will not allow the ravings of a lunatic to alter her life. And she is quite insistent that the matter not be referred to the police. She accepts the entire situation with a sangfroid that amazes me. I cannot take it so lightly. I finally won her permission to seek your counsel with the understanding that you will make no unauthorized disclosure of this nasty business to the police or anyone else.'
'You may depend on it,' my father said gravely.
'Good,' the poet said. 'Would you care to see the second letter?'
'By all means.'
Gillsworth rose and took a white envelope from his outside jacket pocket. He strode across the room and handed it to my father.
'Just a moment, please,' I said. 'Mr. Gillsworth, I presume only you and your wife have touched the letter since it was received.'
'That's correct.'
'Father,' I said, 'I suggest you handle it carefully, perhaps by the corners. The time may come when we might wish to have it dusted for fingerprints.'
He nodded and lifted the flap of the opened envelope with the tip of a steel letter opener taken from his desk. He used the same implement to tease out the letter and unfold it on his desktop. He adjusted the green glass shade of his brass student lamp and began to read. I moved behind his shoulder and peered but, without my reading glasses, saw nothing but a blur.
Father finished his perusal and looked up at the man standing before his desk. 'You did not exaggerate, Mr. Gillsworth,' he said, his voice tight.
'Would you read it aloud, sir?' I asked him. 'I'm afraid I left my glasses upstairs.'
He read it in unemotional tones that did nothing to lessen the shock of those words. I shall not repeat the letter lest I offend your sensibilities. Suffice to say it was as odious as Gillsworth had said: a naked threat of vicious murder. The letter was triple-dis-tilled hatred.
Father concluded his reading. The client and I returned to our chairs. The three of us, shaken by hearing those despicable words spoken aloud, sat in silence. The pater looked at me, and I knew what he was thinking. But he'd never say it, never dent my ego in the presence of a third person. That's why I loved him, the old badger. So I said it for him.
'Mr. Gillsworth,' I said as earnestly as I could, 'I must tell you in all honesty that although I appreciate your confidence in me, I am beyond my depth on this. It requires an investigation by the local police, post office inspectors, and possibly the FBI. Sending a threat of physical harm through the mail is a federal offense. The letter should be analyzed by experts: the typewriter used, the paper, psychological profile of the writer, and so forth. It's possible that similar letters have been received by other Palm Beach residents, and yours may provide a vital lead to the person responsible. I urge you to take this to the proper authorities as soon as you can.'
My father looked at me approvingly. 'I fully concur with Archy's opinion,' he said to Gillsworth. 'This is a matter for the police.'
'No,' the poet said stonily. 'Impossible. Lydia has expressly forbidden it, and I cannot flout her wishes.'
Now my father's glance at me was despairing. I knew he was close to rejecting Gillsworth's appeal for help, even if it meant losing a client.
'Mr. Gillsworth,' I said, leaning toward him, 'would you be willing to do this: Allow me to meet and talk with your wife. Let me try to convince her how seriously my father and I take this threat. Perhaps I can persuade her that it really would be best to ask the authorities for help.'
He stared at me an excessively long time. 'Very well,' he said finally. 'I don't think it will do a damned bit of good, but it's worth a try.'
'Archy can be very persuasive,' my father said dryly. 'May we keep the letter, Mr. Gillsworth?'
The poet nodded and rose to leave. Handshakes all around. My father carefully slid the opened letter into a clean manila file folder and handed it to me. Then he walked Roderick Gillsworth out to his car. I carried the folder up to my cave and flipped on the desk lamp.
I put on my glasses and read the letter. It was just awful stuff. But that wasn't what stunned me. I saw it was on good quality paper, had been written with a word processor, and had an even right-hand margin.
How does that grab you?
3
I went to sleep that evening convinced that the Peaches letter and the Gillsworth letter had been written on the same machine, if not by the same miscreant. But what the snatching of a cranky cat had to do with a murderous threat against a poet's wife, the deponent kneweth not.
I awoke the next morning full of p. and v., eager to devote a day to detecting and sorry I lacked a meerschaum pipe and deerstalker cap. Unfortunately I also awoke an hour late, and by the time I traipsed downstairs my father had left for the office in his Lexus and mother and Ursi had taken the Ford to go provisioning. Jamie Olson was seated in the kitchen, slurping from a mug of black coffee.
We exchanged matutinal greetings, and Jamie- our houseman and Ursi's husband-asked if I wanted a 'solid' breakfast. Jamie is a septuagenarian with a teenager's appetite. His idea of a 'solid' breakfast is four eggs over with home fries, pork sausages, a deck of rye toast, and a quart of black coffee-with maybe a dram of aquavit added for flavor. I settled for a glass of OJ, buttered bagel, and a cup of his coffee-strong enough to numb one's tonsils.
'Jamie,' I said, sitting across the table from him, 'do you know Leon Medallion, the Willigans' butler?'
'Uh-huh,' he said.
Our Swedish-born houseman was so laconic he made Gary Cooper sound like a chatterbox. But Jamie had an encyclopedic knowledge of local scandals-past, present, and those likely to occur. Most of his information came from the corps of Palm Beach servants, who enjoyed trading tidbits of gossip about their employers. It was partial recompense for tedious hours spent shining the master's polo boots or polishing milady's gems.
'You ever hear anything freaky about Leon?' I asked. 'Like he might be inclined to pinch a few pennies from Mrs. Willigan's purse or perhaps take a kickback from their butcher?'
'Nope.'
'How about the cook and the maid? Also straight?'
Jamie nodded.
'I know Harry Willigan strays from the hearth,' I said. 'Everyone knows that. What about his missus? Does she ever kick over the traces?'
The houseman slowly packed and lighted his pipe, an old discolored briar, the stem wound with adhesive tape. 'Mebbe,' he said. 'I heard some hints.'
'Well, if you learn anything definite, pass it along to me, please. Their cat's been swiped.'
'I know.'
'Have you heard anything about the Gillsworths, the poet and his wife?'
'She's got the money,' Jamie said.
'That I know.'
