Luke went blank. “I don’t know. They never appeared.”
Simon eyed him. “Could the steps have been running away?”
“They might have been – I don’t know.”
“Tell us all that happened,” Simon said.
“I admit I came to see Agnes; I had just got to the cloister when I heard steps and saw Denise. She was drunk, so I left her, and when she returned to the frater I went up the alley to meet Agnes, but there was a noise behind me. It worried me and I hurried to the chamber and tripped. When I realised…” Luke paused, scarcely able to go on, then: “I screamed and ran out, but I heard people coming. I didn’t know what to do! I went to the frater’s wall and hid behind a buttress. When you sent to question Denise I slipped away.” He faced the prioress. “Lady Elizabeth, Moll had told Katerine about Margherita embezzling priory funds. That was why Margherita killed them both. Agnes found out too.”
“She told you this?” Margherita demanded. “It is not true!”
“Prove it! Swear it before God, on the gospels, on His cross.”
Margherita stepped to the altar and rested her hand on the book. Meeting Luke’s gaze, she declaimed loudly so all could hear: “I had nothing to do with the death of the novice Moll, the novice Katerine or the novice Agnes. I had no part as an accomplice, nor as the instigator of any one or all of their deaths.”
“Bitch!” he swore, making the sign of the cross. “You dare lie on God’s own book?”
“Enough!” Lady Elizabeth snapped.
Simon had remained silent, surveying the pallid priest. Now he nodded towards Luke. “Do you dare declare your innocence in the same way?”
Luke immediately stepped up to the altar. As he did so, Margherita moved quickly out of his reach. So that there could be no doubt of his conviction, Luke picked up the book reverently and kissed the symbol of the cross on its calfskin cover, then rested it on his left palm, his right hand flat over the top. “I declare my innocence of the killing of any of these novices. I affirm my innocence in the sight of this congregation and in the sight of God, and if I am guilty in any way of any of these deaths, if I knowingly or unknowingly took any active part in them, if I persuaded or incited or aided or abetted any person in these murders, may God strike me dead here and now. As I believe in the resurrection and the life to come, I had nothing to do with these deaths.”
“And that,” Simon observed grimly, “leaves us much better informed, doesn’t it?”
Chapter Twenty-Four
Bertrand was called to the cloister as soon as the convent had finished Prime. Simon left him closeted with the prioress, and strode off to the infirmary to allow Hugh, who was nodding with the effort of standing guard, to take his own rest. Simon was happier spending his time mulling over the events of the evening while sitting next to Baldwin. For some strange reason, Simon was sure his friend was in danger. Intuition told him so.
Meanwhile, he could come to no logical conclusion about the trio of murders. No matter how he reviewed the affair he could see no connection between the dead girls that made any sense. Moll was ultra-religious, a bit of a pain, by all accounts, who took everyone else’s guilt on her own shoulders and informed them of their offences to make them confess and gain forgiveness; Katerine was nosy, pushy, keen to get on, and unscrupulous, prepared to use blackmail to achieve her ends; Agnes appeared unconcerned by the priory and the people within it, she was simply a child who probably shouldn’t have been put there in the first place. Certainly she wasn’t religiously driven.
Simon had heard one thing the previous night that had intrigued him: the wild allegation made by Luke to the effect that Margherita had been creaming off the income and profits from the priory. It was hard to credit that a nun would do such a thing, but looking at the state of the place it was all too easy to believe that someone had been fleecing it.
Margherita had always appeared coldly contemplative, a very genuine Christian, yet he realised that although the treasurer had denied any part in the murders, she had not denied the charge of embezzlement. If his reasoning was correct, and she wouldn’t swear before God to innocence of theft, clearly the fact that she was happy to do so regarding the murders meant she was telling the truth about them.
So he was no further forward, he thought with a heavy sigh.
Baldwin groaned, and Simon leaned forward. “How are you feeling?”
“As if someone’s trying to cut through my skull with a rusty saw,” Baldwin said with his eyes tight shut.
Simon chuckled and passed Baldwin the pot of wine, which the knight soon emptied.
“I doubt it’ll stay down,” the knight said, resettling himself on his side. “I feel like you do after a night drinking all my wine and ale.”
“At least the wound’s healing,” Simon said, his tone gentle.
“I can assure you that from my perspective it appears to be getting worse,” Baldwin said drily. “How does your enquiry progress?”
Simon gave him a doubtful look. “Constance said you should rest.”
“Don’t be a fool. I need something to take my mind off this!” Baldwin hissed painfully.
“All right. Well – there was another murder last night.”
“God’s teeth!”
Simon told all he had learned the previous day, finishing with the discovery of Agnes’s body. “The prioress has locked up Luke and Elias, thinking that a man who dares enter the convent against God’s laws would be capable of murder,” he said.
Baldwin snorted feebly. “By the same token she should arrest herself! She too must be suspect for she once had an affair and got pregnant. No, that is rubbish. And of course we can assume that Elias was innocent.”
Their voices had woken Hugh. “But he was found there!” the servant objected sleepily.
“Precisely Whoever killed the girl would have run. No one would have stood about waiting to be discovered. Luke is a different matter, of course.”
“Except,” Simon interrupted, “Luke had no dagger on him. Come to that, neither did Elias. So where was the murder weapon?“
“What of Margherita?” Baldwin enquired.
“She wasn’t searched,” Simon admitted shamefacedly.
“Wonderful!” Baldwin muttered. He remained staring up at the beams of the roof for a few minutes. “All this makes little sense, especially if we take my own wound into account. Three girls, all very different, and me as well. There must be some kind of pattern to all four attacks; something that ties us together.”
Simon gave his friend a smile of sympathy. “The last thing you need right now is to fret about something like this, and I need to get on as well.”
“Why? What are you going to do?”
“I’m going to ask Margherita what she saw last night.”
Simon left Hugh once more guarding Baldwin. Already, before Simon left the infirmary, Baldwin was sleeping again, and as the bailiff opened the door to the landing, Constance appeared at the top of the stairs.
“Sister, could you tell me where the treasurer is likely to be?” he asked, and she told him to look in the cloister.
Her eyes were red and raw from weeping, and even as he studied her, he saw her blink to keep the tears at bay.
It was this sign of her distress that made him touch her shoulder. She took a quick pace back on feeling his hand, and stared at him with alarm, but he smiled. “Sister, don’t fear. I am sure Agnes died quickly.”
“It wasn’t her I was thinking of,” Constance said. She sadly let her head drop forward, feeling ridiculously feeble. It was mere mawkishness to pine for him. “It was Elias… Oh, Bailiff – do you think he could have killed them?”
Simon gazed at her blankly. “Elias? No, not really. Why do you ask that?”
“I gave him dwale to keep the prioress’s dog silent when he came to visit me,” she said, colouring. “I thought he could have dropped some into Moll’s drink, and then he could have thrown Katerine from the roof, and
