Lassiter

64 Never Let Them See Your Fear

The next morning, I drove north on 27th Avenue and passed under the Dolphin Expressway, headed toward the Justice Building. Robert Plant and Alison Krauss were pounding out “Gone, Gone, Gone,” and the world was tilted crazily on its axis.

“Because you done me wrong.”

At precisely ten A.M., the bailiff escorted Charlie Ziegler from the corridor to the witness stand. The saddlebags under Ziegler’s eyes seemed puffier today, and a mini-bandage on his chin looked like the aftermath of a shaving accident. Sleepless night? Shaky hands?

He avoided my gaze on his walk past the bar. I wasn’t offended. He didn’t look at Alex Castiel, either. But he shot a glance at the jury.

Next to me, Amy Larkin seemed composed, her hands folded primly in her lap. I had never encountered a defendant so damned placid when facing life without parole.

Castiel took his star witness around the track slowly at first, establishing his background in the “adult entertainment industry,” so that my cross-exam would not come as a dirty little surprise to the jury.

Then Castiel moved to the stalking and the threats. Yes, Ziegler had observed the defendant on a neighbor’s property, watching him. Yes, he had seen her in the lobby of his office building. “Loitering and surveilling,” in Castiel’s words.

“Do you recall an occasion on which you received a phone call from Mr. Lassiter concerning his client?” Castiel asked.

“If you’re talking about the incident at the gun range, yes, I do,” Ziegler said.

“What occasioned that conversation?”

“I had made a proposal to Mr. Lassiter to set up a fund to search for Ms. Larkin’s sister.”

Sounding noble, indeed.

“So you thought that’s what he was calling about?”

“Yes, but he said-”

“Objection, hearsay,” I called out.

“May we approach?” Castiel said.

Judge Melvia Duckworth waved us forward, and we trekked to the bench for a sidebar, out of earshot of the jury. “Your question clearly appears to call for a hearsay answer, Mr. Castiel.”

“I’d submit that Mr. Lassiter’s response was an ‘excited utterance’ and therefore an exception to the hearsay rule.”

“Let’s hear a proffer,” the judge ordered.

“Mr. Lassiter replied that Ms. Larkin would rather, quote, ‘empty a clip into your gut than take your money,’ close quote,” Castiel recited.

The judge raised her eyebrows and turned to me.

“I wasn’t excited,” I said.

“Your Honor,” Castiel hopped in, “the defendant had just shot out all the tires on Mr. Lassiter’s car.”

“Three tires,” I corrected him.

“Mr. Lassiter immediately called Mr. Ziegler to warn him that Amy Larkin was armed and coming after him. The evidence code defines an ‘excited utterance’ as one immediately following a startling event in which the declarant is under stress and is excited. Clearly, this falls under the rule.”

“I wasn’t excited,” I repeated, drily. “I was calm and rational. As I recall, I was thinking about whether I should buy four new tires and not just three. It seemed a prudent thing to do, given balancing and rotation and tread wear.”

“Objection overruled,” the judge declared.

We resumed our places, and Ziegler repeated my regrettable words: “Mr. Lassiter said, ‘She’s got a gun, and she’s headed your way.’ Or something to that effect.”

The jurors’ eyes switched from the witness to my client. Grave looks. I didn’t like that. Not one bit.

Castiel moved to the night of the shooting. An assistant handled the projection gear, showing the solarium, the broken window, and what would be the grand finale, the body of Max Perlow. Castiel methodically paced Ziegler through the moments leading up to the murder. A noise outside. The two men walk into the solarium. Perlow waddles up to the window, approaches the glass, and ka-boom, ka-boom. Then the money question.

“Did you, Mr. Ziegler, see who fired the gunshots?”

The jurors leaned forward in their chairs. I clenched a pencil.

Ziegler spoke clearly into the microphone. “I saw a figure outside.”

“Can you identify that figure?”

“Not really,” Ziegler said.

Castiel’s eyes flickered. “Not really?”

“It wasn’t the woman sitting next to Mr. Lassiter,” Ziegler said. “It wasn’t Amy Larkin. I can tell you that.”

I’ll be damned. Just as Amy said, Ziegler was doing the right thing. Assuming it was the truth.

A ripple of murmurs moved through the gallery. Jurors exchanged looks.

Castiel fixed his face into a mask of Zen-like equanimity. He knew the first rule of trial work: Never let them see your fear. “Now, Mr. Ziegler, do you recall giving a statement to homicide detectives?”

“Amy Larkin is tall and thin,” Ziegler said, ignoring the question. “The shooter was bigger, stockier. It was definitely a man.”

A couple jurors exchanged whispers.

“So that it’s clear, Mr. Ziegler, your testimony directly contradicts your statement to the police, isn’t that correct?”

“I’d just seen Max shot and was very upset.”

Castiel stayed calm and did not raise his voice. He’d been doing this too long to pee his pants over a recanting witness. “When you gave your statement to homicide detectives at the scene, the shooting was fresh in your mind, was it not?”

“With Amy Larkin stalking me, there was some sort of mental suggestion that it must have been her.”

“ ‘Mental suggestion’?” Castiel sounded amused.

“Like if you know someone has a green car, if you see a green car, you think it must be them.”

“Was this mental suggestion, this green-car syndrome, still preying on your mind when you repeated your identification in a written affidavit?”

“It must have been.”

“And when you and I met prior to your deposition, you again confirmed your earlier statements, correct?”

“Yes, sir.”

“More green-car syndrome?”

“I guess I’d convinced myself.”

“When Mr. Lassiter deposed you under oath prior to trial, what did you say then?”

“Same deal. But I was wrong.”

Ziegler was trying to exonerate Amy, I thought. Only problem, he looked like he was trying. There was something artificial and pre-packaged about the recantation.

Castiel picked up the wooden pointer he’d used to highlight diagrams of the house and pool deck. He might have wanted to flail his witness with the pointer, but he merely wagged it like a parent scolding a child. “You’ve been upset ever since Ms. Larkin came to town and made those accusations against you, haven’t you?”

“She accused me of a crime I didn’t commit, so yeah, I was steamed. Probably the way she feels right now.”

That zinger brought a sharp look from Castiel, but he kept his voice even and untroubled. He made a show of