draped over the chair Rolfe had warned me about.
Rolfe had said Gilman was a lawyer, so I wasn't surprised when he asked to see my identification. I explained that I had resigned from the police force some years earlier. He raised an eyebrow at this news and flicked a glance at Rolfe.
'I'm involved in this at the request of Barbara Ettinger's father,' I went on. 'He's asked me to investigate.'
'But why? The killer's been caught, hasn't he?'
'There's some question about that.'
'Oh?'
I told him that Louis Pinell had an unbreakable alibi for the day of Barbara Ettinger's murder.
'Then someone else killed her,' he said at once. 'Unless the alibi turns out to be unfounded. That would explain the father's interest, wouldn't it? He probably suspects-well, he could suspect anyone at all. I hope you won't take it amiss if I call him to confirm that you're here as his emissary?'
'He may be hard to reach.' I had kept London's card and I got it out of my wallet. 'He's probably left the office by now, and I wouldn't think he's arrived home yet. He lives alone, his wife died a couple years ago, so he most likely takes his meals at restaurants.'
Gilman looked at the card for a moment, then handed it back. I watched his face and could see him make up his mind. 'Oh, well,' he said. 'I can't see the harm in talking with you, Mr. Scudder. It's not as though I knew anything substantial. It was all a fair amount of years ago, wasn't it? A lot of water under the bridge since then, or over the dam, or wherever it goes.' His blue eyes brightened. 'Speaking of liquid, we generally have a drink about now. Will you join us?'
'Thank you.'
'We generally mix up some martinis. Unless there's something else you'd prefer?'
'Martinis hit me a little hard,' I said. 'I think I'd better stick with whiskey. Bourbon, if you've got it.'
Of course they had it. They had Wild Turkey, which is a cut or two better than what I'm used to, and Rolfe gave me five or six ounces of it in a cut-crystal Old Fashioned glass. He poured Bombay gin into a pitcher, added ice cubes and a spoonful of vermouth, stirred gently and strained the blend into a pair of glasses that were mates to mine. Donald Gilman raised his glass and proposed a toast to Friday, and we drank to that.
I wound up sitting where Rolfe had had me sit earlier. Rolfe sat as before on the rug, his knees drawn up and his arms locked around them.
He was still wearing the jeans and shirt he'd put on to introduce me to Judy Fairborn. His weights and jump rope were out of sight. Gilman sat on the edge of the uncomfortable chair and leaned forward, looking down into his glass, then looking up at me.
'I was trying to remember the day she died,' he said. 'It's difficult.
I didn't come home from the office that day. I had drinks with someone after work, and then dinner out, and I think I went to a party in the Village. It's not important. The point is that I didn't get home until the following morning. I knew what to expect when I got here because I read the morning paper with my breakfast. No, that's wrong. I remember that I bought the News because it's easier to manage on the train, the business of turning the pages and all. The headline was Icepick Killer Strikes in Brooklyn, or words to that effect. I believe there had been a previous killing in Brooklyn.'
'The fourth victim. In Sheepshead Bay.'
'Then I turned to page three, I suppose it must have been, and there was the story. No photograph, but the name and address, of course, and that was unmistakable.' He put a hand to his chest. 'I remember how I felt. It was incredibly shocking. You don't expect that sort of thing to happen to someone you know. And it made me feel so vulnerable myself, you know. It happened in this building. I felt that before I felt the sense of loss one feels over the death of a friend.'
'How well did you know the Ettingers?'
'Reasonably well. They were a couple, of course, and most of their social interaction was with other couples. But they were right across the hall and I'd have them in for drinks or coffee from time to time, or they'd ask me over. I had one or two parties that they came to, but they didn't stay very long. I think they were comfortable enough with gay people, but not in great quantity. I can understand that. One doesn't like to be overwhelmingly outnumbered, does one? It's only natural to feel self-conscious.'
'Were they happy?'
The question pulled him back to the Ettingers and he frowned, weighing his answer. 'I suppose he's a suspect,' he said. 'The spouse always is. Have you met him?'
'No.'
' 'Were they happy?' The question's inevitable, but who can ever answer it? They seemed happy. Most couples do, and most couples ultimately break up, and when they do their friends are invariably surprised because they seemed so bloody happy.' He finished his drink.
'I think they were happy enough. She was expecting a child when she was killed.'
'I know.'
'I hadn't known it. I only learned after her death.' He made a little circle with the empty glass, and Rolfe got gracefully to his feet and replenished Gilman's drink. While he was up he poured me another Wild Turkey. I was feeling the first one a little bit so I took it easy on the second.
Gilman said, 'I thought it might have steadied her.'
'The baby?'
'Yes.'
