'None of my brother's actions is for nothing,' Alia said.
Irulan picked up a scribe, gripped it with white-knuckled intensity. Paul saw her marshal emotional control in the Bene Gesserit way: the penetrating inward stare, deep breathing. He could almost hear her repeating the litany. Presently, she said: 'What have we gained?'
'We've kept the Guild off balance,' Chani said.
'We want to avoid a showdown confrontation with our enemies,' Alia said. 'We have no special desire to kill them. There's enough butchery going on under the Atreides banner.'
She feels it, too, Paul thought. Strange, what a sense of compelling responsibility they both felt for that brawling, idolatrous universe with its ecstasies of tranquility and wild motion. Must we protect them from themselves? he wondered. They play with nothingness every moment - empty lives, empty words. They ask too much of me. His throat felt tight and full. How many moments would he lose? What sons? What dreams? Was it worth the price his vision had revealed? Who would ask the living of some far distant future, who would say to them: 'But for Muad'dib, you would not be here.'
'Denying them their melange would solve nothing,' Chani said. 'So the Guild's navigators would lose their ability to see into timespace. Your Sisters of the Bene Gesserit would lose their truthsense. Some people might die before their time. Communication would break down. Who could be blamed?'
'They wouldn't let it come to that,' Irulan said.
'Wouldn't they?' Chani asked. 'Why not? Who could blame the Guild? They'd be helpless, demonstrably so.'
'We'll sign the treaty as it stands,' Paul said.
'M'Lord,' Stilgar said, concentrating on his hands, 'there is a question in our minds.'
'Yes?' Paul gave the old Fremen his full attention.
'You have certain... powers,' Stilgar said. 'Can you not locate the Entente despite the Guild?'
Powers! Paul thought. Stilgar couldn't just say: 'You're prescient. Can't you trace a path in the future that leads to Tupile?'
Paul looked at the golden surface of the table. Always the same problem: How could he express the limits of the inexpressible? Should he speak of fragmentation, the natural destiny of all power? How could someone who'd never experienced the spice change of prescience conceive an awareness containing no localized spacetime, no personal image-vector nor associated sensory captives?
He looked at Alia, found her attention on Irulan. Alia sensed his movement, glanced at him, nodded toward Irulan. Ahhh, yes: any answer they gave would find its way into one of Irulan's special reports to the Bene Gesserit. They never gave up seeking an answer to their kwisatz haderach.
Stilgar, though, deserved an answer of some kind. For that matter, so did Irulan.
'The uninitiated try to conceive of prescience as obeying a Natural Law,' Paul said. He steepled his hands in front of him. 'But it'd be just as correct to say it's heaven speaking to us, that being able to read the future is a harmonious act of man's being. In other words, prediction is a natural consequence in the wave of the present. It wears the guise of nature, you see. But such powers cannot be used from an attitude that prestates aims and purposes. Does a chip caught in the wave say where it's going? There's no cause and effect in the oracle. Causes become occasions of convections and confluences, places where the currents meet. Accepting prescience, you fill your being with concepts repugnant to the intellect. Your intellectual consciousness, therefore, rejects them. In rejecting, intellect becomes a part of the processes, and is subjugated.'
'You cannot do it?' Stilgar asked.
'Were I to seek Tupile with prescience,' Paul said, speaking directly to Irulan, 'this might hide Tupile.'
'Chaos!' Irulan protested. 'It has no... no... consistency.'
'I did say it obeys no Natural Law,' Paul said.
'Then there are limits to what you can see or do with your powers?' Irulan asked.
Before Paul could answer, Alia said: 'Dear Irulan, prescience has no limits. Not consistent? Consistency isn't a necessary aspect of the universe.'
'But he said...'
'How can my brother give you explicit information about the limits of something which has no limits? The boundaries escape the intellect.'
That was a nasty thing for Alia to do, Paul thought. It would alarm Irulan, who had such a careful consciousness, so dependent upon values derived from precise limits. His gaze went to Korba, who sat in a pose of religious reverie - listening with the soul. How could the Qizarate use this exchange? More religious mystery? Something to evoke awe? No doubt.
'Then you'll sign the treaty in its present form?' Stilgar asked.
Paul smiled. The issue of the oracle, by Stilgar's judgment, had been closed. Stilgar aimed only at victory, not at discovering truth. Peace, justice and a sound coinage - these anchored Stilgar's universe. He wanted something visible and real - a signature on a treaty.
'I'll sign it,' Paul said.
Stilgar took up a fresh folder. 'The latest communication from our field commanders in Sector Ixian speaks of agitation for a constitution.' The old Fremen glanced at Chani, who shrugged.
Irulan, who had closed her eyes and put both hands to her forehead in mnemonic impressment, opened her eyes, studied Paul intently.
'The Ixian Confederacy offers submission,' Stilgar said, 'but their negotiators question the amount of the Imperial Tax which they -'
'They want a legal limit to my Imperial will,' Paul said. 'Who would govern me, the Landsraad or CHOAM?'
Stilgar removed from the folder a note on instroy paper. 'One of our agents sent this memorandum from a caucus of the CHOAM minority.' He read the cipher in a flat voice: 'The Throne must be stopped in its attempt at a power monopoly. We must tell the truth about the Atreides, how he maneuvers behind the triple sham of Landsraad legislation, religious sanction and bureaucratic efficiency.' He pushed the note back into the folder.
'A constitution,' Chani murmured.
Paul glanced at her, back to Stilgar. Thus the Jihad falters, Paul thought, but not soon enough to save me. The thought produced emotional tensions. He remembered his earliest visions of the Jihad-to-be, the terror and revulsion he'd experienced. Now, of course, he knew visions of greater terrors. He had lived with the real violence. He had seen his Fremen, charged with mystical strength, sweep all before them in the religious war. The Jihad gained a new perspective. It was finite, of course, a brief spasm when measured against eternity, but beyond lay horrors to overshadow anything in the past.
All in my name, Paul thought.
'Perhaps they could be given the form of a constitution,' Chani suggested. 'It needn't be actual.'
'Deceit is a tool of statecraft,' Irulan agreed.
'There are limits to power, as those who put their hopes in a constitution always discover,' Paul said.
Korba straightened from his reverent pose. 'M'Lord?'
'Yes?' And Paul thought. Here now! Here's one who may harbor secret sympathies for an imagined rule of Law.
'We could begin with a religious constitution,' Korba said, 'something for the faithful who -'
'No!' Paul snapped. 'We will make this an Order in Council. Are you recording this, Irulan?'
'Yes, m'Lord,' Irulan said, voice frigid with dislike for the menial role he forced upon her.
'Constitutions become the ultimate tyranny,' Paul said. 'They're organized power on such a scale as to be overwhelming. The constitution is social power mobilized and it has no conscience. It can crush the highest and the lowest, removing all dignity and individuality. It has an unstable balance point and no limitations. I, however, have limitations. In my desire to provide an ultimate protection for my people, I forbid a constitution. Order in Council, this date, etcetera, etcetera.'
'What of the Ixian concern about the tax, m'Lord?' Stilgar asked.
Paul forced his attention away from the brooding, angry look on Korba's face, said: 'You've a proposal, Stil?'
'We must have control of taxes, Sire.'
'Our price to the Guild for my signature on the Tupile Treaty,' Paul said, 'is the submission of the Ixian
