Next Door Neighbor

I went on, saying 'Now, it's starting to get a little late, and I still have to go to work tomorrow. Now, I've just told you that Robyn would win, given enough time. Will you accept that?'

Sandra and Lucy both nodded. Robyn was still a little too distracted.

'Then given that Robyn would win, AND I need to get some sleep tonight – all of us do, I think! – What I'd like to propose is that you three – particularly Robyn – let me be more than an active partner, now. Is that acceptable?'

This time, all three were able to express agreement.

'Then if Robyn is willing, I'd like to try something new with her.'

Lucy looked at me, then at Robyn, curiosity on her face. Robyn looked at me, and asked 'What?'

I gazed into her eyes, and asked 'You know how much you've liked it when I've put a finger in your butt?' – here, Lucy looked at me in surprise, as Robyn nodded – 'What I'd like to try – ONLY if YOU'RE willing to! – is making love to you that way.'

Lucy gave me another look, then watched Robyn intently, as did Sandra.

Robyn thought about it for a little bit, and then said, 'Uh, yeah, I think I'd like to try that!' much to Lucy's surprise, as well as Sandra's. Lucy turned and looked at me, but didn't any more than get her mouth open before Robyn interrupted her to say, 'Mom, it's okay.

I know he's not going to just*rape* me, or anything, and so do you.

It*does* feel good to me when he puts his finger in me. From what Sandra and I saw, it does for you, too. If it hurts or anything, I know he'll stop, and we can try something else – I mean, we're having fun here, and I trust him not to be upset or anything if he's the only one that doesn't come tonight. Don't you?'

That pulled Lucy up short, real quick. She looked at me hard, and I told her 'You know damn well that what she just said is true. And I'll tell it to you again, just to make sure: under NO circumstances would I do ANYTHING to hurt Robyn. Or You. Or Sandra. If anything about this starts to bother her, that's the end of it – I stop it right then and there. Keeping both of you – all of you! – happy and healthy means more to me than just getting my rocks off. If I had *any* thought that*anything* I wanted to do was going to hurt her, do you really think I'd ask in FRONT of you?'

At that, Lucy turned back to Robyn and said 'Honey, I've already done that – I mean, have somebody make love to me in my butt. Yes, it felt good to me. If you want, I can do it FOR you, and you can wait to try it when you're a little older, and a little bigger, okay?'

Robyn just looked back at her, levelly, and answered, 'I understand, Mom, really, I do. But this is something that I really want to do.

Uh, I was already thinking about asking him to do it sometime, even before tonight.'

That set Lucy – and me! – back a bit before Robyn went on to say 'I really mean it when I say that it feels good to me when he puts his finger there. I*like* it, and I want to know what it's like to have him make love to me that way. I'm not afraid of it; I*trust* him – I know that if it starts to hurt, even a little bit, he'll stop and not be mad or anything.'

Lucy looked at her closely, and saw that Robyn was being completely honest and truthful with her – and determined to at least give it a try.

That settled, Lucy got up, saying 'Well, if that's the way it is, then I guess I'd better get some lotion, or baby oil, or something.'

Robyn smiled at her in reassurance, then looked at Sandra, who was all but staring at her. Robyn asked her 'What's the matter?'

Sandra hesitated a moment, then said 'Uh, isn't that kinda, you know, gross?'

'Why?'

'I mean, it's your BUTT!'

'So? Didn't you think it was kinda gross when I told you about using your mouth?'

Sandra nodded, reluctantly, and Robyn went on 'Didn't you think it was kinda gross when I told you about having a guy inside you, and shooting his stuff?'

Again, Sandra admitted it.

'If you hadn't at least*tried* that stuff, you would have been missing out, wouldn't you?'

Sandra nodded before Robyn went on 'Okay, so maybe it'll hurt. If it does, he'll stop, and I can try again later if I want. MAYBE it'll turn out I don't like it as much as I think I will. If that happens, then at least I*KNOW*. But not to try it at all? That doesn't do anything.'

By this time, Lucy had returned with a small bottle of baby oil, telling us 'I use this to keep my skin soft on the road. I think it'll do the trick.'

Robyn told her 'It's okay, Mom. I'm sure it'll be fine. Don't worry, okay? It'll all be fine, you'll see.'

With that, Robyn eased herself off of me, and letting me sit up. She moved up to sit on my lap, facing me, before asking, 'Okay, so what do we do now?'

I looked deep in her eyes as I told her 'First thing, I tell you that this is ONLY and idea. You DON'T have to do any of it – if you're not sure, if you're nervous, if there's ANY question or doubt in your mind, then we can stop right here and right now, and I'll still love you and still be happy to make love with you any other way you like.'

She smiled at me, and answered, 'I know that, silly. Really, I was going to ask you about this, anyway. I'm nervous about doing it right, but not afraid, you know what I mean?'

I nodded, and answered, 'Yeah, I think I do. The other thing I want to tell you is that if it starts to hurt, or feel uncomfortable, or anything else like that, TELL ME. I don't know what you're feeling unless you SAY SOMETHING, okay?'

She nodded solemnly, and I went on 'This is the first time you'll do this, so if you don't want anybody watching, I'm sure they'll understand, right?', the last part directed to Lucy and Sandra, who both quickly nodded their agreement.

Robyn looked at them, too, and said, 'It's okay. It actually kinda makes me even hornier knowing that they'll be watching!', with a faint blush.

With that revelation, I told her 'Okay, then here's what we're looking at happening. First, we make sure you're nice and excited.

Then we get you and me all slippery, to make things easier. Then I get behind you and we find out if I'll fit without hurting you. The first time a man is inside you there, it will be a lot like the first time a guy was inside you the other way – if things can get started, I'll wait whenever you tell me to, so you can stretch there, just like you had to stretch the other way. If it starts to hurt, we stop – NOBODY here wants you to get hurt because you tried to do this too soon, okay?'

She nodded, and I hugged her to me, whispering in her ear 'Robyn, I'm serious. I don't want to hurt you even by accident, so TELL me, dammit!' She quietly nodded her understanding, and we separated.

I looked at Sandra and Lucy, and told them 'Instead of you two just sitting there and making us nervous, how about if you help?'

'How?' Lucy asked.

'Well, you just heard me tell Robyn that both of us need to get slicked up – how about one of you does Robyn and the other does me, while Robyn and I make out?', I asked, with a smile.

'I'll do Robyn!', Sandra quickly said, while Lucy looked at me and smiled.

Robyn and I got on our knees, and started kissing and hugging; Sandra took the baby oil and put a little on her hand before rubbing it onto Robyn's ass. I heard Lucy say, 'Sandra, I think she'll need more than that – and you know where. Let me get some towels, so we don't mess up the bed.'

With that, Sandra poured even more oil on her hand, and started to work it between Robyn's asscheeks – and getting Robyn turned on, in the process. A few moments later, Lucy was back, and managed to get a couple of the hotels large bath towels spread out on the bed, and nudged Robyn and I onto them. That accomplished, she waited for Sandra to pour out another puddle of oil, and then took the bottle to get some into her own cupped palm. Then she slowly reached out to wrap her hand around my erection before beginning to stroke its length to spread the oil around.

As the two of them got more and more into their duties, Robyn and I continued to kiss and touch each other, making each other more and more excited.

Finally, Robyn broke the kiss to say, 'I think that's enough oil – I can feel it running down the inside of my legs!' I agreed with her, since I could feel what Lucy had applied starting to trickle down my scrotum. When I