Sup With the Devil

“Never to the point that he didn’t know what he was doing!”

“But to the point that he wouldn’t wake up if someone else put a bloodied knife into his hand? What is it Lady Macbeth says? I’ll gild the faces of the grooms withal . . .”

“But no one would!” protested Horace. “George hadn’t an enemy in the world!” He got awkwardly to his feet and gallantly helped Abigail to rise.

Not even the man George kept at his beck and call for four years, away from family and friends, only for his convenience in a foreign town? An American born and bred, gentlemanly and intelligent and kind, who had to sleep on the floor and live out of a chest the size of a breadbox, so that he was there to ‘make him mind his book,’ keep him away from unsuitable ladies, and wake him up in time for chapel?

It was the first thing the Middlesex County sheriff was going to say.

“It doesn’t take a plot, or a lifelong foe, to do murder,” she said quietly. “Only a moment’s rage. Let us go and see what we can learn.”

The entire student body of Harvard—some two hundred young men and boys between the ages of fifteen and twenty-five—were either milling around the westernmost hallway of Massachusetts Hall or pushing their way up and down Horace’s staircase. Horace bleated, “Here, let me through—I have rooms up here— Please let me through . . .” to absolutely no effect.

Abigail caught the first brightly colored sleeve that came her way, yanked it purposefully, and said in a voice honed by six years of dealing with young Johnny at home, “Excuse me, sir, I am Mr. Fairfield’s aunt—I beg your pardon, sir, but I am a member of the family—Please let us pass—” in so firm a tone that the young men so addressed either backed down out of the staircase or, farther up, squashed themselves flat against the wall. Abigail’s normal conversational tones were brisk but soft, yet at need she could call up a particular timbre of voice that could cut flint. “I beg your pardon, we must get through—Please excuse us, sir, but we’re members of the family—”

In Fairfield’s study, men were packed tight, all of them shouting at the slumped form of Diomede, who huddled in a chair in the corner with a harassed-looking man in a blue coat before him, whom Abigail recognized— from years of association with John’s legal practice—as Seth Congreve, sheriff of Middlesex County. Diomede was shaking his head, saying, “I don’t remember, sir! I don’t know—” He raised his hands, sticky now with drying blood that blotched and boltered the white sleeves of his shirt. “I swear I didn’t—drunk or sober, I’d never have touched a hair of his head!”

His clothing stank of blood and rum, and tears of shock ran down his face.

“So you’re saying you’re so drunk you didn’t even hear—Can you gentlemen please be silent!—So you didn’t hear your master arguing with some other man—someone whom you weren’t even aware was in the room?”

“He could have been,” barked St-John Pugh. “I warned George about that nigger’s drinking . . .”

And the weasel-like sophomore Jasmine Blossom demanded sarcastically, “You were so drunk you didn’t even wake for a man walking in bold as paint and stabbing your master after a quarrel loud enough to wake the Injun? Oh, let me have another story, Papa, it’s not nearly bedtime yet!”

“Mr. Pugh,” said Abigail briskly, “would you and your friends be so good as to assist Mr. Congreve in clearing the room a little? One can scarcely do justice if one isn’t able to hear oneself think. Mr. Ryland, just the man I wished to see—Might you detail some of the King’s Own Volunteers to eject anyone not immediately connected with the investigation? Thank you—Mr. Pugh is also assisting me . . . Deputize whom you will—”

“Yes!” Congreve swung around with a gesture of a man with a sack of corn beset by pigeons. “All of you, out of here—Mrs. Adams!” he added in surprise. “What on earth—?”

“I was working with Mr. Fairfield,” she said, “on a strange little puzzle that involved him and his friends; I am horrified to hear of this. And of course Mr. Adams will undertake to defend poor Diomede, who quite obviously had no more to do with the killing than Mr. Ryland or Mr. Pugh—You there, Mr. Yeovil, are you associated with the sheriff? No? Then please take yourself out—”

“What puzzle?” asked the sheriff, as Ryland pushed past him into the bedroom—even more crowded— beyond. “And why ‘obviously’?”

“A man who’s drunk so much that he doesn’t know what he’s doing is unlikely to win a hand-to-hand fight with a sober one,” she retorted briskly, though she was not, in fact, at all certain that this was true. “Certainly not as swiftly as this battle proceeded, in any case. Mr. Ryland, could you ask Mr. Beaverbrook to remain, and of course Mr. Wylie—” It took her a moment to remember Weyountah’s baptismal name. “Is there a physician here?”

“Mr. Perry.” Congreve nodded toward the bedroom door, then turned toward the task of ejecting the last of the stragglers. “Mr. Perry teaches medicine here at the college.”

“Mr. Pugh,” called Abigail, “might I prevail upon you to keep guard at the bottom of the staircase with your men? Thank you,” she added, not giving the bachelor-fellow a chance to say yes or no. “You have been of inestimable assistance—” She caught him by the sleeve and thrust him through the door and into the faces of Lowth and Jasmine, just reascending after pushing the last of their fellow classmates out at the bottom of the stair. She closed the door on him, reopened it long enough for Ryland and another young man whom she vaguely recognized as one of the younger members of the Oliver family—relatives of the Governor—to push out the last few observers, then closed it behind them all.

Harvard men—and raised in the best traditions of good manners—they clearly had been taught that one doesn’t push back against a lady, and weren’t quite sure how to deal with one who summarily ordered them out the door.

“There,” she said, and walked back to the corner where Sheriff Congreve still stood—looking rather amused —beside Diomede. “It wants but a little firmness—and getting the right people to think they’re going to receive more than their due. Might I speak with the prisoner, Mr. Congreve? I truly cannot imagine the man would turn against his master—and Mr. Adams will want to know every detail I can glean.”

“And Mr. Adams sent you out here?” He sounded doubtful about that, as well he might. Being a lawyer’s clerk required an education, something Abigail was sharply conscious that neither she nor any other woman was allowed to obtain. Nor would she or any other woman have been permitted to exercise the skills of a lawyer if she somehow acquired them. And a lawyer who sent out a woman—much less his wife!—to do a man’s work would have been, quite simply, committing professional suicide.

Abigail lowered her voice, though the little study was now empty except for themselves, Diomede, Horace, and a pale and rather wizened-looking young man who was probably Mr. Beaverbrook, who lived immediately above this room. “The matter upon which Mr. Fairfield asked to see me,” she explained—And it isn’t QUITE a lie, she reasoned, as the poor young man really did consult me for my opinion once he knew what was taking place—“was, we had thought, a family matter concerning my nephew Mr. Thaxter, and for this reason I hesitate to speak of it without consulting Mr. Adams. Whether it has any bearing upon this shocking turn of events or not, I have no idea, but Mr. Adams will certainly undertake to defend Diomede, whom we both know would never have done such a thing.”

On the other side of the table, the servant raised his head, the first flash of life returning to his eyes that Abigail had seen since she had come into the room. The first flash of hope.

She went on as if it were the most natural thing in the world, “The family side of the business not being completed, Mr. Fairfield paid to have me stay in Cambridge last night, at the Golden Stair. I will of course write at once to Mr. Adams, who is at the Maine Assizes this week, and to his clerk in Boston, Mr. John Thaxter, who graduated from here last year. But I know Mr. Adams will want to know the precise details of the scene, as they were before the rooms were disturbed, and will also want to know everything that can be recollected by both the witnesses and the accused—which as you know yourself can become very quickly distorted with the passage of time.”

Congreve nodded and scratched at the edge of his wig—horsehair, Abigail guessed, and probably vastly uncomfortable: she could see the little rim of reddened flesh all around its edge where it irritated the skin. He said, “I see. And that’s perfectly all right, Mrs. Adams—a very respectable gentleman, your husband is, and a fine lawyer. Mr. Langdon—”

He turned to the waspish, red-faced gentleman—resplendent in a red doctor’s gown barred with black velvet and a startling full-bottomed wig—who appeared in the door of the bedchamber.