Death and the Maiden

don’t stay at home in August. I should think he expected to find the boy at Alresford, and is keeping his hand in now until he can get at the kid.’

‘But – keep his hand in? That’s insane!’

‘Well, isn’t the naiad insane? It’s all of a piece!’

Chapter Eighteen

‘“Nay, nay, she’s none drownded,” said Mr Tulliver. “You’ve been naughty to her, I doubt, Tom?”’

GEORGE ELIOT (The Mill on the Floss)

A MONTH later Mrs Bradley and Laura were in London, and the papers were in possession of a curious story. A naiad, it was reported, had been seen in the River Itchen not far from Winchester; this on the apparently unimpeachable evidence of three respectable citizens.

‘Crete!’ said Laura, handing Mrs Bradley the newspaper. ‘They must have gone back to Winchester to kill Arthur Preece-Harvard. We’d better get down there at once!’

‘Do you think so?’ Mrs Bradley enquired. ‘I am inclined to agree that the naiad must be Mrs Tidson. It seems a strange thing for her to have done. One would imagine that the last thing the Tidsons would want would be to attract attention to their presence in Winchester if they mean to kill Arthur Preece-Harvard.’

‘Well, the naiad has greenish hair. It says so here,’ said Laura. She stood behind Mrs Bradley’s chair and pointed to the description of the visitant. ‘Don’t you think we ought to go down and interview these people who say they saw her?’

‘No doubt your Mr Gavin will do that, but, if you want to hear their story at first-hand, why don’t you go alone to Winchester to see them? I can’t come with you just now.’

‘May I? Oh, good. I couldn’t—’ She glanced at Mrs Bradley’s day book, which was on the consulting-room table – ‘I suppose I couldn’t go to-day?’

‘Why not?’ Mrs Bradley comfortably replied. ‘I am called away to Hereford to see what Doctor Watson would call a noble bachelor, and there is no reason for you to stay here by yourself. Henri and Celestine can manage. Off you go, child. There’s a train in an hour. You might catch it.’

‘A jolly good thing Connie wouldn’t come and stay with us,’ said Laura, ‘or one of us would have had to take her along.’

‘She showed the natural repugnance to us,’ said Mrs Bradley, ‘for which I was prepared. I have warned Miss Carmody to keep a strict eye on her movements, but I confess that I should have felt a good deal easier in my mind if Connie had been under our jurisdiction for a bit. Still, it is always a difficult task to save people from themselves. So much so that I sometimes wonder whether the laws of Providence regard as a supremely immoral action any attempt to do it.’

‘Funny that Connie had so much to say about that job, and is still with Miss Carmody,’ said Laura. ‘I suppose you worked it.’

‘I don’t think Connie ever had a job,’ said Mrs Bradley, not for the first time.

The report on the naiad, by the time that Laura reached Winchester, had not received any additions. The creature had been seen twice, each time in the same stretch of water, once by two city councillors walking together, and once by a District Visitor who reported her at once to the police. Laura went out, accompanied by Gavin, to inspect that part of the Itchen in which she had been seen.

They took the now familiar path at the bottom of College Walk, passed through the white wicket-gate, and slackened their rate of walking as they rounded the grassy space where the river made its bend and the stream on the College side of the path ran straight and shallow beside them. They passed the College playing-fields, and the boggy meadows between the swift streams widened.

Thick cresses, darkly, succulently green, the water-mint, the purple loosestrife, seemed a fitting border to the grey-bright floods that were said to house the naiad. The lance-leaved, saw-toothed hemp agrimony, crowding its corymbs at the head of its three-foot stems, was dwarfed by the mighty hogweed, coarse and hairy. The handsome, purple-tinged angelica, with hollow stem, set off and did not diminish the water-level charm of the wild forget-me- not, still blooming at the end of its season. Dark crimson self-heal, square-stemmed, longlipped (the carpenter’s herb, the curative Prunella), reared above purple-edged bracts its dimorphic flowers.

‘Queer about Connie Carmody and the dog,’ said Gavin suddenly. ‘I keep on thinking about it.’

‘I suppose,’ began Laura; and then, urged by some instinct to protect her own sex from the enemy, she stopped short.

‘Go on,’ said Gavin encouragingly. ‘After all, we know who did the murders. But the dog is just a bit odd. Could Connie Carmody be bats, and is that why Mrs Bradley wanted to keep an eye on her and have her in her house for a bit?’

‘I don’t think it’s that,’ said Laura. ‘It was directly Connie had killed the dog, I think, that she gave up all idea of kidding us. She’d killed old Tidson by proxy, I suppose, and she could put up with him after that. Tidson got her worked up about Arthur, and that’s why she ran away from here. She brooded a good bit, and came back and slaughtered his dog.’

‘And then came over all regretful?’

‘No. Only all sick. She didn’t regret what she’d done.’

‘Not a dog-lover, you would say?’

‘No. Only a Tidson-hater, according to Mrs Croc.’

‘But why the dog in that particular spot?’

‘Oh, practice makes perfect, and that’s what Mrs Croc’s afraid of.’

‘I don’t get it.’ Gavin looked at her suspiciously.

‘Neither do I,’ said Laura lightly.

‘You don’t think the old lady is leading us up the garden, and that Connie killed those boys after all?’

‘Good Lord, of course I don’t!’

‘She could have used the same stone, you see, and that would account for the fact that we’ve found only one with prints on it,’ said Gavin.

‘Then what about the absence of prints in Mr Tidson’s room?’

‘I admit that’s a snag. And yet, you see, it’s such a pointer, too.’

‘The lesser of two evils, I expect. Or, at least, the lesser of two obvious risks.’

‘Yes. You know, Laura, this case annoys me a bit. He hasn’t really been so very intelligent, has he? And yet he’s held us up completely.’

‘Comes of having no accomplices, you know. You can get away with most things if you know how to keep your mouth shut and can pick the right time to perform.’

‘Crete must be in his confidence.’

‘Not entirely. They don’t get on too well. But partly, I think. She seems to act as the naiad when he wishes.’

‘In any case, she couldn’t give evidence against him, so I suppose it wouldn’t matter what she did – that is, from one point of view.’

‘It would matter if she gave other people ideas!’

‘What do you suppose is the idea behind this naiad business? Crete being the naiad, I mean.’

‘I don’t know, I’m sure.’ She chuckled. ‘It might be a different idea at different times, don’t you think? If I had to make a guess, I should say that this time it’s to blackleg old Tidson and give away his presence in the vicinity. I doubt whether Crete is a villain. I think she’s just an extravagant cat.’

‘Without much conscience, I should say.’

‘Well, that goes with extravagance.’

‘I don’t know that, of the two of them, I don’t dislike Crete a bit more than old Tidson himself.’