offering his hand. 'I am afraid you are unlikely to have any success,' Campbell continued, glancing at his sister in half apology, then back to Monk. 'Mrs. Gardiner left of her own free will. In the little we know of the circumstances, that seems unarguable. Possibly she was experiencing severe doubts which up to that moment she had managed to conceal. We may never know what suddenly caused her to realize her feelings.' He frowned at Monk. 'I am not convinced that seeking her will not lead to further unhappiness.' He took a deep breath. 'We, none of us, desire that. Please be very careful what you do, Mr. Monk. You may be led, in sincerity, to make discoveries we might be better not knowing. I hope you understand me?'
Monk understood very well. He shared the view. He wished now he had been wise enough to follow his original judgment and refuse the case when Lucius had first asked him.
'I am aware of the possibilities, Mr. Campbell,' he answered quietly. 'I share your opinion that I may not be able to find Mrs. Gardiner, and that if I do, she still might wish to stand by her decision. However, I have given my word to Mr. Stourbridge that I would look for her, and I will do so.' Then, sensing the sharpness in Campbell’s face, he added, 'I have informed him of my opinion as to the chances of success, and I shall continue to be honest with him as to my progress or lack of it.'
Campbell remained silent, pushing his hands into his pockets and staring at the floor.
'Aiden,' Verona said gently. 'I know you believe that she will not return and that only more disillusion and unhappiness will follow from seeking her, but neither Harry nor Lucius will accept that. They both feel compelled to do all they can to find out where she is, if she is unhurt, and why she left. Harry almost certainly for Lucius’s sake, of course, but he is nonetheless resolved. I believe we should help them, rather than make them feel isolated and as if we do not understand.'
Campbell raised his eyes and looked at her steadily. 'Of course.' He smiled, but the effort behind it was apparent to Monk. 'Of course, my dear. You are perfectly right. It is something which must run its course. How can I assist you, Mr. Monk? Let me take you to the stables and enquire after James Treadwell. He may be at the heart of this.'
Monk accepted, thanking Verona and excusing himself. He followed Campbell down the stairs and out of the side door to the mews. The light was bright as he stepped outside. The smells of hay, horse sweat and the sharp sting of manure were strong in the closed heat of the yard. He heard a horse whinnying, and stamping its feet on the stones.
A ginger-haired boy with a brush in one hand looked up at him with curiosity.
'Answer Mr. Monk’s questions, Billy,' Campbell instructed. 'He’s come to help Major Stourbridge find Treadwell and the missing carriage.'
'Yer in’t never goin’ ter see them again, I reckon,' Billy replied, pulling his mouth into a grimace of disgust. 'Carriage like that’s worth a fair bit.'
'You think he sold it and went off?' Monk asked.
Billy regarded him with contempt. ' ’Course I do. Wot else? ’E lit outta ’ere like ’e were on fire! Nobody never told ’im ter. ’E never came back. If ’e din’t flog it, w’y in’t ’e ’ere?'
'Perhaps he met with an accident?' Monk suggested.
'That don’t answer w’y ’e went in the first place.' Billy stared at him defiantly. 'Less ’e’s dead, ’e should ’a told us wot ’appened, shouldn’t ’e?'
'Unless he’s too badly hurt,' Monk continued the argument.
Billy’s eyes narrowed. 'You a friend of ’is, then?'
'I’ve never met him. I wanted your opinion, which obviously was not very high.'
Billy hesitated. 'Well—can’t say as I like ’im,' he hedged. 'On the other ’and, can’t say as I know anythink bad abaht ’im, neither. Just that he’s gorn, like—which is bad enough.'
'And Mrs. Gardiner?' Monk asked.
Billy let his breath out in a sigh. 'She were a real nice lady, she were. If ’e done anythink to ’er, I ’ope as ’e’s dead—an’ ’orrible dead at that.'
'Do you not think she went with him willingly?'
Billy glanced at Campbell, then at Monk, his face registering his incredulity. 'Wot’d a lady like ’er be wantin’ with a shifty article like ’im? ’Ceptin’ to drive ’er abaht now an’ then, as wot is ’is job!'
'Did she think he was a shifty article?'
Billy thought for a moment. 'Well, p’haps she din’t. A bit too nice for ’er own good, she were. Innocent, like, if yer know wot I mean?'
'Mrs. Gardiner was a trifle too familiar with the servants, Mr. Monk,' Campbell clarified. 'She may well have been unable to judge his character. I daresay no one told her Treadwell was employed largely because he was a relative to the cook, who is highly regarded.' He smiled, biting his lip. 'Good cooks are a blessing no household discards lightly, and she has been loyal to the family since before my sister’s time.' He looked around the stable towards the empty space where the carriage should have been. 'The fact remains, Treadwell is gone, and so is a very valuable coach and pair, and all the harness.'
'Has it been reported to the police?' Monk asked.
Campbell pushed his hands into his pockets, swaying a little onto his heels. 'Not yet. Frankly, Mr. Monk, I think it unlikely my brother-in-law will do that. He makes a great show, for Lucius’s sake, of believing that Mrs. Gardiner had not met some accident, or crisis, and all will be explained satisfactorily. I am afraid I gravely doubt it. I can think of no such circumstance which would satisfy the facts as we know them.' He started to walk away from the stable across the yard and towards the garden, out of earshot of Billy and whoever else might be in the vicinity. Monk followed, and they were on the gravel path surrounding the lawn before Campbell continued.
'I very much fear that the answer may prove to be simply that Mrs. Gardiner, who was very charming and attractive in her manner, but nonetheless not of Lucius background, realized that after the first flame of romance wore off she would never make him happy, or fit into his life. Rather than face explanations which would be distressing, and knowing that both Lucius and Major Stourbridge, as a matter of honor, would try to change her mind, she took the matter out of their hands, and simply fled.'
