'Did you know the late Mr. Gardiner well?'
'Knew ’im in passing, like. A very decent sort o’ gent.'
'Indeed. But quite a lot older than his wife—his widow?'
The man’s face darkened. 'What are you tryin’ ter say?'
Tobias shrugged. 'What did James Treadwell try to say?'
'Nothing!' Now the man was plainly angry.
'You did not like him?' Tobias pressed.
'I did not!'
'No love for blackmailers?'
'No I ’aven’t! Nor ’as any man fit ter walk an’ breathe God’s good air. Filth, they are.'
Tobias nodded. 'A feeling shared by many.' He glanced up at the dock, then back to the witness box.
Rathbone knew perfectly well what he was doing, but he was helpless to stop him.
'Of course.' Tobias smiled deprecatingly. 'Treadwell may have been asking his questions about Mrs. Gardiner in loyal interest of his employer, Mr. Stourbridge, in order to prevent him from making an unfortunate marriage. Did that possibility occur to you? It may not have been for purposes of blackmail at all.'
Rathbone stood up at last. 'My lord, the witness is not in a position to know why Treadwell asked questions, and his opinion is surely irrelevant. Unless Mr. Tobias is implying he may have had some part in Treadwell’s death?'
There was a sharp stir in the courtroom, and one of the jurors jerked up his head.
'Quite,' the judge agreed. 'Mr. Tobias, do not imperil your case by wandering too far afield. I am sure your point has already been taken. James Treadwell asked questions in the neighborhood regarding Mrs. Gardiner’s character and reputation. Is that all you wish us to know?'
'For the moment, my lord.' Tobias thanked his witness and turned invitingly to Rathbone.
Again there was nothing for him to ask. The witness had already made it plain he admired Miriam and was partisan in her favor. As far as he was concerned, Treadwell had met with a fate he deserved. It would not help either Miriam or Cleo to hear him say so again.
'I have nothing to ask this witness,' Rathbone said.
Tobias proceeded to call the Stourbridges’ servants to tell their account of the day of the party and Miriam’s still-unexplained departure with Treadwell. The parlormaid had seen it all and told of it simply and obviously with great unhappiness.
At last Rathbone had something to ask.
'Miss Pembroke,' he said with a slight smile, moving into the center of the floor and looking up at her where she stood high in the witness stand. 'You have told very clearly what you saw. You must have had a view of Mrs. Gardiner with no one blocking your way.'
'Yes sir, I did.'
'You said she seemed about to faint, as if she had suffered a great shock, and then after she had recovered herself she turned and ran, even fled, from the garden towards the stables. Is that correct?'
'Yes sir.'
The judge frowned.
Rathbone hurried on before he should be cautioned to come to the point.
'Did anyone speak to her, pass her anything?'
'You mean a glass, sir? I didn’t see no one.'
'No, I meant rather more like a message, something to account for her shock and, from what you describe, even terror.'
'No sir, no one came that close to her. And I don’t think she had a glass.'
'You are not certain about the glass, but you are sure no one spoke to her or passed her anything?'
'Yes, I am.'
'Have you any idea what caused her to run away?'
Tobias rose.
'No,' the judge said to him bluntly. 'Miss Pembroke is an observant girl. She may very well know what happened. It has been my experience that servants frequently know a good deal more than some of us would believe, or wish to believe.' He turned to the witness stand. 'Do you know what caused Mrs. Gardiner’s flight, Miss Pembroke? If you do, this is the appropriate time and place to say so, whether it was a confidence or not.'
'No sir, I don’t know, an’ that’s the truth. But I never seen anyone look as dreadful as she did that day. She looked like she’d seen the living dead, she did.'
'Do you know where Treadwell was during the party?' Rathbone asked.
'In the stables, sir, same as always.'
'So Mrs. Gardiner went to him—he did not come to her?'
