I entered a subdivision called Shady Oaks. Not a single oak tree in the entire place. A large number of “For Sale” signs were planted on front lawns. Nearly half the houses looked empty.
Passing a street called Whisper Lane, Buster got animated. He stuck his head out the window and began pawing his seat. I looked around to see if there was another dog in the area, but didn’t see any.
“What is it, boy? You smell something?”
Buster’s head was firmly stuck out his window. Backing up, I turned down Whisper Lane. A dog’s sense of smell was a thousand times more sensitive than a human’s, and my dog let out a mournful whine.
I braked at a two-story Spanish-style home with a “For Sale” sign on the lawn. The house was under construction, and looked half-finished. I leashed Buster and got out of the car. He pulled me up the path.
Buster hit the front door with his nose, and it swung open. I didn’t like entering strange houses uninvited, even unfinished ones.
“Hello? Is anyone home?”
My voice echoed across the high-ceilinged foyer. The sweet smell of sawdust hung in the air, mingling with spackle and drying paint. I found it surprising that the house was under construction considering the number of “For Sale” signs I’d seen, but after all, this was south Florida. No matter what state the economy was in, they just kept building.
Buster led me down a hallway to the back of the house. He was straining at his leash and pulling my arm. He had locked onto a scent and was not stopping until he’d found its origin.
The hallway led to a family room, which in turn led to a screened-in lanai. The slider to the lanai was pulled open. I went up to it and stopped. Then I stared.
The lanai contained a swimming pool shaped like a lima bean. The water in the pool was a sickening blood red. Floating in the water were two men, both bloated and very dead. One was missing a sneaker on his left foot.
Buster looked up at me, his tail wagging.
“Good boy,” I said quietly.
I had seen the dead more times than was healthy. Something about these two wasn’t right. After a pause, I realized what it was. Their killer had twisted their heads so they were floating facedown in the water, while their torsos were floating face up.
Protocol would have dictated that I call one of the several detectives that I knew in Homicide, but I wanted Burrell to see the crime scene first, and hear what I had to say. I called her from my car. Fifteen minutes later, she pulled up in her red Mustang with the racing stripes down the sides. It was the kind of car I would have owned if I could afford it. I told her about the dead floaters, and we headed inside.
“Please leave Buster outside,” she said.
“But he found them,” I replied.
“Leave him outside anyway. I don’t want him contaminating the crime scene.”
“He’s not going to piss on anything.”
“Just do it.”
I tied Buster to a tree, then led Burrell inside to the floating corpses. She picked up on the unnatural position of their heads quicker than I had, and turned her eyes away.
“Jesus Christ. Who are they?”
“A couple of druggies. They were mugging people in the parking lot of the Hard Rock, and picked the wrong victim.”
“How did you happen to find them here?”
I told her about my trip to the Hard Rock, and what I’d learned from viewing the casino’s surveillance tapes. When I was done, I removed the two CDs Riddle had burned for me from my pocket.
“The first CD contains a casino surveillance film of a guy named Mouse who was stalking Sara Long,” I said. “The second CD shows Mouse getting mugged by these two guys behind the casino, and what happened to them. Mouse is driving the same minivan that was used to abduct Sara Long. He and his partner are responsible for Sara Long’s abduction, and for killing these guys.”
Burrell stared at the CDs and shook her head.
“You don’t want them?” I asked.
“I’ll just throw them in the file.”
Disgusted, I slipped the CDs back into my pocket.
“I’m sorry, Jack, but more evidence has surfaced linking Tyrone Biggs to the abduction,” Burrell said. “I was in the process of charging Biggs when you called me.”
“What evidence?”
“Biggs secretly made sex tapes of himself and Sara when they were dating. They’re pretty steamy. In one, he’s ties Sara facedown to a bed and has sex with her multiple times. The tapes were found hidden in the trunk of his car.”
“What does that prove beside they were into kink?”
“He was blackmailing her with them.”
“Why? He’s going to be rich once he’s in the NBA.”
“He didn’t want money. He wanted Sara back. Biggs told us so after we confronted him with the tapes. He’s in love with Sara, and wanted to be her boyfriend again.”
“That doesn’t prove Biggs abducted her.”
“Yes, it does. It was his motive. We have our case, and we’re moving forward with it.”
“You’re making a mistake.”
“I don’t work for you anymore, Jack. Don’t lecture me.”
Burrell and I did not argue well, and our arguments often ended with one of us getting our feelings bruised. She took out her cell phone and called for backup, then called EMS. Folding her phone, she gave me a harsh look.
“I’m going to play devil’s advocate,” she said. “Let’s pretend you’re right, and the goons that killed these two guys are Sara Long’s abductors. Tell me what their motive is. Are they kidnappers?”
“No,” I said.
“Serial killers?”
I shook my head.
“Then what are they?”
“Serial abductors.”
“You still think this is linked to that cold case from eighteen years ago that you never solved?”
“Yes, I do.”
“All right, let’s pretend that these guys are serial abductors. What’s their motive? Why did they abduct that college student from her apartment when you were a rookie? And why did they abduct Sara Long?”
“I don’t know. But I’m going to find out.”
“Look all you want, Jack. No one’s stopping you.”
“You’re still going to arrest Tyrone Biggs?”
“Damn straight. Then I’m going to grill him, and find out where he put Sara Long. Biggs killed Sara, and I want to know where he hid her body.”
Outside I heard the wail of sirens. As a rule, police cruisers only came quickly when another cop was making the call. Burrell walked out of the lanai, and stopped at the entrance to the hallway.
“Without any real evidence that someone else abducted Sara Long, you’ve got nothing, Jack,” Burrell said.
I gazed at the bloated corpses floating in the pool. I’d just given Burrell all the evidence she needed, only she’d chosen not to look at it. I was done with the police.
CHAPTER 17
I sat on a chair in the empty room, and gave my statement to a Homicide detective, who wrote it down on a
