“Oh, but please sit down, both of you.”
We resumed our places, and Mr. Sarton squeezed round us to situate himself behind the desk.
“Forgive me,” he said, ”for the mistake on the date of your arrival. I’d got a letter from the Lord Chief Justice telling me that you were on your way and that I was to cooperate with you in any and all ways which you might require. He did not name a date or a day, but said, rather, ‘in two days’ time.’ You arrived only a day later.”
“Ah well,” said Sir John, ”Lord Mansfield gave me the loan of his coach-and-four to make the trip down here. And his driver seems to go everywhere at full gallop.”
”That then was no doubt the root of the misunderstanding.
“No doubt, but dear God, Mr. Sarton, did he truly say that you were to cooperate in any and all ways which I might require?”
“Those may not have been his exact words, but they are as I remember them.”
“Then he has made it sound appallingly like a court-martial.”
Mr. Sarton stared at him for a moment, saying nothing. Then: ”Is that not the nature of your inquiry?”
Thus it came Sir John’s turn to maintain a solemn quiet. ”No sir,” said he after near a minute of cold silence, ”it is not. I have not the authority to act as a one-man tribunal in judgment upon you. I would not want such authority. I am here in answer to a complaint regarding the manner in which you have discharged your duties. I am here, to put it another way, to inquire into your methods and their effectiveness.”
“Who made this complaint? Or have I not the right to know?”
“If you expect me to reject your question as impertinent, I must disappoint you. The identity of the accuser is indeed pertinent. A man has the right to face him who sullies his name, else we are all to be in mortal dread of every manner of rumor, false witness, and he which is told of us. And so you may know that the complaint against you was made by George Eccles, Chief Customs Officer for east Kent.”
“Eccles, is it! Indeed, I should have known. He has been against me from near the start. With what, specifically, has he charged me?”
“He has said that you are either corrupt in the discharge of your office, or the most incompetent ever in the history of the magistracy.”
“But … the specifics, the incidents?”
“He gave none.” Sir John paused. ”Let me assure you,
Mr. Sarton, that Lord Mansfield, to whom the complaint was made, would not have taken Eccles’s complaint seriously but for his position; nor would he have sent me down to look into these matters had he himself not taken a personal interest in you here in Deal.”
“I … I know that he was quite instrumental in getting me this post,” said he, faltering for the first time. ”And for that I am still grateful, though a little less, perhaps, today than when I received the appointment.”
“What have been your relations with this man Eccles?”
“Not good, I should say. As Chief Customs Officer for this part of Kent, he has at his disposal a considerable force of men-over sixty at Dover Castle, where he has his headquarters, and more scattered in various towns up and down the coast.”
“How many in Deal?”
“Twenty, I believe. They are quartered at Deal Castle and report to the local customs officer, a man with whom I’ve cultivated good relations. My difficulties have been with his chief.”
He hesitated, frowned, and traced a pattern upon the desktop with his finger as he sought words to continue.
“Like most country magistrates, I have but two constables at my command,” said he, resuming. ”You, I believe, have a greater force-the Bow Street Runners, they are called.”
“I have been fortunate in that regard, yes, and that is because those in the government who apportion money wish to feel themselves safe in London,” said Sir John, ”And by the bye, though my constables be greater in number, they can never be sufficient to the task. London, it seems, will never be truly safe.”
“Be that as it may, sir, would you care to hazard a guess as to how many here in my jurisdiction in Deal are involved in the smuggling trade?”
“I couldn’t possibly put a number on it.”
”No less,” said Mr. Sarton, pausing for effect, ”than two hundred.”
It took Sir John a moment to respond. ”So many? I had not thought it could be so many.”
“I trust the figure,” said the young magistrate, ”for it was given me by the local customs officer, who grew up in Deal and has helped me on numerous occasions in ways his chief, Eccles, would never do.”
“Yes, Eccles-let us get back to you and your difficulties with him.”
“Yes, of course. Because these two constables are expected to keep order in the town and enforce the laws of the realm, et cetera, they are an insufficient number, pitifully insufficient, to do much to put down the smuggling trade here in this district. I saw that immediately I came here. And so I journeyed off to Dover to ask Mr. Eccles’s aid in patrolling the beaches known to be used by the smugglers. He said no, it was out of the question, for there was work enough to be done in the Dover area. But surely, said I, he could spare us at least a part of the force of customs men quartered here in Deal. Again no, said Mr. Eccles, for they had their duties to perform and could not be spared from them. There was no arguing with the man-I tried, but to no avail. He simply would give me no help whatever. And now, I learn from you, Sir John, that he has had the cold gall to accuse me of incompetence or corruption in the discharge of my duties.”
Mr. Sarton ended somewhat breathless. He could say little more in his own defense. And to me it seemed that little more need be said. Indeed I wondered if we might not return to London this very day. But Sir John seemed to have more in mind.
“Have you had no success in combating … what is it they call it here?”
“The owling trade. Yes, I have had-just once. It came through a tip given me by Sir Simon Grenville. He had heard through his servants at the manor house of the scheduled arrival of a shipment from France of wines and brandy on a certain night of the new moon. They made the crossing in one of those galleys which are built on the quiet right in Deal. I understand that they can make it here from Dunkirk, with twenty men rowing, in five hours’ time. They have a shallow draft and can land upon Goodwin Sands or most of the other beaches in the district. And with so many men working, they can be unloaded in no time at all. So there was no point trying to confront them on the beach. We three-my two constables and me-would have been hopelessly out-manned and out- gunned.”
He was warming to the subject, putting a good deal of drama into the telling of his tale.
“That was wise of you,” said Sir John. ”What then did you do?”
“Why, we waited till their two wagons were loaded and had started up the hill, and the galley was departed from the beach. We kept our silence and were well hidden, for we sorely needed the advantage that surprise would give us. We were but three in number, after all. We waited and waited and waited until they were just upon us.”
Reader, I had become acutely aware of the clock that hung upon the wall behind Mr. Sarton. According to it, I had barely five minutes in which to locate the Good King George in High Street, where I was to meet Mr. Perkins and hear his first report. How could I leave gracefully if Mr. Sarton insisted upon spinning out his story to absurd lengths? Would he never reach the conclusion?
But then, rather abruptly, he did end it: ”And then we jumped out at them and upon their wagons and persuaded them to stop.”
That, it seemed to me, was a weak ending to a strong story. Why had he cut it short? Then did I note the quick footsteps in the hall and saw how our host turned his attention past Sir John and me to the door that lay between us. I turned my attention to it just in time to see the putative Mrs. Sarton appear. She carried a tray, and upon it were three cups and a steaming pot which I took to be filled with dark tea a-brewing. Best of all, I spied a plate of sweet cakes and all manner of dainties, near as tempting to the eye as they would be to the palate. Her husband rose, as did Sir John and I.
“You two have already met my wife, Margaret, I believe.”
“We have,” said Sir John, with a stiff little bow, ”and a pleasure it was indeed.”
“Ah, you’re too kind, sir,” said she to him. ”I’ve just brought along some tea and cakes for all. I believe that talk goes better on a full stomach, don’t you?”
“Absolutely certain of it,” said Sir John.
