and fitted a flashlight bulb into the flash socket. My hands were unsteady and I nearly dropped the bulb.
It didn’t take Joe and his assistants long to strip off the outer casing of the barrel.
While they worked, Creed said to me, ‘It’s the barrel Sperry sold to Flemming. Do you see the strawberry plant holes? She must be in it!’
Joe forced the last of the sodden lathes out of the iron hoop that bound them together. The block of cement, shaped like the barrel, looked gruesome in the hard light.
‘Whoever fixed this, did an expert job,’ he said, stepping back to wipe his forehead. ‘Get me a couple of wedges, Tom.’
I took a flashlight photograph of the cement block as Tom fetched the wedges.
‘Let’s take it easy,’ Joe said, and the two of them began to drive the wedges into the cement. Ten minutes of steady hammering cracked the cement. Joe peered into the crack.
Creed shoved him aside, looked into the opening, grimaced and stepped back.
‘It’s her,’ he said. ‘I can see the spangles on her getup. Okay, Joe, get it open.’
A few more blows with the hammers caused the cement suddenly to fall apart the way an Easter egg will open. I took one look and turned away.
I heard Creed say, ‘She’s all yours, Doc: what’s left of her.’
I was on my way out by then. I have a pretty good stomach, but what I had seen turned me sick. I went into the office, took out the bottle of Scotch and gave myself a big shot.
‘Me too,’ Scaife said, coming in. He took the bottle and half-filled his glass. ‘Phew! I wouldn’t be a croaker for all the money in the world. Well, that settles it. It’s her all right.’
After a few minutes, Creed came in.
I made him a drink; he took it silently and went to sit on the desk by the window. He drank some of the liquor although he didn’t look as if he needed it. His eyes were alight with excitement and satisfaction.
‘Well, at last we’re getting somewhere,’ he said. ‘You two stick around. I’m going to talk to the press. There’s no doubt it’s Fay Benson. The body in there’s got a crooked little finger and so had Fay.’ He finished his drink. ‘Now, we’ll have to find out why she was killed.’
He went out to where a gang of pressmen were waiting impatiently in the yard.
Scaife lit a cigarette.
‘We’re heading for some hard work,’ he said gloomily. ‘We’ve got to find this guy Rutland.’
I reached for the telephone and put through a personal call Bernie in New York. After a ten-minute delay, I got Bernie on the line. The time was now twenty minutes past midnight and I was surprised to catch him in.
‘I can’t stay long,’ he said. ‘Clair’s throwing a party, and I’ve got to keep feeding these vultures with my best whisky. What’s cooking?’
‘Get your notebook,’ I said. ‘I’ve got something hot for you so snap it up.’
‘Won’t it wait until tomorrow morning?’ he asked plaintively. ‘Clair doesn’t like me to leave our guests. Guests, did I say? That’s funny! They’re more like wolves.’
‘Listen, you drink sodden baboon; get your notebook and pin your ears back! We’ve found Fay Benson!’
‘You have? Well, that’s something. How is she?’
‘Wet, cold and very dead. Get your notebook!’
After an infuriating delay, he came back on the line again.
‘Clair’s livid with me,’ he said. ‘For the love of Mike, hurry up.’
‘Shut up about Clair!’ I exclaimed. ‘Listen to what I’m going to tell you.’ I began dictating the story. One of Bernie’s major accomplishments was being able to take down in his own peculiar shorthand, dictation at an incredible speed. I gave him the facts and told him I was putting more photographs on the morning plane. ‘Get someone to meet the plane. This stuffs going to be sensational,’ I concluded.
‘I’ll fix it. I’ll have the whole thing doped out by tomorrow. Nice work, Chet.’
‘Glad you think so. Keep close to the telephone. I’ll have something more for you in a little while. We’re waiting for the doctor’s report.’
‘Don’t call me up any more tonight,’ Bernie said, alarm sounding in his voice. ‘Clair . . .’
‘I know: Clair won’t like it. Phooey to her!’ I snarled and hung up.
Creed came into the room, looking pretty pleased with himself.
‘This is just the story those ghouls like,’ he said, sitting down. ‘We’re going to hit the headlines all right. Doc been in yet?’
Scaife shook his head.
We had to wait another ten minutes before the Medical Officer came in. He looked completely unperturbed as he began to fill his pipe and he shook his head when I offered him a drink.
‘She was killed by a blow on the back of her head. I’d say she was struck by the butt of a revolver: I’ve got nothing else for you. She’s been in the water too long to tell us much. She was dead when the cement was put in.’
Creed got to his feet.
‘Thanks, Doc.’ He looked over at Scaife. ‘Come on; we’ve got work to do.’
As the M.O. followed them, I reached for the telephone and called Bernie again.
II
I looked in to see Creed the next morning soon after eleven o’clock. I had paid my bill at the Shad Hotel, packed my bag and was now ready for the two hundred mile run to Tampa City. Scaife told me Creed was tied up, but he wanted to see me before I left.
‘He won’t be more than twenty minutes. Come in my office. I’ve news for you.’
When I had sat down, Scaife said, ‘You were right. Joan Nichols had a record. She served two years in 1948 for blackmail.’
‘Any details?’
‘It was a particularly mean type of blackmail. One of the girls she was working with in a show had a brother who was in a criminal asylum. His background was pretty grimy and Joan found out about it. She threatened to tell the other girls if this girl didn’t pay her five dollars a week. That was about all the girl could afford as she was keeping her mother. The girl paid up. It went on for six months, then her brother died, and she went to the police. Joan Nichols collected two years.’
‘That’s interesting,’ I said. ‘I wonder if she was blackmailing Fay.’
‘More likely she was blackmailing Rutland. Maybe she and Fay were working together to put the bite on Rutland and he knocked them off.’
I shook my head.
‘I don’t see it that way. Joan’s death was accidental. So was Farmer’s. Following your argument, why wasn’t Fay’s? Why was it so important to get rid of her body so no one would ever find it? You don’t go to the trouble of giving a body a cement overcoat unless it’s urgently necessary for the body not to be found. Why shouldn’t her body be found?’
Scaife stared at me. He hadn’t thought of this angle.
‘Yeah, that’s right,’ he said. ‘They could have knocked her off accidentally just as easily.’
The buzzer on his desk sounded and he got up.
‘That’s the old man. Come on, I know he wants to see you.’
Creed was sitting at his desk, chewing on a cigar. He didn’t look as happy as he had the previous night after he had told the pressmen what a smart guy he was. He was scowling, and he stared at me as if he wasn’t sure if he liked me or not.
‘You’ve certainly started something, Sladen, with your ideas. I’m hanged if I know if I can finish it.’ He waved Scaife out of the room. ‘Okay, we’ve found the body; we’ve killed the killer, but where does that get us? Even the press can see Flemming was hired to kill her, and in a day or so, they’ll begin to put some pressure on me. I’ve got no lead now.’
‘I might turn one up in Tampa City. I’m off right now.’
‘In a way I hope you don’t. It won’t get us anywhere,’ Creed said. ‘I’ve already told you: we have no jurisdiction in Tampa City. We can’t send our men in there. Doonan isn’t cooperative. Ever since he’s been there,
