“Why would you, when the sex wasn’t all that great?”
Rae winced in memory of her crude brush-off. “You seriously took my jab to heart?”
“You sounded damned convincing.”
“I lashed out because…”
“Go on.”
Rae’s heart hammered, knowing she was standing at a crossroad. He was asking her to speak honestly, to bear her heart, which meant setting herself up for disappointment.
“I don’t know where this, us, is going Rae. But I can’t move forward if you keep me in the dark.”
“It was the best sex of my life,” she blurted, “and you ruined it. Your regret was crystal clear. You were disgusted and angry.”
“With myself,” Luke cut in. “You’d been drinking. I took advantage.”
“I wanted it. Wanted you. Sex with you.”
“To get me out of your system.”
She’d had no idea her words had inflicted such hurt. Words spoken in anger in order to salvage her own pride. “If I wanted you out of my system, I wouldn’t have come back to Sugar Creek. I wouldn’t be standing here. I certainly wouldn’t be sharing my feelings.”
Luke held her gaze, nodded. “I’m sorry I didn’t handle things better. After.”
“Me, too. I mean—”
“I know what you mean.” He smiled a little, striking a death blow to her already weak knees. “You okay if I leave for a while?” he asked.
“Did I scare you off?”
“No.” He reached out and caressed her cheek. “But there’s something I need to do.”
Rae’s stomach clenched. “Sam.”
“Sam.”
Luke dialed his cousin as he walked toward his wheels.
“I’m in a meeting, Luke.”
“I need to talk to you. It’s important.”
“I’ll step outside.”
“Needs to be in person.”
“Can it wait?”
“No.” Luke revved his car and tempered his pulse. “Where are you?”
“Moose-a-lotta.”
Luke flashed on an earlier phone call from Rocky. “The emergency CL meeting?”
“Yup.”
Damn. The only thing worse than confronting Sam with his news, was confronting Sam in front of the ladies who’d been rooting for Sam and Rae as a couple for months. “I’ll meet you outside of the cafe in ten.”
Rolling through the slushy streets of Sugar Creek, Luke considered three different openings to this conversation. None of them felt right. By the time he parked in front of Moose-a-lotta he’d resigned himself to a black eye or bruised jaw. If Sam struck out like he’d done once before, Luke wouldn’t fight back. Unless Sam went bat-shit crazy on him. Luke couldn’t see that happening. Then again his judgment had been dicey of late.
Luke zipped his coat and stepped onto the road, bracing for the frigid winds and Sam’s wrath. Spying several familiar faces, including his sister and Gram, peeking through the closed blinds of Moose-a-lotta, Luke groaned. Great. They had an audience. If things got ugly between the two cousins, the Cupcake Lovers would have a front-row seat. He wondered if Daisy had told Sam and everyone about running into Luke and Rae at the hospital. He could almost hear the conjecture and gossip buzzing in his ears. He could feel Rocky’s boot kicking his ass to the curb and out of the club for multiple reasons, but mostly for screwing over their poor widowed cousin.
“I’m guessing this has to do with Rae,” Sam said, making the first play.
“I haven’t been entirely forthright,” Luke said while stuffing his gloved hands in his pockets. “All I can say is, it wasn’t intentional. I didn’t pursue Rae. I didn’t charm or seduce her. Hell, I didn’t even flirt. That first kiss, it went down like I said. Purely innocent. Then, because I was worried about her, I hired Jayce to track her.”
“You flew to Bel Air,” Sam surmised.
“I saw red when I found out who she was and how she’d betrayed us. There was a confrontation and an incident. I didn’t think I’d see her again. I sure as hell didn’t think there was anything between us.”
“But there is.”
“There is.” Luke rocked back on his heels, hunched his shoulders against the biting wind, and wondered if hell was going to freeze over before Sam reacted to the news.
The man just stared.
Most people crumbled under Sam’s famous death glare. But Luke was too primed. Too pissed. It wasn’t his fault that Rae had fallen for him and not Sam. He wasn’t a homewrecker. They’d never been a goddamned couple. “Are you gonna slug me?” Because Luke was suddenly itching to slug back.
“No. I’ll just wait.”
“For what?”
“For you to screw up.”
A haymaker would have hurt less. Luke had always looked up to Sam and before this thing with Rae, he’d been as tight with the man as any of his other cousins. And that was damned tight. The censure stung, but it also torqued Luke’s pride. “What if I don’t screw up, Sam? What if I make a commitment to Rae and follow through?”
“You don’t know jack shit about commitment, Luke.”
“What? Because I’ve never been engaged or married?”
“Hell, you’ve never even been monogamous.”
“You weren’t exactly a Boy Scout before you met Paula.”
“Are you saying you feel for Rae what I felt for my wife?”
“I’m saying we’re involved. Back off, Sam.”
The man warded him off with raised palms as if to say,
Luke didn’t believe that for one minute.
“You coming in for the rest of the meeting?” Sam asked. “We’re discussing key issues regarding the future of the club.”
“Pass.” The sooner he got back to Rae with that fortifying soup, the better.
“Yeah, well, some of us are actually invested in the cause.” Sam turned toward the cafe.
Luke frowned. “When did you turn into such a dick?”
“Around the same day as you.”
SEVENTEEN
“Here he comes!” Rocky tagged Daisy on the shoulder and motioned everyone else away from the window.
“Do you think he knows we were watching?” Ethel asked.
“We weren’t exactly discreet,” Chloe said.
“Luke looked right at me,” Monica said.
“I wish we could have heard what they were saying,” Judy said.
Daisy snorted. “I told you to let me crack the door, but
Chloe shushed everyone as the bell above the door tinkled. They all flopped into chairs as Sam strode inside.
Rocky peered around her cousin, thinking her brother might follow. Even though he was a crappy baker he
