“Well?” His impatience grated against her nerves.
She tried to swallow the lump and stared harder. But all that came was a single slow tear.
Papa, frowning, seized a pen and wrote something. “Read that, then.”
Lily was shaking all over now. Tears blurred her vision, and she could barely see the word he had written. It was short, but still . . .
“C. A. T.—Cat!” her father yelled. “Read it!”
“Cat,” Lily whispered. Her stomach was in knots. She thought she might throw up.
“And what’s this?” He wrote something else, the letters bold and black and fierce-looking. “Read it, come on. It’s not difficult, for God’s sake! It’s three blasted letters! Three!” Tears slid down Lily’s cheeks.
“Stop it! Leave her alone!” Rose burst into the room.
“Stay out of this, Rose.” His voice was mild. Rose was Papa’s favorite.
“No, you’re upsetting her.”
“I’m upsetting her? She’s damned well upsetting me. My own daughter—a Rutherford—unable to read the simplest words!”
“Lily tries the best she can. She can read a little, but standing over her and yelling only upsets her and makes it worse.”
There was a long silence. “So it’s true, then. Your sister cannot read. At ten years of age.”
“She’s nearly twelve,” Rose said quietly. She put her arm around Lily. “You mustn’t blame her. She tries so hard to learn, she’s always tried.”
There was a long silence. “Your mother knew about this and kept it from me?”
Rose nodded. “Mama said it wasn’t Lily’s fault. That it was God’s plan for Lily.”
“To make her an imbecile?”
“She’s not an imbecile,” Rose flashed. “Lily’s not stupid, she just can’t read.”
“Is it her eyes?” He looked at Miss Glass. “Perhaps she needs spectacles.”
“I’ve tested her sight,” the governess said crisply. “She can see perfectly well. She just cannot read. Or do simple arithmetic, or tell her left from her right.”
Slowly, deliberately, Papa pushed Lily away. He wasn’t rough, but she felt a coldness coming from him. “A Rutherford, unable to read.” He looked at Lily as if he’d never seen her before, as if she were no part of him. “Unteachable.”
There was a long silence, then Papa said, “Take her upstairs, Rose.”
Rose and Lily left, but Rose left the door slightly ajar. “Shh,” she whispered. “I want to hear what they say.”
They pressed themselves as close to the door as they dared. There was some low-voiced conversation that Lily didn’t catch and then she heard Papa say, “I assumed she was normal. She can ride like a demon . . .”
They heard the clink of glass as he poured himself a drink. “What do I do with the girl now? No man will want a wife who can’t read.”
“Don’t worry, you can live with me when I’m married,” Rose whispered. Lily gave her a troubled look. She loved Rose, but . . .
“There are discreet institutions . . .” Miss Glass murmured.
Lily shivered. She didn’t know what a discreet institution was, but it sounded horrid. She loved her home. She didn’t want to be sent anywhere. They waited breathlessly for Papa’s response.
“No,” Papa said heavily. “I couldn’t do that to her. She might be an embarrassment to the family but she’s a good enough little soul.”
An embarrassment to the family? Lily’s throat closed.
Papa spoke again. “Now that their mother’s gone, someone must take them on. I don’t have time for children, let alone girls.”
“No self-respecting governess would bother with a child like that,” Miss Glass said. “A good school might take her—illiterate or not, an earl’s daughter would add luster to their reputation.”
“What would be the point of that?”
“She might not be teachable, but they can train her to be a lady, at least.”
There was another long silence as Papa considered that. “An excellent solution. I’ll put them both in a school—I believe there are several in Bath, where my younger sister lives. She’s a spinster and can keep an eye on them.”
Lily’s stomach cramped. They were both going to be sent away? Rose too? Because Lily couldn’t read?
They heard the rustle of stiff bombazine as Miss Glass stood up. “If that is all, I’ll take my leave of you now, my lord. I have my own arrangements to make.”
The two girls hurried upstairs.
“I’m so sorry, Rose,” Lily began as soon as they were out of earshot.
“Don’t be,” Rose said fiercely. “I’d rather be with you at some horrid school than stay here without you. Papa is a selfish pig. No time for girls indeed!”
“It’s not you, it’s me.” Lily swallowed and forced the words out. “I don’t think Papa loves me anymore.”
Rose put her arms around her. “I’m sure deep down he does, darling. It was just a surprise to him, that’s all. Papa likes to imagine that all Rutherfords are perfect.”
But Lily knew better. The way Papa had looked at her, as if she was a, a thing . . .
As they entered the bedchamber she and Rose shared, her gaze flew to her bride-doll, Arabella, sitting on her bed. Arabella had funny eyes—she’d been dropped once and a piece of her carved wooden eye had broken. Mama had painted the eye in again but it hadn’t quite worked. Arabella always looked a bit cross, but Lily loved her anyway.
An embarrassment to the family. No man will want a wife who can’t read.
Half blinded by tears, Lily pulled off the elaborate, lacy dress Mama had made for Arabella, the little veil ringed with tiny beads to look like pearls. The veil ripped as she tugged it off. She threw the clothes on the floor and dumped Arabella naked on the shelf near the window. She was just a doll, a collection of cloth and painted wood, a stupid make-believe thing.
Lily and Rose went to bed early that night. Rose had tried to comfort Lily, but Lily was not to be comforted. Everything was horrid; they were going to be sent away from home, and it was all her fault.
She didn’t sleep. Papa’s words kept churning in her head, over and over.
A gleam of moonlight sliced through a gap in the curtains. The clock in the
