"You first," Tasha said, returning the grin.
Paisley offered, "How about a deal?"
Tasha narrowed her eyes suspiciously but eventually grumbled, "I'm listening."
"You bend over and give me your sweet little ass," Paisley said. Then quickly adding as Tasha tried to interrupt, "Then when I'm done with that fuck hole you call an asshole, you can do whatever you want with my ass. If you're still conscious after coming so fucking hard with my dick up your butt."
Tasha opened her mouth to refuse, but then she paused to think about it. She knew Paisley could be a stubborn as she was, and they could spend all night arguing who should take it up the ass, and honestly Tasha was horny and didn't want to stop having sex with Paisley just because she refused to compromise.
She was the Champ Tasha, and she could take one little ass fucking and still be raring to pound Paisley's pale little booty. Paisley could dish out a great butt fucking, and after what had gone down with Becca Tasha's butt hole was aching for some attention.
Tasha replied, "Fine, but enjoy my ass while you can Paisley, cause you're going to be the one unconscious from a butt fucking, courtesy of the Champ."
"Ah, just shut up and bend over," Paisley teased, slapping Tasha's rump.
Tasha glared at her rival for that, but then she got on all fours and waited. She wasn't waiting that long, Paisley at once retrieving a big strap-on dildo and then returning. Paisley took her time when it came to step into the harness, pulling it up her thighs, securing it around her waist and then finally covering it with lube. She spent most of her time grinning at Tasha, in turn Tasha trying and failing to stare back without blushing as her traitorous asshole was already practically aching for that dildo to be pushed into it.
Paisley briefly considered using the lube on Tasha's bum hole, but there was just no way she could resist burying her face in between those juicy cheeks and licking her tasty prize. She could remember just how good Tasha's little ass tasted, Paisley brought right back to her time in Lesbian Wrestling League when Tasha had been a total bottom, and she had been a total top.
Paisley missed those days. Now at best she butt banging other divas one day while getting her butt banged the next, Paisley vividly remembering how the last time she had given a rim job it was to the fucking Belles before they took turns pounding her poor asshole until it was sore and gaping open. Just like Tasha's back hole was about to be.
Paisley grabbed both of Tasha's ass cheeks, pulled them apart and pulled back a few inches so she could study her prize. The cute little puckered hole which had been virgin only two years ago. Paisley had popped that anal cherry and made this forbidden hole her personal fuck hole and Tasha her bitch.
Tasha might act tough, but her ass would always belong to Paisley. Just as Paisley's ass would always belong to CJ, but CJ was gone from the company and not coming back, so Paisley was free to take what was rightfully hers. Paisley intentionally salivated and then spat onto Tasha's asshole before leaning down to rub it in with her tongue. She then repeated the process a couple of times before settling in to give Tasha a long-drawn-out rim job to prepare this hole for the fucking of a lifetime.
Paisley was going to pound Tasha's ass until she forgot all about her recently submissive tendencies and became the purely dominant butt buster she was always meant to be. Or until Tasha passed out from anal induced orgasms. Whichever came first. Paisley had no intention of ever giving up her asshole to Tasha. It was bad enough she was the Belles' butt slut; no way was she going to let her ass become stretched for anyone else.
The next time Paisley saw those talentless bitches she was going to do to them what she was about to do to Tasha, the English girl finally feeling like her old self as she pushed her tongue into the American girl's asshole. The fact that she got her tongue deep into the Champ's ass was a decent indication that Tasha had been recently sodomized, which made Paisley grin with delight into her rival's butt.
Tasha was normally quite mouthy when she was getting her ass licked, especially now it was a sign of respect from bitches or a form of them begging for a butt fucking. Tasha knew if she allowed herself to say anything, she would end up insulting the other girl, and Paisley could throw it right back in her face by reminding her what she was about to do to her asshole, and Tasha just couldn't take that kind of verbal abuse right now.
Paisley's skilled tongue was reminding her how much fun it was to be a bottom, a big part of Tasha tempted to embrace her old life again. Not as much as when Becca had topped her, but it was still significant. Paisley pulled back and, after briefly sucking her fingers, pushed her index finger into Tasha's asshole. The invasion was hard and fast, Paisley entering her ass as fast as she'd ever entered it before, which made Tasha cry out in pain.
She then cried out in pleasure as her ass quickly relaxed as Paisley began pumping that finger in and out of her butt hole. The pain and the annoyance of the quick penetrated had woken Tasha up from her submissive thoughts and now she went back to trying to keep herself as quiet as possible. Tasha tried her best, doing things like gritting her teeth and digging her nails into the bed. But Paisley was just so skilled at stretching asses and effortlessly made Tasha's asshole, relax and ache for a fucking by something bigger. Fingers just wasn't going to cut
