"Oh my God, you're actually walking around here calling yourself an alpha female, when there's a fucking butt-plug up your ass?" Tasha mocked through her laughter. "What, is that so you can be ready if CJ comes back, or the Belles feel like some English ass?"
"No!" Paisley protested. Then quickly clarifying, "I knew you were probably going to end up ass fucking me, so"
"You wanted to be ready for me? How sweet?" Tasha chuckled.
"No, I was robbing you of the chance of stretching me out," Paisley explained like it was obvious.
Tasha frowned, "Doesn't that just make it easier on me?"
"It gives you less of a chance to stretch my ass, and if anything, it makes it easier on me," Paisley shrugged, before smirking as she looked back at her rival. "At least, that's how it is for me. You and Becca might have a different routine."
Tasha frowned, before smirking, "So, you destroy your own ass, so I couldn't? Oh Paisley, I'm never heard such dumb bottom logic. Especially because you don't think I'm going to stretch you."
Tasha kneeled behind Paisley and grabbed hold of the handle of the plugs sticking out of that pale little behind. Gemma thought Tasha was just going to ram her way inside right from the start, but she chose to tease Paisley a little bit.
Paisley couldn't help but mock her, "You call this stretching? Your barely even teasing me. If that's the best you got Tasha you might as well hand over that strap-on now, because you clearly don't have what it takes to top anyone."
"Oh sweetie, not only am I going to top the hell out of you, but I won't be the only one," Tasha chuckled wickedly, before turning her attention back to Gemma. "Bring me Paisley's favorite dildos. You know, her strap-on, and the one she uses to sodomize herself like the shameless anal loving bottom she truly is."
"But you're already wearing a strap-on?" Gemma frowned in confusion.
"Do as you're told bitch," Tasha ordered firmly. Then once Gemma had obeyed her, she grinned at her, took the handheld dildo and ordered, "Great, I'll take that. Now, strap the other one on, and lay down on your back. Paisley, go ride your girlfriend face to face, with your slutty little asshole."
This caused Paisley to blush, "Wait, what?"
"You heard!" Tasha growled firmly. "Now do it!"
Paisley was about to at least put up a real fight before resisting, and Gemma hoped she would. But instead Paisley lowered her head to show her submission, and then as soon as Gemma was in position climbed on top of her.
Gemma’s once proud girlfriend pulled the butt-plug out of her ass, lined up the stretched out back hole with the other girl's cock and then pushed downwards. The little anal whore even moaned as she penetrated herself on that dick, Paisley barely taking the time to blush and look apologetically down at her bitch before pushing herself further downwards.
Gemma didn't think things could get more embarrassing for them, then Paisley pushed the butt-plug into her mouth and began sucking it clean. No one even asked, she just did it because she wanted a taste of her own ass, and just couldn't resist, even in front of Tasha who would mock her for it.
Paisley moaned like the shameless ass to mouth whore she was while she cleaned that toy. Partly because of dildo, which was slowly sliding into her ass, and then pumping in and out of it after Paisley briefly savored the moment when she was officially sitting on her girlfriend's lap with every single inch of her own strap-on up her butt.
"Fuck me, oh, that just slid in! Oh God Paisley, you're such a whore!" Tasha cackled gleefully. "Oh yeah, you're such a shameless little ass whore. Yeah, go ahead ass whore, ride that cock for me. Ride it with your slutty little asshole for my amusement. Oh, and to get it ready for me to use. Oh yes, oh, ride it! Suck that plug! Oh fuck!"
Paisley didn't think she'd ever been so ashamed of herself. It was bad enough that she was acting like a shameless anal slut, but it was always worse to do it in front of Gemma. There had even been a few times where CJ had used Gemma like this to DP her, but to anally ride a total bottom like her girlfriend was a whole new level of humiliation. Which put a now familiar a look of disappointment on Gemma's face, but this one just seemed even more intense than usual. And why wouldn't it, considering how Paisley was behaving? But she just couldn't help herself. It just felt so good.
Paisley's back door had become pounded so hard and often that there was barely any pain to begin with, and the plug cleaning was because she was a total whore for ass to mouth. Paisley also hoped that it would muffle her moans of pleasure, but Tasha was surprisingly and scarily silent for most of this round of anal sex. Eventually the taunts came it was far too infrequent to truly be effective.
"Oh yeah, bounce that ass! Oh, bounce it on your own strap-on, oh, while your girlfriend is wearing it, oh fuck Paisley, you really have no shame, do you?" Tasha mocked gleefully. "Oh yes, you love it, huh? Love that big fucking dick in your ass? Exposing what a total ass whore you are? Showing your girlfriend what you truly are? Oh yes, that's it Paisley, show your girlfriend just how much you love it in the ass! Show her that you're a total bottom who can't get enough of it up her butt! Oh fuck, show her you're nothing but an anal loving bitch by riding that big dick and getting your little bitch hole nice and ready for
