“Deeper,” she said between gasping breaths. “Stick your tongue deeper inside my asshole.”
With pleasure, I thought to myself as I pressed my face further forward, forcing my tongue deeper inside her.
Natalie got into the act too, reaching back to grab her asscheeks and spreading them wide, allowing me even deeper access to her asshole. I yanked my fingers out of her pussy to give myself a better angle to work with and then dove in with abandon, reaching under her body with my arms to grab ahold of her tits while I squished my face against her flesh as forcefully as I could.
I held my tongue deep inside Natalie’s asshole for a full ten seconds, wiggling it around a bit and loosening it up for what I hoped was to come next.
And sure enough, just seconds after I finally let my tongue slide out of her asshole, she turned her upper body towards me and looked at me with a mischievous grin.
“Now that you got my asshole all nice and wet and loose, what are you going to do with it?” she said.
“I don’t know,” I replied, returning her grin. I stood up so I was towering over her, my cock resting atop her perfect little ass. “What do you want me to do with it?”
“I want you to stick your hard cock in it and fuck my ass until I cum,” Natalie said, her eyes full of need.
“Is that right?” I said, just playing with her at this point.
I love it when Natalie talked dirty to me and I always tried to get as many words out of her as I could, even at the expense of immediate gratification. After all, letting one’s excitement level get too high is a sure sign of a short session. The key lasting longer in bed is to maintain a lid on your excitement, to keep a handle on it, so to speak.
Natalie nodded.
“And what are you going to do for me if I give you what you want?” I said, grinding my hips slowly against her, my cock riding the crack of her ass and my balls pressing against her asshole.
“Anything you want,” she said between deep breaths.
“Anything?” I asked, raising one eyebrow.
“Anything,” she repeated, more desperately this time. “Fuck my ass and I’ll do whatever you want.”
“All right,” I said as I grabbed ahold of my cock and smacked it against her asscheek a couple of times. “But I’m going to hold you to that, okay?”
Biting down on her bottom lip, Natalie nodded.
I stared down at her sexy face, made even more attractive by the desperation painted on it, and slid my cock into her asshole. My excitement level was off the charts, partially because of my cock in Natalie’s asshole, and partially because I had her thinking I was doing her a favor but giving her exactly what I had been seeking all along. It was the best of both worlds.
At first, I didn’t even move. I was so fascinated by the look of my cock planted halfway in her ass all I could do was stare at it. Not to mention the fact that it felt like if I moved even a little bit I was going to cum instantly. Something about the psychological impact of fucking Natalie in the ass had me right at the point of orgasm. I figured it was the taboo as much as the physical sensation that was threatening to spill me over.
Natalie sensed (not to mention, felt) my trepidation. She looked back at me and saw my face and uttered an evil-sounding laugh. “Is my tight little asshole too much for you to handle?” she said, gently taunting me. “Are you going to bust your load without even having the chance to fuck my ass proper?”
I didn’t answer. It was taking all my concentration just to avoid doing exactly what she was talking about. Natalie’s asshole was so tight, and the pressure was so much more intense than vaginal sex—her sphincter muscles seemed to squeeze every part of my cock at the same time, providing constant stimulation—that I wasn’t sure how long I could hold out for. I felt like if I moved at all I was done for.
And then she started slowly moving her ass back against me.
“Holy fuck,” I groaned as she worked my cock deeper and deeper into her asshole.
“Do you like that?” she asked. “Do you like the feel of your cock in my asshole?”
“I fucking love it,” I said.
“It feels good, doesn’t it?” Natalie said. “So tight and tense and nasty.”
This time I just nodded my head. I was afraid to speak.
“Give it to me deeper,” she said. “I want to feel your cock deep in my asshole.”
Figuring I didn’t have much time left anyway, I bit the bullet, pushing my hips forward, forcing my cock further into her asshole.
Natalie let out a little gasp, followed by a low moan of pleasure. “Just like that,” she said softly, mostly to herself. “Fuck that tight asshole with that hard cock of yours.”
My cock was working in and out of her asshole now, moving fairly quickly but not penetrating her too deeply. It was disappearing about halfway in before I was forced to pull it back out but the way things were going that was more than enough.
Natalie had dropped her head to the bed, altering the angle of penetration a bit and giving an even better look at her ass.
“Holy fucking shit,” she said, groaning with every thrust. Her breath was ragged and her voice was high pitched. “Don’t stop, don’t fucking stop. I’m gonna fucking cum!”
