He was married, and had a child. She had to accept that. That was a sacred thing. He was
The idea of it hurt her more than anything else, but she just
If that was the case, then what was the point of her coming back in time? Was it really to find her father, as that priest had said? Was Caleb just the lure to lead her down that path?
Or was her destiny to be with Blake instead? Was that the whole reason she had come back?
Was that fate’s way of winking at her?
On the one hand, since Caleb was taken, there was nothing wrong, she realized, in being with Blake. But a huge part of her still loved Caleb, still longed for him. The idea of being with Blake still, somehow, despite everything, felt disloyal.
Why had it never entered her mind that things could go so wrong? She had imagined that possibly she could never find Caleb. But she had never imagined that something even worse could happen: that she could find him, and that he could be with someone else. And not even remember her. It was the worst thing she could possibly imagine. She should have foreseen it. But if she had, would she have done anything differently?
Dawn was breaking fully on the horizon now, shades of red and orange and pink flooding the sky, lighting up the lagoon and the water. She had been awake all night long, she realized, and now the world was beginning anew again.
She saw the island on the horizon, and knew she would be there shortly.
But a part of her wished she wouldn’t. A part of her wished their boat would just keep going, and fall off the face of the earth.
“Caitlin!”
Caitlin opened her eyes and saw Polly standing over her, shaking her.
Caitlin woke up, disoriented. Had it been her father’s voice? Or Polly’s?
She sat up and looked all about the room, looking for her father. But it was just another dream.
It had been so vivid, like a meeting.
She sat up, rubbing her eyes, and squinted against the harsh sunlight streaking into the room.
Daytime. She tried to remember. When had she fallen asleep? Had she been sleeping all day?
Rose came up and licked her face.
“What time is it?” Caitlin asked, groggily.
“It’s late in the afternoon,” Polly said, “you’ve been sleeping all day. I didn’t want to wake you. I let you sleep as long as I could. But now, most the day’s passed, so I figured it’s ok. You’ve slept enough, right? I’m just dying to talk to you. How did everything go last night? What happened? Why didn’t you come back with me? Did Blake bring you back? How was your time with him?”
As always, Polly fired question after question, barely giving Caitlin a chance to think. She didn’t know which question to answer first.
“I didn’t come back with him,” she said. “I came back alone. I hired a boat to take me back.”
Polly’s eyes opened wide in anger.
“What happened?” Her expression darkened. “If he abandoned you there, I’ll kill him—”
“No, no,” Caitlin said, “it’s nothing like that. He
“Why?” Polly’s expression changed again. “Oh, I see,” she said. “Things didn’t go so well? You don’t like him? Why, what did he say? What happened!?”
“No, it’s nothing like that either,” Caitlin said.
She got up, stretching her legs, needing to breathe a bit, to process it all. She wanted to answer Polly, but she barely knew the answers herself.
“I guess I just…needed time,” she said. “To think it all over, you know? I actually…I…ran into someone else last night…someone I used to know.”
Polly hesitated. “That…Caleb person you were talking about?”
Caitlin looked away, her heart pulling at even the sound of Caleb’s name.
“Yes,” Caitlin answered, finally.
“So? What happened?”
Caitlin thought. What
“Things…I guess…just didn’t turn out as I expected,” Caitlin said.
“So? What about Blake? What’s wrong with him? You guys seemed to dance so well together.”
Caitlin tried to think. Blake was amazing. There was no doubt about that. And her feelings for him—they were very real. Why had it all had to happen at once? She felt so torn, so conflicted. She knew, intellectually, that Caleb was taken, and that it wasn’t healthy to dwell on him anymore. But at the same time, to be with Blake, right now, so fast, at this moment…it just felt too soon.
“There’s nothing wrong with him,” Caitlin said. “I just… I don’t know. I guess I just haven’t figured it all out yet.”
Polly nodded. “I hear you there,” she said. “Guys are impossible.” She sighed. “Anyway, sorry for all the questions. I was just really curious. I missed you. You have a way of growing on people.
Not to mention, it’s almost dinner time. And someone very important wants to see you.”
Caitlin wracked her brain. Who could that possibly be?