parked her unmarked sedan in the church lot up the street, walked a half block to the house, and wondered how many frat boys had used the acronym as a bad pickup line – as in, 'Come on over to my PAD.'
Andie had yet to confirm that the PAD house existed in the 1970s, but from the looks of it, she was betting yes. The unadorned one-story cinder-block construction with low-slung roofline was the typical hurricane-resistant style of the 1960s that only a Florida architect could love. She walked up the sidewalk and rang the bell at the front door. It seemed surprisingly quiet inside. Apparently, even frat boys stopped to recharge their batteries every once in a while.
The door opened, and a muscular young man wearing only nylon jogging shorts and flip-flop sandals greeted her. If Andie had to guess, she'd say he spent more time working on his suntan and his six-pack abs than his studies.
He smiled and said, 'Hey, baby.'
'Hi. Do you live here?'
'Yeah. Wanna see my-'
'Don't say it,' she said. Obnoxious enough, but on some level, she was sort of flattered that he hadn't taken her for the mother of one of his buddies. 'My name's Andie,' she said. 'Andie Henning.
'I'm David. You with a sorority?'
Either David was playing with her, or the darkness was kinder to her thirty-something face than she realized. 'Yeah,' she said, playing along. 'I'm a pledge over at FBI.'
He scrunched his face, as if reciting the entire Greek alphabet in his head, and then it hit him. 'You mean…'
She nodded and flashed her badge. 'Can I come in?'
'Yeah – sure,' he said nervously. 'I guess so.'
He let her inside and closed the door. 'How can I do for you? I mean, what-'
'Relax, okay? You're not in any kind of trouble.'
'I should probably get our president.'
'Is he here?'
'Yeah. But he's kind of – he's with his…'
'He's in his PAD?'
He smiled, which softened some of his nervous edge. 'You know how that is.'
'Look, I'm working on a very old case. It doesn't affect anyone who currently lives here. All I want to know is if you keep any composite photographs of your old fraternity classes around the house.'
'Of course,' he said. 'They're hanging in the chapter room.'
'Great. Can I see them?'
'Well, I don't know.'
'It will take five minutes. You live here, so all I need is your consent.'
'It's just that, we don't really let anyone in the chapter room. Not even pledges. It's only for brothers.'
'Oh, come on. You know as well as I do that there's nothing sacred in there. The only reason you keep it locked is because you don't want anyone looking at those composites and seeing what a bunch of geeks you PADs used to be.'
'Yeah,' he said with a chuckle. 'Those mullet haircuts in the eighties were the best.'
'What about the seventies?' she said, soft-pedaling her real interest. 'The days of big hair and bad mustaches. Or maybe you don't go back that far.'
'Oh, we go back to 1962.'
'Wonderful. I love a place with a sense of history. So what do you say? You and me in the chapter room for five minutes? Or do we have to go knocking on the door of your president's PAD?'
'Well, okay. Follow me.'
He led her down the hall and through the cafeteria. It was after the dinner hour, but some men were still at the tables, eating and talking, while others were actually studying. They looked up with curiosity as Andie and David passed. Andie followed him to the kitchen, which smelled of some food that Andie was quite certain she'd never eaten. The final leg of the journey was down a hallway that was too narrow to walk in any formation but single file. The Greek letters IIAA were painted on a door that more or less blended into the wall, as if someone had made a halfhearted effort to create a secret entrance. It was secured with a combination lock. David made Andie face the other way as he dialed in the code, and then he took her inside and switched on the light.
'This is it?' she said.
She hadn't meant to insult him with her reaction, but had she endured the living hell that fraternity initiations were in the 1970s and earlier, this first look at the secret chapter room would have smacked of the proverbial crock at the end of the rainbow.
'This is it,' he said.
The windowless room had all the charm of an unfinished basement – concrete floor, walls of painted cinder blocks, and shop-style fluorescent lighting suspended from the ceiling. Covering the walls, however, were several dozen framed composite photographs, each with head shots of young men dressed in suits. Andie immediately zeroed in on the composites where the outfit of choice was the powder-blue leisure suit. Andie went straight to them, as she removed her printed photographs from her purse.
David asked, 'You know what year you're looking for?'
The composites were arranged in chronological order in columns of three. 'Right around here,' she said, searching. 'Early to mid-1970s.'
Andie's adrenalin was pumping. Each head shot had the young man's name underneath it, so if her computer- generated photographs matched, she was home-free. Theo's mother would have been fifteen years old in 1968, so she started there, just to be overinclusive. She compared the cameraman's image first, breezing through the late sixties, and slowing down for more careful examination in 1970, 1971, and so on. She went all the way to 1980.
He wasn't there. She went through it again, just in case she'd missed something.
He definitely wasn't there.
She did the same thing with the image of the heckler and the drunk who had started the war of words with Portia in the movie. She checked each composite, photograph by photograph.
They weren't there, either.
At this point, she was well beyond her allotted five minutes. David said, 'Something wrong?'
'I was just so sure that-' She stopped herself and did a double take. 'There's a year missing.'
'What?'
'Nineteen seventy-two. It's not here.'
David took a closer look. 'You're right.'
Andie walked the entire room, checking to see if it had been mounted someplace else, out of chronological order. 'It's not here,' she said. 'Is there another room where it could be?'
'No. I been living here three years. All the old composites are in this room.'
'I need to see 1972,' she said.
'Well, I don't know how to help you. The one you want is the one we don't have. Which is sort of an interesting coincidence.'
Andie noticed something about the wall. The composites weren't all the same size, and they'd hung so long in the same place that a faint shadow on the painted wall matched the outline of their frame. The composites after 1972 didn't match their shadow – which meant they'd been moved. Rearranged. Recently. To make it not so apparent that 1972 was missing.
'It's definitely interesting that it's not here,' she said, the wheels turning in her head. 'But I'd say it's no coincidence.'
'Hey wait a sec,' said David. 'Pi Alpha Delta does have a historian'
'A historian?'
'Yeah. He's with the national office in Columbus, Ohio. Some old fart who doesn't want to let go of his college days.'
'You think he has copies of old composites?'
'He has everything from every chapter in the country. But they'd be little copies. Like yearbook-sized. Would
