'But it couldn't have been me that froze the poor man,' Petra said. 'I wasn't anywhere near the Archive when the attack took place. I was asleep in my rooms!'
'You were on campus,' the man in the flat-brimmed hat clarified evenly, 'which places you in the vicinity of the crime, regardless of your specific location. And being asleep is not what one would tend to call an airtight alibi.'
'Excuse me,' Harry interjected, turning to the stranger. 'I didn't get your name, sir.'
'I haven't given it,' the man replied, still smiling pleasantly. 'I assumed that that was the Chancellor's honor. I'd hate to overstep my bounds.'
'Pardon me,' Franklyn said with a note of impatience in his voice. 'Mr. Potter, this is the honorable Albert Keynes, General Arbiter for the Wizarding Court of the United States. Mr. Keynes, Harry Potter is a representative of the European Ministry of Magic, visiting us in pursuit of his duties as that entity's head Auror.'
'A pleasure,' Keynes nodded smugly, obscuring his face for a moment behind the black brim of his hat.
'I'm impressed that you were able to be here on such short notice,' Harry replied, unsmiling. 'General Arbiter sounds like a rather demanding and important post.'
The man laughed lightly. 'The title sounds more grand than it is, I'm afraid. There are, in fact, many of us, stationed all around the country, performing our given duties to the best of our ability. My station covers only Pennsylvania, but I admit that the metropolitan Pittsburgh and Philadelphia areas do take up most of my time. I was in the vicinity when I received the message from Chancellor Franklyn.'
Harry asked, 'You represent the American Wizarding Court then?' Before the man could answer, however, Chancellor Franklyn spoke up.
'We have a rather more hands-on approach to legal matters in the American magical world, Mr. Potter. A holdover from a time when magical individuals were scattered finely all across the country, making it necessary for the law to go to them, rather than the other way around. Mr. Keynes, in effect,
'Judge, jury, and executioner,' Professor Cloverhoof quipped darkly, buffing his nails on his lapel.
Keynes nodded. 'Crude, but accurate enough, Professor,' he said, and then turned to Harry. 'I am an arbiter, Mr. Potter. My job is to make impartial judgments based on examination of the evidence and interviews of everyone involved in any given case. This is why I have requested that your son join us. I understand that he has observed much of what has taken place in connection with the attack on the Hall of Archives. You need not fear for his involvement. I am trained to be utterly fair and objective.'
'I am glad to hear it,' Harry replied. 'Can we expect a quick end to this matter, then?'
Keynes clucked his tongue. 'The role of the arbiter is simple, Mr. Potter, but we are trained to be exceedingly thorough. This is a particularly difficult case, as it is a matter of Ms. Morganstern's word against that of Mr. Henredon's. Judgments in such cases have been known to take months or even years to reach.'
'But this is just stupid!' James interjected, his face reddening. 'Petra was with Izzy when the Archive was attacked! That proves it wasn't really her that froze Mr. Henredon.'
'Proof is a ticklish concept, my boy,' Keynes said, shaking his head sorrowfully. 'The young lady in question is the defendant's sister, rendering her testimony suspect, at the very least. Further complicating matters, I am given to understand that this is not your first encounter with the law, is it, Ms. Morganstern?'
Petra's expression cooled slightly as she looked at the man in the black hat. 'I don't know what you're talking about.'
'It might have slipped your memory,' Keynes admitted with a nod. 'It was the Muggle police, after all. I understand that such mundane authorities might not command the respect of someone like yourself. As I mentioned, however; we arbiters are very thorough. On the way here, I perused the police report regarding what took place on the occasion of your last day at your grandfather's farm. Granted, I had to read between the lines a bit, but there is no question that the events of that morning resulted in at least one death, and quite possibly two, although the second, I admit, is pure conjecture on my part. Do you remember now, Ms. Morganstern?'
Petra stared at the man, her lips pressed into a thin line. After a moment, she nodded once, curtly.
'This is the first I have heard of these things,' Franklyn said, peering at Petra and then Harry. 'Might I inquire as to why a known criminal was allowed to be offered a position at this school?'
Harry didn't remove his gaze from the man in the black hat. 'Petra is not a known criminal,' he answered evenly. 'The Auror Department conducted an investigation into the events at Morganstern Farm, and there was no indication of foul play. Warren Morganstern took his own life, as even the Muggle police report must show. His wife, Phyllis Morganstern, formerly Blanchefleur, has indeed gone missing, but since she was wanted for questioning regarding the deaths of both her first and second husbands, this is no great surprise.'
Keynes smoothed his robes again as he said, 'Your own investigation notwithstanding, Mr. Potter, these factors must be considered when rendering judgment on this most delicate issue. I will be calling upon many resources and interviewing any number of individuals, both as witnesses and as character references. I may even need to call upon Mr. Morganstern's widow, if, as you say, she is still among us. It may be months before I reach my verdict.'
James didn't like Keynes one bit and felt quite confident that regardless of how long the verdict took to reach, the man would find Petra guilty in the end. 'What will happen to Petra if you decide she's done what Mr. Henredon says?'
Keynes leaned back and laced his fingers over his chest. 'The law is very clear in such cases, unfortunately,' he said with undisguised relish. 'Attempted murder can mean anywhere from twenty years to life in prison. Add to that the use of dark magic, the attack on the Vault of Destinies, and the thievery of a priceless relic in the form of the missing crimson thread—and yes, I do know of these things; as a member of the American Wizarding Court, not much escapes my notice—then it seems inevitable that Ms. Morganstern will spend the rest of her days in Fort Bedlam maximum security wizarding prison. Her sister, Izabella, will become a ward of the state. As a Muggle, it will be up to the Magical Integration Bureau to find her a new home in the non-magical community. She is underage, fortunately, which means that the authorities at the Crystal Mountain will likely move to have her memory Obliviated. This would probably be best for all involved.'
'What kind of awful person are you?' James exclaimed angrily. 'You act like there's nothing you'd rather see!'
'James!' Harry Potter said sternly, placing a hand firmly onto his son's shoulder.
Keynes smiled again at James and tilted his head sadly. 'It is true, young man. There is nothing I prefer to see more than for justice to be done. It is a mistaken kindness to coddle the guilty. Someday I hope you will come to see the truth of that. Although I have my doubts.' He glanced at Harry and sighed. James saw that Keynes' upper lip was sweating lightly.
Petra spoke then, her voice strangely calm. 'What will become of me and Izzy during your investigation?'
Keynes brightened a bit. 'It is customary for the defendant to be handed over to the arbiter in charge of his or her case until such time as a judgment can be carried out. Therefore, from now until I reach my verdict, you shall be in my custody. Your sister, however, will be sent to the wizarding orphanage in Pittsburgh.'
'My sister,' Petra said coolly, 'will be staying with me.'
'I'm afraid you are in no position to make such requests,' Keynes said, his smile widening. 'It is a Mu
