Pleating for Mercy

“Come again?”

“No. Nothing,” I said, but my mind was racing. I bent over, trying to catch my breath, hands on my knees, elbows locked. If this was authentic, then Butch Cassidy really had sent something to Texana and it was probably here somewhere . . . God almighty, the stories were really true. And Meemaw had known the truth all along.

Will put his hand on my back and, like magic, breath filled my lungs again. “You okay, Cassidy?”

I managed a nod as I straightened up. “There’s some family legend, but there was never any proof, but now . . . now . . .” I stopped and regrouped. “But this . . .” I’d let the paper roll into a tight scroll again and clutched it in my hand, afraid it might evaporate if I let go.

He felt my forehead with the back of his hand, then both of my cheeks. “You sure you’re okay? You need to sit down?”

“I’m fine,” I said, batting his hand away. “Look. Look at the date on this.”

“I saw it. 1898.”

“Right. My great-great-grandmother was born in October of 1898.”

The shadow of confusion on his face cleared. “So you think the baby mentioned in the note was your great- great-grandmother?”

The Singer still purred from the workroom. I caught a glimpse of Gracie’s foot. She was back to sorting the buttons from the jars Nell had dropped. I looked up at Will, keeping my voice low, my skin pricking with excitement. “It has to be. It’s addressed to T. That’s got to be Texana Harlow, my great-great-great-grandmother. H was Harry Longabaugh. Etta was his girlfriend.”

“And Frannie?”

I laughed. After a high school research project, I knew almost everything there was to know about Robert LeRoy Parker. “Frannie Porter was a madame in San Antonio. They used her brothel as a rendezvous.”

Will stared at me, riveted. “Family legend. Wait a second. You mean the old outlaw stories about Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid?”

A chill of excitement swept through me. “Butch’s real name was Robert LeRoy Parker and Sundance was Harry Longabaugh.”

Will tapped the rolled-up paper with his finger. “And you think this note was written to your . . . great-great . . . however many greats . . . grandmother, from Butch Cassidy?”

“Yes!” I grabbed his hand, my excited whisper ringing in my ears. “I grew up hearing the stories. Butch Cassidy sent a letter and something else—a trinket—to Texana before he escaped to South America. She never saw him again . . . No one ever found the letter. We never had proof of our family lineage. But this”—I waved the note —“this verifies that it’s all true. He and Texana really did have a baby together.”

“Um, Harlow?” Gracie stood just inside the workroom. She held out her hand, palm up. “I think you should see this.”

“Show-and-tell today,” Will said as we went to see what she held.

It was a ring, the band made out of lustrous platinum. The biggest diamond I’d ever seen sat smack in the center of two rows of smaller diamonds.

Butch Cassidy and Texana were still on my mind. “Butch sent Texana something . . .”

“Hate to burst your bubble, Cassidy,” Will said, holding the ring up to the light, “but this isn’t a hundred and ten, or however many, years old.”

He handed it to me so I could take a closer look. All my wishful thinking didn’t make me right. This ring was shiny and brand-spanking new. “This was in that bag of buttons?” I asked Gracie.

“Yep.”

Why would a brand-new ring be mixed in with Meemaw’s buttons? My mind shot back to the day Nell died, yanking out buried images, rearranging them, and shoving them right back into my consciousness.

Nell had been in the workroom. I’d been too busy telling myself that the customer is always right to worry much about why she’d been back there. What had she been doing that could have unsettled the shelves and broken the button jars? Was she searching for something? But how would she have known there was something hidden there? And of all the jars, would she have picked the right one?

Then, for the second time in a few minutes, I lost my breath. She wasn’t searching for it. “Oh my God, she was hiding the ring!”

The Singer had stopped its steady rhythm. “Who was hiding what?” Mama asked, coming over to us.

Instead of answering, I handed her the note. She scanned it, met my gaze, and just like that, all the color drained from her face. “This is proof,” she whispered.

My eyes welled as I nodded. It was a monumental moment for the Cassidy family, but we were also in the thick of a murder investigation. Mama and I wrapped our arms around each other, savoring the moment for as long as we could, whispering about the discovery, Butch and Texana, and our family history.

Mama wandered off a few moments later, still in a daze about the note. Eventually, my mind drifted back to Meemaw and the ring. She’d never done things the easy way when she was alive. Now that she’d passed, everything was more puzzling.

I thought back to that day in the shop. She must have seen Nell trying to hide the ring. She’d made the leg of the shelf shoot across the room like a bullet, causing the button jars to crash to the ground. By her own orchestration, Will was at the ready to do repairs for me, and now I had a shelf that needed repairing. Meemaw had seen an opportunity to help me find the note from Butch, and she’d taken it.

“The first day Josie and the bridesmaids all came in here, Nell was in the workroom but we were all out here. She paced around, always going off on her own to look at swatches or the lookbook.”

“Lookbook?” Will sounded like we were speaking a foreign language.

“My design book.” I waved the whole train of thought away. “It’s not important. The point is, maybe she was trying to get away from all of us so she could hide this.” I held up the ring like a prize.

Gracie raised her hand like she was in class at school. “Um, I have a question.”

We waited.

“It’s just . . .” She bit one side of her lower lip. “Why would Nell have had your friend Josie’s engagement ring?”

“Wh-what?” Will and I stared at Gracie, slack-jawed. “This isn’t Josie’s—”

I stopped short, caught off guard by her wagging head. “Not now it’s not, but it was. I saw it after your friend got engaged to Holly’s uncle.”

And just like that, I suddenly remembered the day Josie and her bridesmaids had first come into Buttons & Bows and the story about her two rings. The first had been too flashy for her and they’d exchanged it for a simpler setting.

I stared at the sparkling diamond. This was that ring? “But why did Nell have it?” I asked aloud. Two other questions quickly followed in my head. Why had she been trying to hide it? And why, oh why, had she picked my shop to hide it in?

Chapter 39

I’d never fancied myself an amateur sleuth, but a desperate phone call from Josie changed my mind. She said she needed to know what had happened to Nell—for her own peace of mind. Part of me wondered if she was beginning to doubt Nate. With her first engagement ring tucked safely in a little navy velvet jewelry bag sitting in the middle of the cutting table, I was certainly doubtful of his innocence.

“Will you help? Just come to the funeral and . . .” Her voice faded away.

“And see what I can see,” I finished for her.

“Yes.”

“Whoever killed Nell isn’t going to be wearing a sign announcing the fact,” I said, but I was already scanning the notes I’d written in the back of my sketchbook. If I was right and Miriam had been about to name Nate as the killer, I couldn’t let Josie go through with the wedding. The truth needed to come out before she married a murderer.

A number of clues seemed to point to Nate as the killer. Was he guilty of murder, or did the fact that Will trusted him mean I was barking up the wrong tree?