accident.
Walking by one of the docked boats, I nodded to the older man sitting in a deck chair, thumbing through a magazine.
He glanced up as I walked by. “Interested in fishing?”
“No, not really.”
“I know this island like the back of my hand. And the waters. You can ask anybody. I find the fish when no one else can.” He tilted his long-billed cap up on his head, his weathered face smiling.
“I’m sure you’re good.”
“Good? I’m the best.” He stroked his chin. “You got any friends who are looking for a charter-half day, all day, you send ’em to me.”
“You know the area pretty well, right?”
“I do.” He slowly stood up, thrusting his hands into his khaki cargo shorts and twisting his neck as if it were stiff.
“What do you know about Cheeca Lodge?”
“Fishing?”
“I was thinking more about the property.”
“What about it? You know they rebuilt some if it a couple of years ago. Place had a big fire and they had to close up. Some guy tossed a cigarette on the thatched hut bar on New Year’s Eve. Nasty situation. But it’s a fine resort. Fanciest one in this area. Very modern, upscale-”
“Quite a bit of property?”
“Oh, I’d say. Got a golf course, big pool, and lodge. Plus all them bungalows. But it’s a bit pricey.”
“Quite a history.” If the gold wasn’t buried in the ocean, Kriegel said it would be buried somewhere on that property. Where Cheeca Lodge now stood. Hey, it wasn’t the size of the ocean, but still a sizable area to cover.
“Started out the settlers built a two-room schoolhouse and a Methodist Cemetery.”
“So now there’s this fabulous resort-”
“And an old cemetery.”
“The cemetery is still there?” We’d heard that, but I still had a hard time believing it. You don’t have an old cemetery on a resort property.
“Yep, right on the beach beside the swimming pool.”
I wondered if they sold that photo on a postcard. “Swimming next to dead people. Wish you were here.”
“Pinder Cemetery. Used to be called that. Named after Etta Pinder. Died sometime around nineteen fourteen. Now they call it Pioneer Cemetery, but it’s still there. The statue kind of guards it.”
“Statue?”
“The broken-winged angel. I think she was there before the hurricane back in thirty-five. She’s still there, in the middle of that plot of ground.”
I was trying to picture this ancient, deteriorating cemetery and this high-class resort coexisting.
“The resort is-”
“Built up around it.”
“So you’re swimming, fishing, laying out in the sun and there’s this old cemetery right beside you?”
“That’s exactly the way it is.”
“And the bodies are above ground?”
“No. Buried under the ground.”
Again I remembered the letter we’d found. Kriegel was concerned that if you dug straight down, you’d hit water before you could bury anything. His assumption was that the land was almost at sea level.
“Why are you so interested in Cheeca?”
“I want to visit.”
“It’s a private resort. They got a gate with a guard. You’re a guest or a vendor or you don’t get in.”
We’d hurdled bigger obstacles than Cheeca Lodge.
“So, unless I pony up for the room rate, I can’t visit?” I asked the old captain, even though I wasn’t sure he had the answer.
“Well,” he stretched his arms and took a deep breath, “I told you I know this island like the back of this hand-” the gentleman passed his hand in front of my face. “If you pull up to that gate and say you want to visit the Methodist cemetery, they cannot deny you a visit. It’s an official historic site.”
“Really?”
“They don’t want everyone to know that, but the Methodist church still owns the cemetery and anyone, even you, can show up and be admitted. I mean, they do have this very pricey resort and all.”
“What’s your name?”
“Here’s my card.”
I looked down to read it.
Al Amero. Fishing expert and boat captain.
“Mr. Amero, I’m Skip Moore and I will tell anyone who wants to know that you are the finest fishing guide anyone could want.”
He gave me a broad smile and shook my hand.
“I do the best I can, young man.”
“You’ve been a big help.”
“Things are a little slow right now. You might want to get out there and start spreading the news, know what I mean?”
CHAPTER FIFTY
I found him at the pool bar, no surprise.
“Where’s Amy?”
He rolled his eyes. “I stopped by the bar next door and she’s in deep conversation with another guy. Some salesman named Trump from Illinois.” He took a swallow of his draft.
“Yeah?”
“I suggested we split for some private time, but she’s telling me that she’s not done yet and she’s kind of into this guy.”
“She said that?”
“Implied it.”
“Imagine that.”
“Imagine what?”
“She’s married, having an affair, decides to have an affair with you, then finds someone else attractive. I mean, what are the odds?”
“I thought you’d have a little more compassion, amigo.”
“I don’t.”
“I got that.”
He was silent for a moment. I could hear the gears working in his head. Finally, he looked at me.
“Well, it’s obvious that Em isn’t on board with this either. Maybe I should stay away from women who are in a relationship.”
“Or multiple relationships?”
He nodded.
“James, I want to take the metal detector to Cheeca Lodge. Tonight. After dark. There’s some exploring that needs to be done.”
“We can do that.”
“We’ve got to tell them that we are there to see the cemetery.”
“Dude, I’m really not into cemeteries.”
