Harry Turtledove
The Center Cannot Hold
I
Lieutenant Colonel Abner Dowling strode into the offices of the U.S. Army General Staff in Philadelphia, escaping the January snow outside. He was a big, beefy man-unkind people, of whom he'd met altogether too many, would have called him fat-and walked with a determination that made other, younger officers get out of his way, even though his green-gray uniform bore not a trace of the gold-and-black ribbon that marked a General Staff man.
He looked around with more than a little curiosity. He hadn't been in General Staff headquarters for many years-not since before the Great War, in fact. He'd spent the past ten years as adjutant to General George Armstrong Custer, and Custer's relationship with the General Staff had always been… combustible was the first word that came to mind. The first printable word, anyhow.
But Custer was retired now-retired at last, after more than sixty years of service in the Army-and Dowling needed a new assignment. I wonder what they'll give me. What ever it is, it's bound to be a walk in the park after what I've gone through with Custer. Anything this side of standing sentry on the battlements of hell would have seemed a walk in the park after ten years with Custer. The man was unquestionably a hero. Dowling would have been the first to admit it. Nevertheless…
He tried not to think of Custer, which was like trying not to think of a red fish. Then he got lost-General Staff headquarters had expanded a great deal since his last visit. Having to ask his way did take his mind off his former superior. At last, by turning left down a corridor where he had turned right, he made his way to the office of General Hunter Liggett, chief of the General Staff.
Liggett's adjutant was a sharp-looking lieutenant colonel named John Abell. When Dowling walked into the office, the fellow was talking on the telephone: '-the best we can, with the budget the Socialists are willing to let us have.' He looked up and put his hand over the mouthpiece. 'Yes, Lieutenant Colonel? May I help you?'
'I'm Abner Dowling. I have a ten o'clock appointment with General Liggett.' By the clock on the wall, it was still a couple of minutes before ten. Dowling had built in time for things to go wrong. Custer never did anything like that. Custer never figured anything would go wrong. Dowling shook his head. Don't think about Custer.
Lieutenant Colonel Abell nodded. 'Go right in. He's expecting you.' He returned to his interrupted telephone conversation: 'I know what we should be doing, and I know what we are doing. There will be trouble one day, but they're too sure of themselves to believe it.'
However much Dowling wanted to linger and eavesdrop, he went on into General Liggett's inner office and closed the door behind him. Saluting, he said, 'Reporting as ordered, sir.'
Hunter Liggett returned the salute. He was a jowly man in his mid-sixties, with a penetrating stare and a white Kaiser Bill mustache waxed to pointed perfection. 'At ease, Lieutenant Colonel. Sit down. Make yourself comfortable.'
'Thank you, sir.' Dowling eased his bulk down into a chair.
'What are we going to do with you?' Liggett said. It had to be a rhetorical question; the answer surely already lay there on his desk. He went on, 'You've seen a lot these past few years, haven't you? By now, I suspect, you could handle just about anything. Couldn't you, Lieutenant Colonel?'
Dowling didn't like the sound of that. 'I hope so, sir,' he answered cautiously. Maybe he wouldn't get a walk in the park after all. 'Ahh… What have you got in mind?'
'Everyone is very pleased with your performance in Canada,' General Liggett said. 'The assistant secretary of war, Mr. Thomas, spoke highly of you in his report to President Sinclair. He wrote that you did your best to make a difficult and unpleasant situation go more smoothly. Any time a soldier wins praise from the present administration, he must have done very well indeed.'
'Thank you, sir.' Dowling remembered that Liggett had become chief of the General Staff during the present Socialist administration, replacing General Leonard Wood. That made him watch his tongue. 'I'm glad Mr. Thomas was pleased. I didn't really do that much. Mostly, I just sat there and kept my mouth shut.' N. Mattoon Thomas had come up to Winnipeg to force General Custer into retirement. Custer hadn't wanted to go; Custer never wanted to do anything anyone told him to do, and he thoroughly despised the Socialists. But they'd held the high cards, and he hadn't.
'Well, what ever you did say, Mr. Thomas liked it,' Liggett said. 'He wrote of your tact and your discretion and your good sense-said if you were a diplomat instead of a soldier, you'd make a splendid ambassador.' Liggett chuckled. 'Damn me to hell if you're not blushing.'
'I'm flattered, sir.' Dowling was also embarrassed. Like a lot of fat men, he flushed easily, and he knew it.
General Liggett went on, 'And it just so happens that we have a post where a man with such talents would be very useful, very useful indeed.'
'Does it? Do you?' Dowling said, and Liggett gave him a genial nod. Dowling had a fair notion of where such a post might be. Hoping he was wrong, he asked, 'What have you got in mind, sir?'
Sure enough, Liggett said, 'I've had to relieve Colonel Sorenson as military governor of Salt Lake City. He's an able officer, Sorenson is; don't get me wrong. But he turned out to be a little too… unbending for the position. By President Sinclair's orders, we are trying to bring Utah back towards being a normal state in the Union once more. A tactful, diplomatic officer running things in Salt Lake could do us a lot of good there.'
'I… see,' Dowling said slowly. 'The only trouble is, sir, I'm not sure I think Utah ought to be a normal state in the Union once more.' The Mormons in Utah had caused trouble during the Second Mexican War, back at the start of the 1880s-as a result of which, the U.S. Army had landed on them with both feet. Then, in 1915, perhaps aided and abetted by the Confederates and the British from Canada, they'd risen in open rebellion. The Army had had to crush them one town at a time, and had made a peace only in the Tacitean sense of the word, leaving desert behind it.
'Between you and me and the four walls of my office, Lieutenant Colonel, I'm not sure I think so, either,' Liggett answered. 'But the Army doesn't make policy. That's the president's job. All we do is carry it out. And so… would you like to be the next military governor of Salt Lake City?'
Maybe I should have been a nasty son of a bitch when I was working for Custer, Dowling thought. But he said what he had to say: 'Yes, sir.' After a moment, he added, 'If I'm being diplomatic…'
'Yes?' Liggett asked.
'Well, sir, wouldn't you say the good people of Salt Lake City might see it as an insult to them if a full colonel were replaced by a lieutenant colonel?' Dowling said. 'Couldn't it lead them to believe the United States Army finds them less important than it once did?'
Amusement glinted in Liggett's eyes. 'And how do you propose to make sure the good people of Salt Lake City-if there are any-don't find themselves insulted?'
'I can think of a couple of ways, sir,' Dowling replied. 'One would be to appoint somebody who's already a bird colonel as military governor there.'
'Yes, that stands to reason,' Liggett agreed. 'And the other?' He leaned back in his swivel chair, which squeaked. He seemed to be enjoying himself, waiting to hear what Dowling would say.
Dowling had hoped the chief of the General Staff would come out and say it for him. When Liggett didn't, he had to speak for himself: 'The other way, sir, would be to promote me to the appropriate rank.'
'And you think you deserve such a promotion, eh?' Liggett rumbled.
'Yes, sir,' Dowling said boldly. After ten years with Custer, I deserve to be a major general, by God. And if he said no, he knew he'd never be promoted again.
General Liggett shuffled through papers on his desk. Finding the one he wanted, he shoved it, face down, across the polished expanse of mahogany to Dowling. 'This may be of some interest to you, then.'
'Thank you,' Dowling said, wondering if he ought to thank Liggett. He turned the paper over, glanced at it-and
