terror,’ she said later, ‘that we were all praying and waiting anxiously for the arrival of the Germans, as we then knew we would be safe’.26
Fighting their own people, the Bolsheviks could not afford to continue fighting Germany. Over the next two months Michael’s diary would be dominated by the negotiations with the Germans for a separate peace. ‘What a disgrace to Russia!’ he wrote when he first heard of the talks.27 They would stop and start and in the end the peace terms agreed would be worse than the ones first on offer. Signed on March 3 — the Bolsheviks had adopted the Western calendar, February 1, 1918 becoming February 14— the Treaty of Brest-Litovsk ended the war between Russia and Germany, and cleared the way for a civil war. Russians would now concentrate on killing each other.
For the nervous servants at Nikolaevskaya Street, the regret was that the advancing Germans had stopped short of Gatchina. ‘Everyone was in despair,’ wrote Miss Neame. It would quickly prove to be more than justified.
Four days later, at 11 a.m. on Tuesday, March 7, Michael was on his bedroom balcony, overlooking the snow-covered street beyond his garden. It was a beautiful morning, with bright sunshine. Troubled by his ‘damned stomach pains’ he was lying on his couch, beginning his diary for the previous day, noting that he had been playing the guitar in the afternoon. As he started to write: ‘In the evening…’28 he was interrupted by the sight of a group of armed men running up the road towards the house. Minutes later they were on the path, and forcing their way into the house itself.
Michael heard them running up the stairs, and then they were in his bedroom, the officer in charge bursting onto the balcony.29 In his hand he carried an order for the arrest of Michael and Johnson.
The order was signed by Moisei Uritsky, the head of the feared Petrograd Cheka — formally the Extraordinary Commission on the Struggle Against the Counter-Revolution, Speculation and Sabotage — and which was designed as an instrument of terror, with powers which in effect made it a law unto itself.
Miss Neame, cowering downstairs, would never forget Michael’s arrest. This time his protestations were ignored. This time there would be no negotiations, no compromises, no acceptance that he could make his own arrangements for accommodation in Petrograd, no opportunity even to pack a bag. He was pulled from his couch, and pushed out to the stairs with shouts and brandished bayonets. The cries of Natasha and the rest of the household were ignored as they were thrust aside, and Michael and Johnson marched down the path and into the trucks which had driven up to the house.
Watching him go, Miss Neame was struck by the ‘sad look in his eyes —so tired and ill, he was hurt at all the injustice’.30 He would never come home ever again.
Driven to the capital, he was taken to the Smolny, once an exclusive girls’ school, a few streets beyond the Tauride Palace and now Bolshevik headquarters. Michael would quickly find that he was not just under arrest as before — he was a prisoner of the revolution.
A distressed Natasha, quickly packing a suitcase, followed Michael to the capital, catching the train, and spending the night at the home of her friend Maggie Abakanovich on the Moika. Having telephoned Millionnaya Street, she met up with Princess Putyatina next morning and together they walked to the grey-painted Smolny. Passing through the colonnaded entrance, past machine-guns and guards with fixed bayonets, they were given permission to see Michael; they found him in a large room, furnished now with eight beds and a few chairs. He was standing in a window recess, talking to Johnson as armed guards stood around, smoking and laughing loudly. When Natasha walked in, he came quickly over to her and ‘kissed her hand without speaking’.31
As they all sat down in the chairs and began talking quietly, a door opened and Uritsky came in, dressed in a leather jacket, high boots and a grey fur hat. Princess Putyatina remembered ‘a man of under-average height, with a prominent, fleshy nose, large lop-ears, small ferrety eyes with an expression of cold cruelty’. He gave a short nod, pulled up another chair, sat down and lit a cigarette. He refused to answer any questions about the reason for Michael’s imprisonment, and after a few vague promises about improving conditions, he got up and left.
The following day, Thursday, Natasha and Princess Putyatina returned again, but were allowed to see Michael for only thirty minutes. Desperate to do something, Natasha decided to go directly to Lenin, who was somewhere in the same building. ‘Noticing that there was a sentry in front of one of the doors, we presumed that must be his office. Natasha brusquely opened the door without giving the sentry time to bar the way,’ and marched in. Lenin, sitting at his desk, looked up startled, as Natasha firmly closed the door behind her.
The confused sentry outside made no attempt to follow her in, though he did bar the princess from doing so. She collapsed on a bench. ‘I do not know how long I waited, but I do know that I got up several times and paced the corridor nervously’. At last the door opened and Natasha peeped out, beckoning her in. The sentry hesitated, but stepped aside as the princess swept by him.
Natasha was standing in the office on her own. Lenin had disappeared through another door, promising to look into the matter, but ‘saying that it not only depended on him’. After a long wait, the inner door opened and instead of Lenin his friend Bonch-Bruevich walked in, nodded a greeting, and tried to sound reassuring. The question of Michael’s arrest would, he promised, be reviewed later in the day. No, he could not say more. 32
It was all they could get out of him, and with that Natasha and the princess left and walked back into the capital. Was there hope? They could only reassure each other through their tears that there must be.
That evening, as Natasha waited anxiously for news, twenty-four party leaders met at the Smolny, among them Lenin and Joseph Stalin, the man who would one day succeed him. Fearing that Petrograd was too near the German lines, and the counter-revolutionary movement in Finland, the meeting was to finalise the decision to move to the greater safety of Moscow.
One of their last decisions was to decide the fate of the ‘former Grand Duke M. A. Romanov’. Given his prominence, and the potential threat he posed as a rallying point for counter-revolutionaries, not least the monarchists, the meeting was in no doubt that he could not be left behind. The answer was that he was to be exiled ‘until further notice’ to the distant Urals. Johnson was also to be exiled, but ‘shall not be accommodated in the same city’. The arrangements were ‘entrusted to Comrade Uritsky’.33
Next morning, Friday, a protesting Natasha was refused permission to see Michael. With that she and Princess Putyatina hurried away to find Uritsky. It was a very long walk back into the centre of the capital, and down to 2 Gorokhovaya Street at the bottom of the Nevsky Prospekt; the building they were looking for, formerly the offices of the City Governor, beside the Alexander Gardens and opposite the Admiralty, was now the headquarters of the Cheka.
Natasha waited by the steps, and the princess went inside to find Uritsky. He was in his office, and motioned her in, telling her that she had come ‘just at the right time’. Michael, he told her, was to be exiled to Perm, a thousand miles away.
Shocked, the princess hurried out to the waiting Natasha, and broke the news. ‘It was a terrible blow, but she bore it with courage and resignation’.34
Late that night Michael sat down in his prison room at the Smolny and wrote his farewell letter to Natasha.
At 1 a.m. that Saturday, March 11, Michael and Johnson were driven out of the Smolny through the darkened, freezing and snow-covered streets to the dimly-lit and near-deserted Nicholas station. After three shivering hours, with no means of keeping warm, they were marched to the train which would take them into exile and to a fate it was best they could not know.
20. PRISONER OF PERM
IN peacetime the twice-daily standard trains from the capital took two days to reach Perm, and the twice- weekly Siberian express got there in 37 hours. The train on which Michael and Johnson left at 4 a.m. that Saturday
