The peeler slipped from my hand and clattered to the floor.
He dropped down and picked it up. When he stood, he gently cupped my face. “You have ‘watching others’ listed as
My mind spun in a hundred directions. Would we be in Paul’s playroom? How did that work? Would Christine care?
“You have ‘forced nudity around others’ and ‘exhibitionism among friends’ listed as soft limits.” He didn’t move his hand. “I won’t push those limits this weekend. You will remain clothed, and I will not ask you to play in front of anyone.”
We were both silent for several seconds, and his unspoken words rang in my head. A reminder he
He smiled. “And it’s Tuesday, Abby.”
Tuesday. Abby.
He waited until Tuesday to bring the weekend up because he wanted my honest opinion. I understood immediately why he hadn’t asked me on Sunday, not when I’d very nearly called him
“Wow,” I said. “When I marked that down, I guess I wasn’t thinking anything would happen this fast.”
“Do you not want to go?”
I tilted my head. “No. It’s not that. I just have to think a minute.”
I went back to the vegetables, making sure everything was ready for when the rice came out. He walked to the refrigerator and pulled out the tuna and eel—giving me space, allowing me time to think through my answer.
“Have you ever had sex with Christine?” I asked.
“What?” He looked up from unwrapping the fish. “No.”
“Have you ever played with her?” I asked, rethinking my question.
“No.” He took a knife and cut the tuna into strips. “I have watched them before.”
“That would have been my next question.”
“I thought as much.”
I separated the vegetables into little piles—my pile and his—and thought more about his question. Would it be odd to sit down for dinner with a couple after seeing them in a playroom?
“Abby?” he asked, washing his hands. “Paul and Christine are highly regarded in the community, and they’re quite used to dealing with jitters. It may be slightly uncomfortable at times, but this is something they’re both used to. He told me Christine gets turned on by being watched.”
I thought about that. Remembered back to when Nathaniel and I had sex at the Super Bowl. There was still an undercurrent of excitement that ran through me whenever I thought about it.
“Christine would be a good person for you to talk with,” he said. “She would understand and help you with any questions you have but aren’t comfortable talking to me about.” He walked to me and stroked my cheekbone. His expressive eyes betrayed the even tone of his voice. “And she married her dominant.”
Would Nathaniel and I one day be at that point? Would he want that? Would I?
I thought about how close I was to Felicia and pondered how nice it would be to have a girlfriend in the lifestyle I could talk with. Then I thought about my checklists and the items I had marked as soft limits. Would I be willing to modify my checklist afterward? Would watching one of my soft limits play out before me change my interest?
“Let’s go.” I smiled. “Let’s do it.”
I thought he would ask me if I was sure, but instead he kissed me softly. “I’ll call Paul tomorrow.”
After dinner, we took Apollo outside to play a bit of catch. He knew what we were going to do and ran out before us, practically dancing in his excitement.
Nathaniel and I walked outside, our arms brushing every so often. He threw a tennis ball to Apollo when we’d made it out to the cherry trees. Apollo growled low in his throat and took off at a run to catch the ball and bring it back for another round.
I giggled when Apollo nearly tripped over his feet as he turned back to us. He looked as if he were laughing when he returned.
“What a ham,” I said.
“He likes to show off for you,” Nathaniel said, throwing the ball again.
The three of us played fetch for a few more minutes. The weather had finally turned warm, and even though it was still more than a week away, it looked as if Felicia and Jackson would have nice weather for the wedding. I wasn’t sure how Felicia did it; I’d never be able to handle planning an outdoor wedding. Too much uncertainty.
“When does the lease on your apartment run out?” he asked.
His question rattled me, and I messed up on my throw of the ball. Fortunately, Apollo didn’t care.
“Mid-June,” I said.
“Are you going to renew?”
“I haven’t decided yet.”
I heard him take a deep breath from where he stood beside me.
“I’ve been thinking,” he said.
I steeled myself. Was he going to ask me to move in with him? What would I say? How would I answer? I threw the ball to Apollo again, and I noticed my hand shook.
“Will it bother you to be alone once Felicia’s not next door?” he asked.
I’d asked myself that same question numerous times. “I don’t know.”
“I’m not sure I like you being there by yourself.”
“Because Felicia offered me so much protection? I am a big girl, you know.”
“I know you are. I just worry.”
“Maybe I’ll get a dog or take Apollo with me or get a really big can of Mace or—”
“Or you could move in with me.”
My breath caught, and I shifted my gaze to follow Apollo. “I suppose that depends.”
“On?”
“On if you want me to move in because you want me or because you’re worried about me.”
His eyes were soft and pleading. “You doubt I want you?”
“It didn’t seem like that was your primary motive in asking me to move in.”
“I messed up,” he confessed. “Let me try this a different way.” He took my face in his hands and lifted my chin so our gazes met. “I want you in the morning when your hair’s a mess and you’re grumpy until you’ve had your coffee. I want you in the evening so you can tell me about your day while we make dinner together. And I want you at night because I love nothing more than to fall asleep knowing you’re closer than my next breath.” His lips lightly brushed mine. “Will you move in with me?”
My mouth was dry. I couldn’t speak.
“Abby?”
“Yes.”
Smiling once more, he took my hand and we walked back inside the house.
Hours later, I stood in his room, watching as he took Apollo out one last time. Through the large picture window in his bedroom, I could see Apollo roaming the yard, nose to the grass. Nathaniel stood at his side, looking up at the moon, deep in thought.
I scanned the expanse of his yard, following the long path of his driveway until trees obscured it. It didn’t seem real that in about three weeks, this would be my new home. This house. This yard. This room.
“What has you thinking so intently?”
My eyes flew back to the yard. I’d missed seeing and hearing Nathaniel return to the house. I turned to face him.
He still wore his suit pants from work and, though he’d taken off his tie, he hadn’t changed out of his white
