even sit on the nest together, side by side or one partially covering the other. Both females also lay eggs: as a result, their nests have SUPERNORMAL CLUTCHES of 9—12 eggs, twice the number in most nests belonging to heterosexual pairs. If their nest is robbed by predators, the pair will dutifully build a second one (often in a much higher location, to make it inaccessible to most ground predators) and begin laying eggs again (as do male-female pairs when they lose a nest). However, all of the eggs they lay are typically infertile since neither female has mated with a male, and the pair usually abandons the nest after the eggs have failed to hatch. Blue Tit female pairs are unlike most homosexual pairs in birds because only one female lays eggs. As a result, nests belonging to such pairs contain not supernormal clutches, but exceptionally
In Eastern Bluebirds, two males sometimes associate with one another in what appears to be a homosexual pair-bond: they travel exclusively in each other’s company (perhaps even spending the winter together), jointly inspect nest sites during the early spring, and court one another. The latter activity involves COURTSHIP- FEEDING—a behavior also seen in heterosexual pairs—in which one male offers a symbolic food gift, such as a cutworm, to the other male, often preceded by a distinctive call. Paired males might be related to each other (father-son or brothers). Occasionally, a female who has lost her heterosexual mate is joined by another female, who helps coparent her offspring. The two birds take turns feeding the youngsters and may also be assisted by one or more of their young from a previous brood.
Nonreproductive and Alternative Heterosexualities
Approximately 17 percent of all sexual activity in opposite-sex pairs of Blue Tits occurs outside the female’s fertile period. Male Eastern Bluebirds also sometimes try to copulate when females are nonfertile, such as during incubation or after the breeding season is over. Other nonprocreative matings involve occasional interspecies encounters: juvenile Eastern Bluebirds have been observed being mounted by great crested flycatchers (
Several other alternative parenting arrangements occur in these species. Red-backed Shrike youngsters sometimes move to adjacent territories where they are adopted by other families, and a few nonbreeding birds of both sexes help feed chicks belonging to other pairs (sometimes even assuming full responsibility for them later on). “Helper” males such as these may even replace the biological father as a model for song-learning by the youngsters. In addition, late-breeding Red-backed Shrikes sometimes become single parents when their mate deserts them; occasionally two such birds and their offspring join together to form a “blended family.” At least 15 percent of Eastern Bluebird mothers in some populations raise unrelated youngsters when outside females lay eggs in their nest. The divorce rate for Blue Tits varies considerably, from 8—85 percent (depending on the population); in addition, about a third of females and up to 20 percent of all males in some areas form polygamous trios (or occasionally quartets). Other more complex family arrangements also occur: one female Blue Tit was part of a polygamous trio with another female and a male; she also copulated promiscuously with a second male, eventually forming a new polygamous bond with both him and yet a third male, all of whom helped care for the young! Overall, however, more than 85 percent of Blue Tits never successfully breed, and about a third of all parents never have grandchildren. Red-backed Shrike parents occasionally cannibalize their own young or eggs.
Other Species
Some male Pied Flycatchers (
Alsop, F. J., III (1971) “Great Crested Flycatcher Observed Copulating with an Immature Eastern Bluebird.”
*Ashby, E. (1958) “Incidents of Bird Life [report on Red-backed Shrikes].”
Birkhead, T. R., and A. P. Moller (1992)
*Blakey, J. K. (1996) “Nest-Sharing by Female Blue Tits.” British Birds 89:279-80.
*Cramp, S., and C. M. Perrins, eds. (1993) “Red-backed Shrike (
Dhondt, A. A. (1989) “Blue Tit.” In I. Newton, ed.,
———(1987) “Reproduction and Survival of Polygynous and Monogamous Blue Tit
Dhondt, A. A., and F. Adriaensen (1994) “Causes and Effects of Divorce in the Blue Tit Parus caeruleus.”
Fornasari, L., L. Bottoni, N. Sacchi, and R. Massa (1994) “Home-Range Overlapping and Socio-Sexual Relationships in the Red-backed Shrike
Gowaty, P. A., and W. C. Bridges (1991) “Behavioral, Demographic, and Environmental Correlates of Extrapair Fertilizations in Eastern Bluebirds,
Gowaty, P. A., and A. A. Karlin (1984) “Multiple Maternity and Paternity in Single Broods of Apparently Monogamous Eastern Bluebirds (
Hartshorne, J. M. (1962) “Behavior of the Eastern Bluebird at the Nest.”
Herremans, M. (1997) “Habitat Segregation of Male and Female Red-backed Shrikes